Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee — ik ben een vrouw die nooit is getransitioneerd; ik post op detrans- en gender-kritische fora om te pleiten tegen vroege medische transitie en om kennis over PCOS/hormonen te delen. Ik was een ongelukkig jongensachtig meisje tijdens de puberteit, maar kwam rond mijn zestiende tot vrede met vrouw zijn, en ik heb nooit als trans geïdentificeerd. Ik heb PCOS met hoge testosteron, haaruitval en gezichtsbeharing, en ik gebruik vrij verkrijgbare HRT plus DHT-blokkers. Ik ben sterk tegen het geven van hormonen of operaties aan minderjarigen en geloof dat er een grote golf van spijt aankomt, terwijl ik goed geëvalueerde transities van volwassenen steun.
Volledig verhaal
I am a woman, born female, and I have never identified as trans — I have been posting on detransition and gender-critical forums to argue against early medical transition and to share what I know about hormones from my own health problems. I was a tomboy as a child, and when puberty started I got 'really freaked out by the way the boys acted towards me' — it felt like I was kicked out of my peer group for no reason, and between the physical changes and male sexual attention I was 'very unhappy with being a girl for a while.' I didn't come to terms with it until I was about sixteen, when I realised straight males 'had other uses' and figured out how to fit into my new look.
I have PCOS (polycystic ovary syndrome), which gives me high testosterone, hair loss at the hairline and crown, and facial hair growth. I started over-the-counter HRT (Life-flo) plus DHT-blocking supplements a couple of months before mid-2019, and I saw serious regrowth around my hairline and crown. I take a beta-sitosterol pill daily, I used to drink mint tea for it, and I've read that peppermint stops testosterone converting to DHT effectively; I've also tried cutting carbs to help with facial hair and weight gain. I also collapsed in the street because of low progesterone levels, which is why I defend HRT for women — I point out that all-cause mortality for women on HRT is the same as for those off it, with slightly higher breast cancer and clot risk and slightly lower cardiovascular risk.
I began researching trans-related data in 2018 and was 'horrified at the sway the activists have over how the medical profession are dealing with this now.' I argue that a thorough psych evaluation, therapy, and a fully adult mind should be required before anything is done, because the brain doesn't finish developing until the mid-twenties. I believe 80% plus of kids stop identifying as the opposite sex if you leave them alone, and I've told a young person on HRT since fourteen that stopping the meds and 'going with your biology would probably be better for your health and finances in the long run,' while also suggesting they test-drive presenting as a feminine gay man in a place where nobody knows them. I have advised another detransitioning person to sue their doctors, saying the publicity might stop other teenagers being fast-tracked 'into this kind of hell,' and noting you can't legally get a tattoo until eighteen but it's considered fine to remove genitals and take hormones.
I engage heavily with the research: I cite studies showing that the present data do not support the notion that brains of male-to-female transsexuals are feminised, and a 2017 structural-connections study finding that after controlling for sexual orientation the transgender groups showed sex-typical values, with the exception only in androphilic trans women. I use Blanchard's typology and frequently diagnose other posters with autogynephilia, telling one person their feelings were 'textbook autogynephilia' and 'based around sex and not your sense of self identity.' I also argue from UK crime statistics that trans women offend at the same rate as men, that about 1 in 500 killers in the UK over 2007–2017 were trans women (matching the estimated 1/500 trans population), and that being more likely to kill than be killed is not a female behavioural trait. I'm sceptical of the 2% detransition figure, pointing out it only covers people who had five to ten years of therapy and surgery, and that clinics only followed up patients still attending — one doctor's estimate was that about a third of patients are out of sight.
On the other hand, I knew a genuinely trans person from the 1980s: a boy I'd known since starting school who was 'always super girly,' transitioned about ten years later in his late twenties, and whom I was happy for because he barely passed as a male. I am not averse to transitioning fully adult people who have been through proper evaluations. I get called a TERF whenever I raise overenthusiastic medical interventions in teens, trans regret, or neuroscience objections on /r/ukpolitics, and people there 'literally do not believe any meaningful number regret transitioning.' I expect a wave of regret to hit the media when twenty-somethings who had life-altering surgery and mid-teens hormone treatment come forward, and I believe it's being suppressed right now.