Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die rond mijn 7e sociaal transitioneerde, de diagnose genderdysforie kreeg en op mijn 12e pubertijdremmers en laaggedoseerde testosteron kreeg volgens het Nederlandse protocol. Op mijn 15e begon ik gendercritisch materiaal te lezen, kreeg ik spijt van de transitie en begon ik testosteron af te bouwen, met mijn remmer die op 21 januari 2020 verwijderd zou worden. Nu omschrijf ik mezelf als iemand die zichzelf geen enkel gender toekent, gewoon een mens die toevallig vrouw is, en ik voel me als een 'wetenschappelijk experiment' dat afwacht wat er met mijn lichaam gebeurt. Ik maak me zorgen over mijn verdiepte stem, mannelijk gezicht, mogelijke borstgroei, vruchtbaarheid en dat anderen me als man-naar-vrouw zien. Ik blijf ambivalent, makkelijk te beïnvloeden door beide kanten, en kritisch over algemene bevestigende zorg en transitie van kinderen, terwijl ik transitie in sommige gevallen nog zie als een mogelijk laatste redmiddel.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and was a tomboy from very early on. Around six or seven, I begged to be allowed to dress like a boy, be called 'he,' and have short hair. My parents didn't know what to do, so they took me to specialists, who noted that it 'might not just be a phase,' and I was eventually diagnosed with gender dysphoria. I also had significant behavioral problems as a child — I was very, very angry at everything, screamed a lot, and got really anxious.
My parents have always been really supportive and as impartial as they could be; they just never heard the other side. My family and I had been planning the Dutch protocol since I was pretty young. I socially transitioned at around seven and have not socialized as female since I was about seven. I got puberty blockers at 12, and a couple of weeks after the blocker I started low-dose testosterone cream that was meant to mimic male puberty. My bone age x-rays were always about two years behind my chronological age, but my bone density was never actually measured. I had stopped growing on a higher dose of T.
I transitioned before I had any internet access, and the only time I was looking at FTM stuff online was about five years after my social transition, so I don't think online influence caused my transition — though I'm sure it had some influence. I wasn't the classic ROGD kid; I practically grew up as trans. I'd had a completely flat chest, and I'd had a bit of breast budding when I was younger (penny-sized, not noticeable).
Around 15, I started reading articles and was introduced to gender-critical material and 'the other side,' and began thinking critically about transition for the first time. I barely thought about it before. I started regretting at 15. I noted that I had definitely had romantic feelings for girls. I was obsessed with bodybuilding and did all I could to build muscle and have low body fat; I remember wanting to be muscular when I was 8. I've always been worried about body image, and I noted that body image issues and dissociation are often related to being trans, but no one knows which comes first. I wasn't sure I was ever considered anorexic.
I found unlimited support and affirmation while I was trans, but could find nothing once I planned to detransition. My therapist is trans and, although he supports my choice to detransition and is very kind, he still says very trans-biased things, and I was planning to find a new one soon. He gave me part of a pro-trans book with extremely convincing evidence (studies claiming being trans is biological, blockers and hormones are not harmful and are the best treatment). I've read both pro-trans and anti-trans texts and found that both sides somehow make sense and don't make sense at the same time. I noted that affirmative care is now the norm and that child transition, which is my experience, is 'just not ok in a majority of circumstances.'
I'm super easily influenced — I said I could probably convince myself to be alt-right or become a Buddhist monk in a couple of weeks, and I don't always trust my own thoughts. I'd be sure I wanted to detransition after seeing a detrans video, then not want to after seeing a pro-trans one. I recognized I needed balance and reduction in my input. I also noted I'm overthinking and indecisive but know I am not a 'trender.'
I was an atheist but slowly warmed up to spirituality. I began learning Arabic, learned about Islam through that, learned to pray in Arabic, and went to a mosque to take my shahada. I received immediate support and love from everyone there. I later left Islam as part of my broader changes. I also started intuitive eating instead of calorie counting, started studying guitar again, and tried to limit social media, really only visiting detrans and exmuslim communities for some sense of community, because the only detransition community I could hear was online.
With my endocrinologist's permission, I was taking less testosterone to wean off. I had an appointment scheduled for January 21st, 2020, to get my blocker removed. After lowering the T dose, I already looked much thinner and more feminine, and oddly I started growing again. I was mostly scared about developing breasts (I had a completely flat chest) and anxious about getting a period, which I had never had. I'd been gendered as female in public way more (not since I was about 8) and couldn't decide which restroom to use. I said I didn't really care how people saw me anymore except for safety reasons, and thought the trans idea of passing was sort of unhealthy. At that point I said I didn't think of myself as any gender, just as a human with both feminine and masculine characteristics who happens to be female, and I was cool with that.
I got my ears pierced. My voice had dropped instantly on testosterone, and I said I was 'pretty screwed' but could make it work. I worried about having to bind (which I noted is quite harmful) or have surgery if I developed breasts, and hoped I might have very small breasts since it's in my genes. I said I definitely had solid reasons for detransition — having kids in the future, self-acceptance, and general moral beliefs — but sometimes really didn't want to do it, and worried that if I made the decision there would be no going back and I'd regret it forever. I described detransition as 'the big one,' feeling very irreversible and daunting, and said I felt like a science experiment, basically waiting to see what would happen with my body. I noted there are too many unknowns and that my parents were only given affirmative information and resources.
I posted a link about trans advocates trying to cancel a feminist talk on gender identity at the Seattle Public Library because I saw it in the newspaper and got excited to see detrans-related content in my area; I said I wasn't even a total gender critic. I also asked whether to keep my current androgynous/unisex name (which I'd had since around seven and feel connected to, and which shares my dad's name as a middle name) or reclaim my unmistakably female birth name, which I never liked and can't connect with. I was considering playing it by ear and possibly changing it back if I wasn't passing in a year or two, or officially changing it back while keeping the current name as a family nickname.