Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (als vrouw geboren, momenteel non-binair identificerend) die ongeveer vier jaar sociaal als FTM transitioneerde maar op een onderbuikgevoel stopte vlak voordat ik met hormonen zou beginnen. Mijn besluit werd gedreven door hoe gezien worden als man mijn sociale wereld veranderde, angst voor levenslange medicalisering en een mix van vrouwenhaat en homofobie, vooral vrouwenhaat, en niet door spijt van een lichamelijke ingreep. Ik ervaar nog steeds verpletterende episodes van dysforie en rouw om een leven als man dat ik nooit zal leiden, wat soms mijn daten beïnvloedt, maar verder bloei ik op de businessschool met een goede carrière, vrienden en een hechte detransitionerende vriend. Ik heb autisme, aanhoudende lichaamsdysmorfie gekoppeld aan een eerdere zelfbeschadigingsmethode en blijvende stembandknobbeltjes door jarenlang spreken onder mijn natuurlijke register. Ik heb geen spijt van mijn detransitie en geloof dat er goede levens wachten na detransitie, al wil ik nog steeds aan vrouw-zijn ontsnappen en voel ik me niet helemaal mijn bij de geboorte toegewezen sekse.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I'm 21 as of December 2020, so I was born in 1999. I identified as trans — first as FTM, then briefly as nonbinary — for about four years, desisting after roughly three years of identifying as male when I made the decision not to medically transition. I never went on hormones; I stopped right before getting HRT on a gut feeling. I socially transitioned for about three years during that period.
My dysphoria was bad enough that it impacted my day-to-day life, and I had a diagnosis, the talks, and dreams of going on testosterone, cutting off my conservative family, and living a 'tit-less life on the road, a beautiful man.' But I realized that dream wasn't realistic — I'd miss my family, I'd still be me, and I'd still be worried about whether I was man enough, woman enough, nonbinary enough. I also weighed the potential nerve damage or dog ears of top surgery, hair loss or acne from T, and becoming a permanent medical patient on hormones. Hormones terrify me, especially as someone who became heavily suicidal on a light birth control — we are fragile bodies and hormones run everything.
A big reason I decided to desist rather than physically transition was my social situation. As I socially transitioned, I realized how people's perception of me changed. I didn't like being a woman, but I also didn't like being seen as a man after some time — the shift in privilege and power dynamic was scary and I hated it. Being seen as nonbinary made me seem 'trans,' which was a whole new headache. The entire time I was trans, people were either walking on tiptoes around me, or on my case about calling me not trans enough for liking feminine things, or more threatening than the world I'd known. That wasn't a life for someone with horrible anxiety and sensitivity to rejection. I realized I wasn't trans anymore when I wanted to take it all back so I wouldn't have to feel like I'd been trapped in another hellish gender box — it was honestly really traumatic. I wouldn't say I regret it because it was necessary to understand who I am now.
I read detrans stories and came to realize a lot of women had similar experiences to mine, and I realized I could have just been myself from the start. Coming to terms with that really lessened my dysphoria — it's still there, but I learned it can be managed in other ways. Speaking to other GNC and detrans women has helped, though I still struggle to consider myself a woman. Radical feminism really helped me deconstruct a lot of my issues with self-image and esteem; it helped me redefine being a woman and I began to prioritize my actions and who I was over how others saw me, which was freeing. A talk-therapist who helped me work through experiences with conversation and not imposing a framework on me helped the best.
I also dealt with body dysmorphia connected to a self-harm method — it started as something unrelated and turned into something that's still ongoing. I have autism and a very complicated relationship with my gender. I still identify as nonbinary, honestly, despite being for the most part detransitioned — it's been a way for me to be more honest with myself, decide against transitioning, and find alternative help for my dysphoria. I think I'd have gone through with it if I didn't have that avenue to explore these old aspects of myself I at one point completely rejected. I don't even really remember what gave me the drive to want to transition — it was a lot of things, and I still don't 'feel like' my assigned sex at birth, so I understand how I came to that conclusion.
I kept my name — it's actually a little more neutral and reflects how far I've come. My family calls me by my original name; I never really came out to them and I consider it a term of endearment. I'm bi, and being wlw adds its own struggles — I get dreams and a 'relationship feel' of imagining myself as a guy she's with. It affects my ability to date men and women because I get too in my head about how they perceive my gender in the relationship.
I didn't go on hormones, but speaking way below my register for years formed vocal nodules in my throat. My voice squeaks, cracks, and hurts; if I try to aim above my range, it's all air and pain. I used to sing at a soprano/mezzo soprano and can't anymore, but I can still sing velvety alto songs. I have a naturally deep voice now and find that in white-collar corporate work it actually helps — men take me more seriously. I work in business school and have made many friends; I'm living a good life and working on my career. I have a close friend who fully transitioned and is now detransitioning; neither of us have negative feelings regarding it because we accept it as part of the story of our lives — it was a phase, but at the time it felt real.
Some days the dysphoria is crushing — I just want to sit and cry and mourn a life as a man that I never got to live and never will. Other days I can get by but it overshadows aspects of my life. I know in my soul that physical and even social transition wouldn't benefit me and I don't think I'd choose it in the future. I feel like I lost some of the best years of my life to the phase that I still don't quite understand. I think what drove it was a mix of misogyny and homophobia, primarily misogyny — I still wish to escape womanhood and all it is, I've always hated it, I just know I'm not trans. I wouldn't say I was never trans — some people will say I never was — but I had the diagnosis and the dreams. I don't fault anyone for coming out of transition with trauma or negative feelings, but I've found that perspective alone can change how a situation looks in hindsight. Good lives still await people after detransitioning.