Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw: een butch, gendernonconforme vrouw van 4'11" die per medio 2023 na ongeveer 5 maanden testosteron was gestopt, omdat het mijn gezondheid schaadde en me niet hielp om als man door te gaan. Ik had al in mijn kindertijd dysforie, nog voordat ik iets wist van trans identiteit, kreeg pubertijdremmers voorgeschreven voor precociteit, kreeg van mijn moeder geen behandeling voor een groeistoornis (naar verluidt om "mijn homoseksuele en transseksuele neigingen te corrigeren") en groeide op onder druk van mijn gezin om vrouwelijk en heteroseksueel te zijn. Ondanks mijn pogingen om een mannelijke vrouw te zijn en te putten uit jaren van radicaalfeministisch denken over de voordelen van vrouw zijn, houdt mijn dysforie aan: ik beschrijf dat ik me vast voel in een kostuum en rouw omdat ik nooit een cis man zal zijn, en ik heb andere detransitioners openlijk gevraagd hoe zij daar voorbij zijn gekomen. Ik heb IBD, word als gnc-vrouw lastiggevallen in damestoiletten en heb kritische maar genuanceerde opvattingen over transitiegeneeskunde; ik geef de schuld aan gebrekkige diagnostische criteria die gendernonconformiteit met dysforie verwarren. Ik heb een relatie met een vriendin met wie ik hoop te trouwen en zeg uitdrukkelijk dat ik mezelf nooit van het leven zou beroven, omdat ik er voor haar en mijn zus moet zijn.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned woman — a butch, gender-nonconforming woman who went off testosterone because it was damaging my health, didn't help me pass, and made me feel like "a failure of a man." I was born female, and I am 4'11" with what I describe as a classical female skeletal structure, a round face, an hourglass figure, and hips and ass that friends tease me about. Without testosterone my skin is soft and whatever muscle I have is covered by a layer of subcutaneous fat.
My dysphoria goes back to childhood, long before I knew what being trans was: I spent my childhood believing I'd grow up bald and wide-framed like my dad, waiting for my voice to drop and facial hair to come in. I also relate this to growing up relating to males more often than females, and to my sexuality, though I don't fully understand why I was like this. I was prescribed puberty blockers for precocious puberty as a child — my parents made that decision based on my symptoms and a desire for a normal puberty. I also have a growth disorder; I am 8+ inches shorter than even the women in my family. My mother refused me treatment, which I was told was to "fix my gay and transsexual tendencies," and my family pressured me to stop being masculine, get a boyfriend, and "think about having kids one day" — I believe because they were afraid I'd end up gay or trans given my already existing behaviors.
I was a radical feminist for years, and it taught me to embrace the advantages of the female body — ultradistance athletics, longevity, metabolic efficiency. I say explicitly that in no ways do I feel inferior to males. But accepting being a masculine woman hasn't worked, because for me "it's about the maleness, not masculinity" — my female characteristics feel wrong, like I'm stuck in a costume, and I hate that I'll never be a cis man. I've tried coping strategies: I wear "dad clothes" and have for several years, and I've been working on building muscle (eating a lot of protein; triceps have grown, asking about delt exercises). I've been off testosterone for 5 months as of one exchange, and I've discussed laser hair removal timelines for facial hair (my girlfriend did around 8 sessions; dense facial hair can take up to 400 hours).
I have a girlfriend I want to marry, provide for, and start a family with, and a sister I need to be here for. I state clearly I would never kill myself because I need to be there for them. Still, every day I'm weighed down by the realization that I am not male and never will be. I asked other detransitioners directly: "How did you do it? What can make me ok with being female?" — I desperately wish to be one of those detransitioners who just wake up with no dysphoria.
I have IBD, which makes bathroom access a real concern. As a butch, androgynous woman I've been questioned and harassed so much in women's restrooms that I prefer the men's or to just hold it. I'm critical of sex-based bathroom laws precisely because gnc people like me get targeted regardless. I've also noted that my height insecurity stems mostly from my growth disorder, my mother's refusal of treatment, and being much shorter than the women in my family, and that it feels akin to being a short male — expected to be a protector and "dominant" but treated like the opposite because people associate short stature with femininity. My friend groups aside from a non-LGBT all-male one have teased me about my height, hips, and personality.
I hold nuanced, somewhat critical views on transition medicine. I argue that the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for gender dysphoria relied heavily on gender roles and gender nonconformity, which would capture most gender-nonconforming or gay/lesbian children, and that this explains high desistance rates — blaming doctors for conflating gender nonconformity with gender dysphoria. I believe the diagnostic criteria and process are insufficient and should screen for sexual assault, depression, body dysmorphia, and other conditions first. At the same time, I cite studies that HRT improves trans children's dysphoria and quality of life, defend parental consent for medical treatment (citing my own blockers for precocious puberty), and note transsexual medical care has existed since the early 1900s. I also warn others that long-term cross-sex HRT alters sex characteristics and "essentially makes you intersex" — "functionally intersex" — leaving many unsatisfied. I only regret certain aspects of HRT, and I've suggested breast reconstruction/prosthetics and speech therapy for detransitioned women.