Alle verhalen

Een gespiegelde versie van een nog onvolledige vorm

Man · Gedesisteerd197
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een 25-jarige autistische man met chronische pijn en hypermobiliteit die sinds de puberteit ernstige lichaamsdysforie heeft, met name rond mijn genitale anatomie en mijn stem. Ik overwoog op een gegeven moment te transitioneren, maar besloot het niet te doen, in de conclusie dat van gender veranderen slechts „een gespiegelde versie van een nog onvolledige vorm” zou zijn, en ik heb geen hormonen of operaties gehad. Ik maakte een periode van religieus militantisme en extreem traditionalisme door die mijn zelfbeeld en relaties beschadigde, maar ik trok me terug en heb mijn geloof door studie herzien. Ik heb meerdere therapeuten en medicijnen geprobeerd met beperkt succes, maar nu heb ik een trans-affirmerende therapeut met wie ik de dysforie zonder HRT bewerk, en ik onderzoek actief detrans-gemeenschappen en doe daar mee. Ik identificeer me nu als cisgender man die niet wil transitioneren, nog steeds worstelend met dysforie maar langzaam meer duidelijkheid krijgend, en ik heb kritische opvattingen over starre genderideologie aan zowel traditionalistische als transkant.

Volledig verhaal

I am a 25-year-old male (I have described myself as an 'aspie' and elsewhere as an ace person) who has been dealing with intense body dysphoria since puberty. The core of it has been an intense discomfort with the passive sensation of my body, particularly my genital anatomy, which I've described as 'the whole sensation of having a manhood / flesh worm / etc being well not as advertised. Like an afterthought piece of hardware that's supposed to be technically compatible and the diagnostics read healthy but whenever you press a button on it blue screen the whole system and your CPU catches on fire.' I've said this has been the 'unsolvable problem' I've coped with by working so hard I don't feel anything but passive pain elsewhere. I have pursued transition in the past — I've referenced 'when I was last pursuing transition actively' and my 'initial desire to transition fully' — but I did not go through with it or stopped short. My goal at the time was to end up 'somewhere more in the middle than necessarily go hyper feminine or anything close to that.' I ultimately decided I don't want to transition, saying 'Switching genders seemed an appealing option to contrast that result, but it's just a mirrored version of a still incomplete form.' I've also noted 'the rigour in which you were forced to conform early seems to have sapped a critical amount of confidence from your personal identity, and when you transitioned that idea was reinforced even more,' suggesting I did socially transition at some point. I've commented on the detrans community from an outside/considering perspective, reading detrans poll results and threads about unexpected effects, and noted 'this community is definitely more cautious than the more - aggressively positive spaces.' I grew up in a traditional, religious environment in a poorer, more desperate part of town where I had to be a protector for friends against men. I said I 'didn't really have much room to experiment or explore myself growing up as much as always being someone's guardian / survival mode' and didn't feel like I had an adolescent development stage, being 'pushed straight into responsibility without time to really experiment.' I experienced chronic pain and sensory issues my entire life, and I have autism and hypermobility. I described my upbringing as involving 'generations of people working in survival mode passing down behaviours which presume an inflexibly hostile environment.' I went through a period of 'religious militancy' and assimilated into fundamentalist traditionalism, which involved 'misdirected anger at LGBT people for existing as a concept' and a 'poor interpretation of religion.' I described this as having 'puritan radiation poisoning' and said it 'probably bricked my self perception somewhat.' I eventually stepped away, did long periods of self-reflection, and re-examined my faith through historical and biblical scholarship, concluding my issues were 'with man rather than God.' I described my brain as stuck in 'perpetual wartime functioning' with lingering threads of that old ideology blowing nonconformity 'out to witch hunt proportions.' I have tried multiple therapists, antidepressants and anxiety medication (to ill effect), and indirect approaches like exercise, theology, and building heteronormative relationships. These produced short-term success followed by increasingly severe burnout. I currently have a trans-affirming therapist who is 'perfectly content to work through issues related to dysphoria without HRT,' which has been helpful because I didn't feel guilty talking about those feelings. I currently have an asexual partner (we are both 'non sexual (woo autism)'), and our relationship is built on cuddling, DIY crochet, embroidery, and art together. She had her own period of questioning her gender due to how she was treated as a woman, but did not transition; together we worked on exploring areas of her life that brought fulfilment, with an amazing turnaround in her health and mood. I run business ventures and maintain a 'hyper masculine front' for business benefit, which I find exhausting. I described physically and socially being a man as 'exhausting in an existential manner' — 'If it was a role you clocked in and clocked out of that would be fine, 100% of the time is exponentially draining.' I experience significant distress around my voice, which has a wide range from theatre practice but sounds 'strained and discordant' unless I'm angry (authoritative) or alone (softer). Friends have joked it sounds 'like a German autocrat.' I'm uncomfortable being perceived or photographed, and I struggle to access a 'graceful but firm tone' around people I care about. I've noted I feel 'gross and detached in post' when seeing or hearing myself. I have no sexual attraction to anyone — I've said 'I literally feel the same way about men and women, which is to say no sexual attraction' and that the only angle I intrinsically understand about sex is 'to have kids for religious/ legacy reasons.' I've noted I 'Haven't ever struggled with AGP.' I've become active in detrans and related communities, reading research, poll results, and threads, and asking detailed questions about others' experiences. I've been critical of both traditionalist spaces and what I see as narcissistic dynamics in some trans communities, drawing parallels between 'AGP transitioners and Neo-traditionalist alpha males.' I've advocated for people finding personal fulfilment without rigid gender labels, and I've been vocal about the harms of rigid gender expectations across the spectrum. I've expressed caution about transitioning, noting I 'wonder sometimes where the downplaying comes from' regarding physical side effects, and suggested I would 'very aggressively band anyone' exhibiting narcissistic or extreme patterns if I were moderating such communities. I have not described any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. I've described friends in traditionalist spaces 'offing themselves metaphorically or literally' but that's about others, not myself. My mental health struggles center on burnout, chronic discomfort with my body, and the after-effects of religious extremism, and I've described therapy and community engagement as helping me slowly make sense of things, though I still feel 'there is a lot of tools missing from the collection to actually _fix_ my mindset.'