Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd, gedesisteerd tienermeisje — autistisch, masculien, als vrouw geboren — in een Oost-Europees land met strenge toegangscontrole. Ik identificeerde me vanaf mijn 12e als trans, stapte ongeveer een jaar geleden uit een transgroep en brak ongeveer 6 maanden geleden het laatste contact met die mensen af, waarna mijn dysforie verdween — en daarna deels terugkwam. Ik heb nooit hormonen genomen of een operatie gehad; mijn transitie was volledig sociaal en 'in mijn hoofd', en ik heb haar verworpen omdat ik biologisch een man wil zijn, niet een transman. Mijn toenmalige beste vriend (een volwassen FTM) reageerde vijandig toen ik zei dat ik niet trans was, en een andere vriend probeerde me terug te bekeren nadat ik gedesisteerd was. Nu probeer ik te leven met terugkerende dysforie die 'voelt als doodgaan' als ze wordt getriggerd, zonder dat er zelfbeschadiging of suïcidaal gedrag is vastgelegd.
Volledig verhaal
I am a teenage girl living in a former Soviet country in eastern Europe, near Russia, far from the US and UK, where transition is heavily gatekept — you must be 18, diagnosed as trans, and it can take up to 2 years, with no self-ID and no informed-consent model. I am autistic and, by my own description, "not really functional in real life."
I first heard about trans people in general at age 11, and at age 12 I discovered that transitioning was a thing — that was also when I got into what I now call "the trans cult." A year ago (so around age 14, given I was 15 when my then-best friend reacted badly to my coming out as cis) I got out of that group. When the group went quiet and I filled my life with other things, my dysphoria disappeared completely. I later realized the "dysphoria" had largely come from hanging out with trans people constantly. I cut off my last connection with those people about 6 months before mid-2022 and said I was happy.
But then the dysphoria came back — "kinda." I don't even know if it qualifies as dysphoria. I want to be a biological male; being a trans man wouldn't be enough, because I'm too aware of my sex. That's precisely why I won't transition: a trans man body would be worse than my female one. I explicitly reject the usual explanations people offer: I'm not gay, I have no sexual trauma, I wasn't bullied, and I didn't grow up under strict gender roles. I say none of those reasons are true for me. What I describe instead is an obsession with male physiques — "I'm so interested in and obsessed with men (nothing sexual) that I want to be one desperately."
I hate being female because of the biology and because of feminists. I describe having painful, heavy periods — "having to bleed every month until I pass out from low hemoglobin." I resent how feminists portray women either as victims who must be protected or as "total crackheads." My desire to be male has nothing to do with gender roles: even if every gender role were burned to the ground, I'd still want to be male. It's about the body. The only reason I can live with a female body is that I can't have a male one, and I'm definitely not going to have a trans man one. I also note my body has too many physical issues for me to ever be perceived as male even with full transition.
I describe myself as a masculine girl and I hate the term "GNC" (gender non-conforming) — "I'm a masculine girl and I hate the term 'GNC'." I wish I were a normal girl or boy rather than what I call a "messed up piece of shit," and I clarify I haven't been shamed for being masculine. I know I am female but don't see or count myself as one: when dressed, I see a male; shirtless, I still see male despite having breasts; only fully naked do I see female, because then I see "the main part of my sex." When women's rights are discussed, or when Roe v. Wade was overturned, my reaction is "doesn't affect me, I'm not female." When I imagine myself in third person, I see someone who looks somewhat like me but better and male.
Because everyone pushes me toward trans organizations for "it's totally okay to be trans uwu" lectures, which I don't want, I developed a coping mechanism: a male in my head who shows his body whenever the dysphoria triggers. Every time it triggers it feels like death.
I desisted socially without changing my appearance at all — I had never changed it when I started identifying as trans; "It was all in my head." I did my social transition with clothing and short hair. My voice is sometimes low, sometimes high, but it doesn't matter because the people who think I'm a boy are mostly strangers; one of my classmates told me my voice gave me away. My native language has no gendered pronouns, so I only use male pronouns online and have no real-life experience of them.
I posted a song I translated from my native language in which the "you" is the trans identity — lines about wasted years, carrying all of its stuff out, forgiveness, and seeing it recede in the rear-view mirror's dust cloud. I also shared screenshots of how my then-best friend (ftm, an adult while I was 15 at the time) reacted when I said I'm not trans, which got a lot of attention; I read their attitude as caring about me only as long as I was useful — "They only care about you as long as you're useful to them (identify as trans, support the narrative)." When I desisted, my closest friend at the time tried to convert me back to being trans.
I've never received sexual attention, so I don't know what that feels like. I don't believe in God; religion isn't important in my country. I've shared an article about hormone side effects and argued that the concept of "gender" is too broad and implies something called gender exists. I think transition helps those who transition due to genuine gender dysphoria but not those who transition due to social pressure. I have no recorded surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers — my account describes social identification only, and I explicitly say I won't transition. I have not described any self-harm or suicidal behavior, though I say the dysphoria "feels like death" when it triggers. My current status: I identify as a detransitioned/desisted girl, a masculine female, and I'm trying to live with the returning distress.