Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in a family that, as far as I can tell, was reasonably close — I was terrified of telling my parents when I decided to detransition, but in the end my family immediately embraced me back as a woman because that is how they knew me first, and I am actually closer than ever with my dad now than I was before. I developed young and had very large breasts, and I felt insanely gross and uncomfortable about them — sensory-wise with how my clothes fit and with how people looked at me. From the second my breasts developed when I was 12, adult men at the grocery store were commenting on them, and I felt sexualized from preteen years onward, alongside shame and pressure about not measuring up to the ideal of femininity in my peers' eyes. I now describe my FTM transition as "retiring from womanhood": I didn't want to have to do all the work of existing as a woman, and being a boy seemed easier.
I had known mental illness — major depression and anxiety — and I was overweight and depressed. I thought I was not a good enough female, ugly, fat, depressed, with poor self-care, and I thought it would be simpler to be a man because I could throw on tarp-like clothing and be unkempt. Transitioning to male was like a way of giving up, because it is more socially acceptable to be a fat unkempt man than a fat unkempt woman. I had a lot of internalized misogyny, and gender transition was the thing I learned about first. I also had a lot of pent-up anger and a tendency to rebel and go against the grain.
Medical transition was framed as a last resort for my depression and suicidal ideation at age 16 — I don't know how anything can be a last resort at 16. I started testosterone at 16 and was on it for 3-4 years. I had top surgery at 16. When I was 16 I knew a trans guy of about 20 who was on T and who a few months later came to tell me he was detransitioning and that I should think harder about what I was doing — the first trans person I ever met, more than 15 years ago. I wish I had listened to that omen. I also recall being automatically doled off to a "mentor" who victimized me, and I have wondered how many others experienced sexual abuse or inappropriate behavior from adult trans mentors.
I had to stop T when my lab work came back showing polycythemia, and I was at risk of a stroke or heart attack at the age of 25. Years later, a different trans-affirming doctor scoffed at that and said polycythemia is normal for trans men and I could just donate blood. Nobody is looking out for you in this world but yourself. Nobody told me when I started T at 16 that I would be on the verge of osteoporosis at 30, or that I would develop high blood pressure. My period came back within about 3 months of stopping T.
After stopping T I lived as a male for years, identifying as trans, until more time passed. As my body reverted to being feminine I realized I secretly liked it and had no desire to ever take T again. I reached a crossroads where I had to acknowledge I didn't pass as a man anymore, and I could either live in an odd non-binary zone or change paths. I tried to identify as non-binary but only felt non-binary because that was how people saw me — as a question mark. I developed a fear of leaving my apartment, even to take out the trash, and would come home and cry after running errands. I had to make the leap. Changing paths was the best decision.
I started doubting my transition a few years prior but found no resources or community and felt like I was the only one; finding this community helped me take the leap back. I legally changed my name back to my birth name and it feels comfortable to be referred to by it. I have been off T for something like 8 years now. My voice has lightened with time but is still deep for a woman; I can lift it into a head voice, and when I am tired, grumpy, or depressed my voice goes more monotone and reads as more male, while a cheerful mood brings out a more female cadence. I am read as female and called ma'am pretty much always, though I still have to adjust internally to believe people aren't secretly questioning my gender. Nobody has ever commented to me about my chest; I think it is more me feeling self-conscious.
I still have minimal breast tissue that is hard to distinguish from my chest wall, which makes cyclical discomfort alarming to me. I was prescribed birth control but never picked it up because I am scared of messing with my hormones anymore; I am trying to accept my cycle and using evening primrose oil. I cannot do laser hair removal for facial hair left from T, and waxing is distressing because the hairs must grow long enough to grip, meaning visible facial hair as a woman. I have had to deal with the attitude — from doctors, friends, and family — that I had "already damaged" my breasts with binding, which fed the belief that they were already ruined so I might as well get rid of them; I wish I had fought that distorted belief more and maybe pursued therapy and a breast reduction instead.
On relationships and identity: I am attracted to men and want to attract men, but I am a tomboy and fluid in my presentation and worry about finding a man when I can never consistently perform femininity. I have realized I am not as masculine as I wanted to be — rather, I don't perform femininity well; I am still quite feminine in presence and demeanor. Living as a man made it painfully clear I lacked masculinity. The only men I attracted as an FTM were toxic men who could sniff out my insecurities, and I feel my prospects are better now dating as a detrans woman. I have a complex about my gender being questioned and have had to work on releasing resentment toward myself. I would like to become a therapist someday, but right now I have a lot of my own healing to do.
I am critical of how transition is currently offered to young people: I think all medication should be safeguarded and that calling it "gatekeeping" is a cop-out, that minors can't consent to cosmetic surgery or sex changes if they can't consent to sex, and that targeting parents following doctors' orders is the wrong target — the clinics should be investigated. I think gender dysphoria can only truly be handled holistically, in the cognitive and emotional realm, and that medicalization is not the only way to live with dysphoria. I don't recommend gender therapists; the ones I tried gave me "bullshiter vibes" even when I was identifying as trans, and I suggest finding a regular, well-qualified therapist. I have been told people in my life assume I am 100% supportive of all of it even after seeing me detransition, and it feels like they want to tell me what I think; I have chosen to be as apathetic as possible and not engage. I find the constant demand that detrans people add disclaimers that they still support trans people exhausting.