Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben nooit getransitioneerd en identificeer me niet als gedetransitioneerd. In 2021, op mijn 17e, ben ik uit nieuwsgierigheid lid geworden van r/detrans, omdat ik me eigenlijk geen enkel gender voel en een plek wilde waar ik vragen kon stellen zonder transfoob genoemd te worden. Ik had toen last van depressie en suïcidale gedachten en zei tegen mezelf dat ik eerst mijn eigen hoofd op orde moest krijgen voordat ik me met bredere politieke vragen bezighield. Ik sta voorzichtig sceptisch tegenover medische ingrepen in de menselijke ontwikkeling, vooral puberteitsremmers, zonder me uitdrukkelijk tegen transitie uit te spreken, en ik ben ervan overtuigd dat homoseksualiteit geen geestesziekte is. Ik heb geen medische ingrepen ondergaan en heb geen spijt van transitie, omdat ik nooit ben getransitioneerd.
Volledig verhaal
I never really thought I was trans — that's the first thing I want to be clear about. I joined r/detrans out of curiosity rather than because I had transitioned or was planning to. I was 17 at the time, around May 2021, and I'd originally joined the subreddit hoping to ask questions in a place where I wouldn't be berated as a transphobe. I realized fairly quickly it wasn't really the place for my questions, but I stayed because I found other people's experiences quite interesting to read. I mostly kept quiet there.
I'd never really felt like any gender, which is part of why the whole topic fascinated me — I found it quite baffling. When I did comment, I usually made sure to give a disclaimer that I wasn't trans and was just there out of curiosity. I rarely commented, and when I did it was usually because I was drunk — I remember apologizing on at least one occasion for incoherent, drink-fueled posts. I was self-conscious about that pattern.
I was dealing with depression and suicidal feelings at that time. In May 2021 I wrote plainly that "i mean im depressed and suicidal and i dont need to lose more hope in humanity. i need to sort my own mind out first." That was a real statement of where I was: I felt I needed to stabilize my own mind before taking on the wider world. I told myself I was only 17 and would "wait till im older for these things" — figuring I'd sort myself out before everything else. I also felt that I couldn't become an expert on everything, so I needed to learn what was important to me and what I actually wanted to become an expert in. I was critical of what I saw as a problem with modern society: that we don't wait anymore, that there aren't as many experts, and that everyone learns a tiny bit about lots of things and then decides their opinion.
On the substance of transition and gender, my stance was cautious but not opposed. In May 2021 I said I'd "given up looking into anything that has become political because im 17 and theres wayy to much agression," so I just asked when I heard reasonable-sounding people. My takeaway was essentially "common sense of fucking with human development might be a bad idea" — while explicitly adding "not saying dont transition." I was interested in puberty blockers specifically and asked what negative effects they had, saying I hadn't considered some of the points people raised to me. I suggested a new subreddit, r/detransexperiences, might be in order given gaps in what was being discussed.
Earlier, in March 2020, I'd been active in threads about coping with other people's judgment. I offered advice like dividing a problem into its component parts and seeing which could be solved, and suggested that if the difficulty was mainly other people's reactions, it was worth learning to cope with their judgment rather than changing course. I was skeptical of using drugs to cope, saying "You really shouldn't be using drugs to help you cope with hard times" and that if anything it had to be psychedelics, though that was still a bad idea — and that medication should be prescribed by a doctor, not taken because you feel bad. I also recommended podcasts, movies, and shows as healthier distractions.
I was somewhat irreverent and dismissive of social pressure generally. I told someone not to let other people interfere with how they identify, and floated the idea that "trans people are only trans because of other people," suggesting they learn to worry less about other people's thoughts. I was also blunt about geography and culture, joking that Turkey didn't sound like a good place to be different.
By September 2023 I responded to something with a single word: "lady." And in June 2024 I stated a clear position: "Regardless of whatever, I don't see how homosexuality could be a mental illness."
I never socially or medically transitioned, never took hormones, and never had any surgeries. I don't identify as detransitioned — I was never transitioned in the first place. I came to the community as an interested outsider, partly because I don't really feel like any gender myself, and stayed for the discussions. My main struggles during this period were depression and suicidal thoughts, which I wanted to address before engaging with broader political questions. I don't discuss family, relationships, sexuality, or trauma in any detail in what I've written, so I'll leave those areas open.
As for my current views: I'm supportive of people's right to transition but cautious about medical intervention, especially in development, and I firmly do not regard homosexuality as a mental illness. I haven't done any formal advocacy or activism.