Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I have identified as a detransitioned man for several years now. I first noticed painful gender dysphoria when I was about 3 or 4 years old, and I began using the word transgender for myself around age 12 or 13. I socially transitioned at about 16 and started hormone therapy (estrogen, mtf) at about 20, after a process that took only two weeks and one doctor's appointment. I lived publicly as trans for over a decade and was on hormones for about four years, stopping around age 22 after I began recovering memories of childhood abuse. I tapered off under my prescribing doctor's care — halving my dose for two weeks, then halving it again for two more weeks, then stopping.
The core of my story is abuse. From roughly ages 3 to 15 I was raped and tortured for hours daily by a family member, my sister. Part of this involved forcing me to cross-dress, calling me by a female name, keeping my hair long, and sometimes making me wear female clothing outside the house. I was repeatedly told how disgusting boys were compared to girls, and repeatedly told that if I had been born a girl the rape and torture would not have happened. My parents also kept my hair long, talked about how gross boys were, and made me wear my sister's hand-me-downs, so I was frequently mistaken for a girl until about age 9. I developed the belief that if I truly became a woman the abuse would stop, and I blamed myself for being male. I hated my genitals and my male body, feeling vulnerable and inhuman inside my own skin, as if I existed only as an object for my abuser. I craved transition as a way to end the abuse and feel safe in my body.
I left that situation at 15 and repressed many of the memories, but the dysphoria stayed. I transitioned hoping to alleviate the dysphoria and pass as a woman, and hormones did greatly reduce my dysphoria and improve my body image. But it did not make me feel more like myself — I still felt the same suffocation coupled with paranoia about passing. I detransitioned after recovering more complete memories of the abuse and realizing it was the direct cause of my dysphoria. I stopped hormones about five months after figuring that out. It took me well over a year between realizing I wanted to detransition and actually doing so, and it cost me many friends.
After stopping hormones I felt a lack of energy, more mood swings, depression, loss of libido, worse insomnia, and increased suicidal feelings, but within a month or two things went back to normal. I am a survivor of two suicide attempts — one before starting hormones and one while on them. I still experience pretty severe dysphoria almost every day, and for a long time it was a constant battle not to retransition, though that has gotten easier. I still hate my genitals, though therapy has reduced those feelings considerably. The main lasting physical change from hormones is fat redistribution in my chest — I wore a B cup while presenting as a woman, and my chest is still noticeably larger without layers, and my face still looks fairly feminine. I still get gendered as a woman in public on occasion. I have also had nipple discharge since puberty, which a doctor attributed to somewhat elevated prolactin, probably from antidepressants.
Therapy has been the single biggest help. I have worked with around six therapists over roughly 15 years of treatment. My current therapist, who studied under R.D. Laing and has a background in trauma, has been the most helpful, and I also worked with Jungian therapists who were neutral on the question of transition. I have PTSD, OCD, depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts. I was also told as a young person that medical transition was the sole option for someone with dysphoria, and I feel I was groomed toward being transgender by my abuser. I put off medical transition for about seven years while questioning and going to therapy, but throughout that time I was met with "nothing can cause dysphoria, so you must be trans" from the trans community and from affirming therapists.
Things that have helped me manage dysphoria without hormones include therapy, medications prescribed for other issues (including medical marijuana prescribed for PTSD, which I also use for a stomach condition), not limiting my feminine expression while still presenting male, understanding my childhood trauma, exercise and keeping my body in shape, mindfulness, meditation, art, and reading Daoist texts like the Tao Te Ching and the Zhuangzi. I also worked on reducing AGP-related fantasies through therapy and by gradually shifting how I imagine myself during masturbation. I went back to my birth name, which I have always liked. I am gay — I have mostly had women friends, and my last boyfriend before detransitioning was fine with it, so we were then in a gay male relationship, which we were both comfortable with. I still list myself as a trans woman on dating and hookup sites because my body hasn't changed much and it works for me. I have been part of a small male detrans Discord group.
I went back to school/work decisions too: I chose transition over a very promising career and would not make that decision again. I have worked as a writer/editor and made comics. I currently live in East Asia, having grown up in San Francisco. I am Jewish. I have dealt with a lot of isolation, and I was bullied badly in school, partly racism related to my mother's afro. I also experienced abuse in my adult life.
As for what I think now: I believe dysphoria usually has a cause and that therapy should be the first step, and I would like to see mandatory therapy before transition, though I don't think it should necessarily block an adult who still wants to transition. I support informed consent and easy access for adults but oppose minors transitioning with hormones or puberty blockers. I am skeptical of AGP/HSTS as complete explanations but acknowledge AGP as a real phenomenon for some. I don't really believe in gender as an innate thing, viewing it as socially constructed, and I use pronouns as a matter of empathy. I have been critical of what I see as transphobia in the detrans community and have pushed back against off-topic or hateful posts, sometimes at the cost of downvotes. I have advocated for detrans-specific therapy and community, and I have offered to talk privately with people who are struggling. I regret choosing transition over my career and the years and friendships it cost me, though I don't regret that I tried it, since it did reduce my dysphoria at the time. My dysphoria is now extremely mild compared to childhood after years of intensive therapy, but it has not disappeared.