Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw met OCD en een geschiedenis van anorexia (opgenomen in 2005 op mijn 19e), en ik begrijp mijn eigen worstelingen nu vanuit lichaamsdysmorfie en jeugdtrauma door bemoeizuchtige ouders. Ik woon momenteel in Oregon, ben 40 en zit in therapie vanwege een verstrengelde relatie met mijn moeder. Ik geloof dat veel van de moderne trans-identificatie sociale besmetting, subcultuur en een zichzelf vervullend verlangen is om 'trans te zijn' in plaats van echte genderdysforie, en ik vind dat de last van de stoornis moet liggen bij degene die hem heeft. Ik adviseer anderen die twijfelen over transitie actief om te vertragen, therapie te volgen en uit te zoeken of OCD, trauma of hormonen hun gevoelens aansturen, en ik moedig gedetransitioneerde mensen aan zich publiekelijk uit te spreken.
Volledig verhaal
I have OCD — I've had several forms of it: homosexual OCD, harm OCD, sexual intrusive thoughts, relationship OCD, and sexuality OCD — and it has shaped how I understand my own feelings and, in turn, how I understand gender dysphoria. I was hospitalized for anorexia in 2005 when I was 19, and I've been in therapy for it; I had to work through those issues a lot, and while I don't always love my body or who I am, I'm on the other side now and can accept myself so much more. I'm 40 now, and I still describe myself as a shy, awkward introvert who feels 'not right' in her skin sometimes.
I went to beauty school in Oregon and lived in Portland for years — I'm an Oregonian and still visit — and I went to college in 2003, when, as I put it, there wasn't a single trans or non-binary person to be seen anywhere. That memory matters to me because it's part of why I'm skeptical of how mainstream trans identity has become. I think a lot of young people are lost, and being trans gives them direction, identity, something to hang their hat on — and that wanting to be trans can become a self-fulfilling prophecy, where the more you want it, the more you notice things about your behavior, until you realize you were playing the part of trans rather than the part of the opposite gender. I wrote a whole post about this distinction — wanting to be trans versus wanting to be the opposite gender — because I think for some detransitioned people that's exactly what happened.
I have childhood trauma: overbearing parents who are still this way, which caused me to crave extreme autonomy to the point of being extremely detached, with horrible attachment issues. I often have the feeling of not wanting to be known or perceived, of wanting to disappear but not die, to start over from scratch — and I've realized that's completely due to that childhood trauma. Right now I'm in a toxic, enmeshed relationship with my mother, and I'm learning in therapy that my 'move across the country' fantasy is a flight response, not a solution. I know what a transition fantasy feels like because of that — that desperate, real feeling that running away would fix everything.
I think gender dysphoria can be tied to body dysmorphia, not in all cases but in some. In the early 2000s we looked in the mirror, hated what we saw, and starved ourselves — it was a form of self-harm and a means of control. Now, with gender ideology on the rise, people look in the mirror and hate what they see, and their first thought is that they need to change it: 'I'm not a feminine enough woman, I'm not a sexy enough woman.' Instead of focusing on the body part they focus on the woman part. Half of these people would have been anorexic in 2005. I genuinely believe gender dysphoria sits in the same category as the body dysmorphia anorexics deal with — just a slightly different version.
I'm skeptical of how much of modern trans identity is social contagion, subculture, and coping. I think transgenderism now functions like an alternative subculture — punk, goth, emo — except now it's getting medicalized. I think people who talk the most loudly about their trans identity are the least likely to be trans, because they're projecting outward to convince themselves. I think a lot of people are sold an idea of what being a boy will be like — the e-boy with blue hair — and never ask whether they're ready to age into a middle-aged balding man with a pop belly. I think gender identity itself is a fairly new concept that has muddied the waters of what was always a sex-based disorder, and I've written posts asking whether the stress of 'identifying' is something we made up.
I also think the burden of gender dysphoria should fall on the person who has the disorder, not on everyone else — I've compared it to my OCD, where I have to learn to deal with my triggers rather than forbidding everyone else from saying the words that trigger me. I've argued that biological women shouldn't be the ones made to feel unsafe in their own bathrooms and locker rooms because of someone else's disorder. I've also been critical of how feminists and the trans movement interact, and of how parents are pressured into uncritical support.
I've given a lot of advice to people questioning transition: take your time, get deep therapy, look into whether something else is going on — hormones, trauma, OCD — before deciding you must be trans. I've told people that being trans is rare, that it's okay to be a masculine woman or a feminine man, and that acceptance of that is crucial and often a relief. I've encouraged detransitioned people to tell their story, even if it makes others angry, and to use TikTok to reach lonely teens. I'm still in therapy, working on boundaries and on not running from my problems.