Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw van geboorte die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, maar tot de puberteit kinderdysforie had, waaronder het smeken aan mijn ouders op mijn 7e om te zeggen dat ik een jongen was. Vroeger steunde ik transactivisme, maar ik „peakte” na het lezen van deze subreddit en bekritiseer nu het huidige informed-consent-model, de nadruk op hormonen en fetisjgedreven transitie, mede op basis van een FtM-vriend wiens dysforie als volwassene begon met opwinding door cosplay. Ik begrijp het concept genderidentiteit niet, beschouw mezelf nog steeds als jongensachtig en haat het niet om vrouw te zijn — alleen hoe ik daarom behandeld word. Ik heb geen medische ingrepen ondergaan en meld geen operaties, hormonen of doorlopende medische behoeften.
Volledig verhaal
I never transitioned — I'm a natal female who never took testosterone — but I ended up on this subreddit because I used to be one of the people supporting all trans activism, or at least I tried to ignore the things I was skeptical about, thinking that was "transphobic." I remember checking this sub first and expecting some TERFy, hateful stuff, for reasons such as detransition being presented as something extremely rare. Instead I peaked.
As a child I had real dysphoria. Around age 7 I used to beg my parents to tell me I was a boy. I insisted on using boys' restrooms and I even attempted peeing like them. But I kind of grew out of it during puberty. I'm still very tomboyish though. I also had childhood dysphoria until puberty, and I can relate to people who hate how they are treated on the basis of being female even if I don't necessarily hate being female itself.
I don't really understand the concept of gender identity. I'm not really sexed either, as I don't focus on my gender at all. What's funnier, I can be both female or male in my dreams from time to time. I'm flat chested myself and I always joke about my swimsuit bras being half-full because they're always too big for me — it doesn't make me less female, and I even enjoy being flat. I've told others that a classmate of mine, a girl, naturally had an adam's apple, and that this feature can occur on natal women who never transitioned. I'm natal female and never touched T, and my eyebrows are thicker than what some people worry about on T.
I have an FtM friend whose story convinced me that crippling dysphoria wasn't what made him trans. It didn't exist before adulthood, and he defended himself by saying you can get dysphoria at any age — which I pointed out contradicts the "born that way" arguments. When I asked him to describe his experience, he had no childhood dysphoria like mine. What made him dysphoric was feeling arousal from dressing up as a male character he adored, when he was 20+ years old. It's a clear fetish behind it. He felt "gender euphoria" when he cosplayed a male character — joy and arousal in his case — he was worried it was a fetish, he saw a therapist, and the therapist told him about being transgender. That's how it went. I'm genuinely grossed out by him, unlike my MtF friend, who I believe won't detransition and who I never found creepy — she has been dysphoric her whole life very strongly.
It bothers me that my FtM friend called the "real life test" — living for a year as your preferred gender before hormones and surgery — very old fashioned and somehow very harmful. He seems to support the way the US handles it now. He argued against it by saying transwomen are more likely to be killed and harassed before hormones, which doesn't make sense to me because I doubt hormones change that after the first shot; you're as vulnerable to hate and harassment because you don't magically lose the features that make you a bit different from natal women and men. I have the impression the trans community prioritized hormones over passing, which seems most crucial for someone who wants to be seen as the other gender. They sound kinda like drug addicts with their obsession about hormones. The most ridiculous thing I've seen is a trans woman getting her first shot and suddenly feeling her dysphoria gone, even if she didn't start passing.
On biology, I think gender differences seem to be mostly environmental. I can only believe hormones may change the way someone acts, but it shouldn't expand as far as women preferring cooking and men preferring hunting — men are testosterone dominant but aren't always stereotypically masculine either, so hormonal influence is possibly not as big as we believe. I also think that trans activists defend their stance by saying trans people are born the way they are, therefore other options are like conversion therapy — but a gay person doesn't need surgeries and hormones to accept themselves.
I don't watch trans YouTubers, so certain thoughts never occurred to me. I don't hate being female; I just hate how I am treated on that basis. I don't consider myself to have transitioned or detransitioned medically, but I've moved from being a trans ally to being critical of how transition is currently handled.