Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die 1 jaar en 8 maanden testosteron gebruikte voordat ik een paar maanden geleden van de ene dag op de andere stopte; ik ben nog niet sociaal gedetransitioneerd. Ik voel intense schuld dat mijn jongere broer of zus zich als trans begon te identificeren nadat ik uit de kast kwam en nu op 14-jarige leeftijd puberteitsremmers krijgt, en ik heb alleen mijn therapeut en één broer of zus over mijn detransitie verteld. Ik identificeer me als aseksueel, al ontwikkelde ik seksuele aantrekking op T die verdween toen ik stopte, en mijn menstruatie is teruggekomen. Ik ben kritisch over medische transitie bij jongeren, 'egg'-cultuur en de bewijsbasis voor pediatrische gendergeneeskunde, terwijl ik ertegen ben dat mijn ouders worden gecriminaliseerd. Ik accepteer dat ik vrouw ben en verwerp het label 'ftmtf', omdat ik detransitie zie als een einde aan de onzin en niet als nog een stap in een genderreis.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up atheist; that hasn't changed after detransitioning. My gender dysphoria started in puberty — I would crossdress, pretend to be a guy named Kyle, and make my family refer to me that way during little skits, which felt exciting and freeing. I wanted desperately to be 'one of the guys' with an all-male friend group, and all of my friends were female. When one of my friends came out as FTM I was happy to have someone to share the experience with. I described myself as very skinny with a growth hormone deficiency that caused my breasts to be very small, with zero curves — essentially the figure of a 12-year-old boy — and I still hated showering, looking in the mirror, and going in public because of dysphoria. When someone first referred to me as something other than 'she' I felt immediate relief, and it physically hurt when people called me she. I would feel envy so strong it physically hurt when I saw a man in public, and I would fantasize about getting breast cancer so I could get a double mastectomy. I took testosterone even though there was a high possibility of balding in my family because I would much rather be a bald, potentially unattractive man than a woman.
I was on testosterone for 1 year and 8 months; my dose was 30mg, increased to 40mg about a month before I stopped. A few months before my first post here (Feb 2024) I stopped my injections cold turkey rather than tapering, and I was worried about potential health problems since my next gender clinic appointment was months away. The main effect I noticed was a much lower sex drive. I had been off T for a couple months at that point and was experiencing vocal pain — I missed my old voice and pain-free vocal cords. I later noted my period had come back, 'shorter than normal but I was almost happy to see it again.' I identified as asexual, though I developed sexual attraction while on T and it went away again after I stopped. I am not socially detransitioned — I still avoid 'misgendering' people I know even when they aren't around out of habit. I don't use the label 'ftmtf' for myself; for me detransition is 'finally putting an end to the bullshit and just accepting that I'm female and that doesn't have any effect on my personality or interests or style.' I have a therapist, and the only people I've told about my detransition are my therapist and one sibling.
I feel enormous guilt about my family. My little sibling (female) started identifying as a boy after I came out, and my little brother (FTM, 14) is now being put on puberty blockers at the gender clinic. My mother had told me she wasn't going to put him on testosterone for a long time because, in her words, 'you just seemed so much more sure about me being trans than him.' I told my sibling about my detransition with the intention of getting him to reconsider medical transition, but he is emotionally closed off and constantly insults me, making connection difficult. His identical twin also identifies as non-binary, though that one isn't as deep and doesn't feel gender dysphoria or a need to medically transition. I feel it's all my fault and wish I never brought it upon my family, and I was trying to convince my parents to change course without first telling them I had detransitioned. My parents are standard liberal Democrats voting for Biden; both my mother and father hold the same views. I opposed a criminal investigation into my parents' situation, saying they are doing what licensed doctors tell them is safe for a child suffering from depression and gender dysphoria.
On the wider debate, I don't believe in a blanket care ban for transgender youth but said I was 'starting to lean that way,' and argued there need to be far more restrictions, noting America is a huge outlier on pediatric gender medicine. I engaged heavily with evidence quality, pointing out that systematic reviews on transition outcomes were based on low or very low quality evidence on the GRADE scale. I was critical of 'egg' culture, of claims that male/female socialisation doesn't exist, and of the idea that trans men can oppress trans women, saying I was 'very glad to have escaped all this.' I also compared my dysphoria in detail against someone with trans-related OCD, concluding they likely had OCD rather than gender dysphoria, and said many people in the detrans community either had or still have gender dysphoria and work through it without transition.