Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een vrouw die als kind genderdysforie ervoer maar nooit is getransitioneerd, en ik ben nu moeder en criticus van de huidige genderbevestigende zorgbenaderingen, vooral voor minderjarigen. Ik geloof dat intensieve therapie altijd aan hormonen of operaties vooraf moet gaan, en ik verzet me online actief tegen mensen die transitie overwegen voordat ze onderliggende problemen als lichaamsdysmorfie, eetstoornissen en autisme hebben aangepakt. Ik ben zeer sceptisch over door activisten geproduceerd onderzoek naar transkwesties en over hoe gemakkelijk sommige zorgverleners hormonen voorschrijven. Ik ben nooit getransitioneerd, dus ik ben niet gedetransitioneerd, maar ik beschouw mezelf als bondgenoot van detransitioners en voorvechter van voorzichtiger, therapie-eerst-benaderingen van genderleed.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up struggling with gender dysphoria as a child, and looking back I can only imagine how much more screwed up I would be if I had been a kid growing up in today's climate around these issues. I never pursued transition myself, but that early experience of dysphoria shapes how I think about these questions now.
I'm married and have children. Getting pregnant was a long, difficult journey for me — it took 10 years to get pregnant and keep a pregnancy to term. I had been on birth control for 7 years, including Depo, which worked well for preventing pregnancy but messed up my body's cycles badly when we actually wanted a family. What finally worked for me was a combination of things: I lost 60 pounds on the keto diet, started working out four days a week (beginning with bike rides on my e-bike), did things for myself and my partner like cooking and planning outings, and saw a counselor who helped me work through a lot of emotional issues I had. It wasn't any single thing, but the combination of it all.
Female reproductive cancer runs in my family, and I've been frustrated that all the doctors will do for me is offer birth control and tell me I might want more kids — when in reality I don't want my reproductive organs to kill me.
I have a sister-in-law who works at a clinic that I believe heavily pushes kids, as young as 8 or 10, into hormones and surgery. When my husband and I said we wanted kids to go to therapy first rather than start hormones, she accused us of being transphobic and hateful, telling us 'You just don't care about trans kids, and they are so happy when they get to go on hormones right away.' That disgusted me and made me seriously reconsider our relationship with her. I wanted to distance my own kids from her for fear of her confusing them. She buys into pretty much what the media tells her and won't allow anyone to question it, even when she's wrong. She believes you can just stop taking cross-sex hormones and everything goes back to normal, and that cross-sex hormones are 100% natural and cause no damage. I find people like her frustrating to be around — I feel like I can't talk about these topics without becoming 'evil' somehow for daring to disagree.
I believe intense therapy should be the start for people experiencing gender distress, not hormones or affirming care. When I've interacted with people online considering transition, I've tried to push them toward addressing underlying issues first. In one case I noticed from someone's post history that they might be struggling with an eating disorder alongside gender issues, and I told them they needed to be working with a psychotherapist about body dysmorphia before taking things that could permanently damage their body. I've also raised concerns about autism — telling someone that knowing you're autistic and continuing to develop coping mechanisms are two different things, and that it sounded like they'd stopped learning to cope and started looking for easy outs. I've encouraged people to seek second opinions from professionals who will push back and dig, to be honest with those professionals, and to deep-dive into what HRT actually does to the body and the long-term health risks. I've noted that a lot of people conflate being trans with other underlying mental health issues, and that it's important to find the root cause of distress rather than slapping on an easy label. At the same time, I acknowledge that adults can choose for themselves — I just want it to be a fully informed decision, not one made emotionally.
I'm highly skeptical of research produced by activist organizations. When I saw a statistic cited from the National Center for Transgender Equality, I pointed out that NCTE was founded by trans activists, so any study they conduct is biased, and I shared their own overview describing internal turmoil and staff walkouts to argue the organization wasn't credible. More broadly, I'm skeptical of survey-based research because of the potential for flawed methodology and bias in how data is collected. I've cited work on misleading statistics, including a 2009 survey by Dr. Daniele Fanelli finding that 33.7% of scientists admitted to questionable research practices, to make the point that who conducts a study and how the data is gathered matters enormously.
I'm also critical of how easily hormones are prescribed. I know of a lady in my town who only needs one appointment before she prescribes hormone replacement therapy to anyone who comes in self-diagnosed, while adults with actual hormone imbalance issues have to wade through multiple appointments and blood panels before getting prescribed anything. That double standard frustrates me.
On broader social questions, I've expressed the view that men don't have to fight like women do in society, and that women are the ones pushed to be accepting and to change — oddly enough by groups of men.
I don't identify as detransitioned since I never transitioned, but I consider myself an ally to detransitioners and a critic of the current approach to gender medicine, particularly for minors. My core position is that therapy should come first, that underlying mental health issues need to be thoroughly explored before any medical intervention, and that informed consent needs to be genuinely informed.