Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die door een zware periode is gekomen en nu stabiel en in vrede ben met mijn lichaam, en mijn ervaring gebruik om anderen aan te moedigen zonder publiekelijk over mijn eigen medische details te praten. Ik geloof dat transitie voor veel mensen, ook voor mij, voortkwam uit emotioneel trauma, leed over mijn lichaamsbeeld en een gevoel van gevangen zijn dat rond de puberteit kwam en met de tijd afnam. Ik schrijf het aan het afstand nemen van het voortdurende online genderdiscours en het omringen met mensen die zichzelf accepteren toe dat ik weer mijn eigen stem hoor. Ik ben kritisch over de LHBTQ-gemeenschap en sommige artsen die medische ingrepen aanmoedigen terwijl ik denk dat mensen in zo'n kwetsbare staat geestelijke gezondheidszorg nodig hebben, en ik moedig anderen aan voor onderzoek te pleiten. Ik beschrijf in dit materiaal geen operaties, medicatie, zelfbeschadiging of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I never wrote a full account of my own transition here; almost everything I posted in this window was advice and encouragement offered to other people in the community, so my own story only shows through in the things I let slip while writing to them.
What I did say plainly is that I went through something in the past that I had to face, and that I came out the other side in a stable place. I told one person, "You are very brave to face what happened to you in the past," and later, "Very happy for you that you are in a stable place now. You should not feel guilty." Reading those lines back, I was clearly writing about myself as much as about them. I also referred to "the first time" — meaning the first time I went through a transition-related process — and told someone that their family and friends "did not understand what you went through the first time, they still sticked around." That tells me my own family did not understand what I went through either, but that they stayed.
I have a clear and settled view of why people like me end up transitioning. I wrote that "the problems most of these people have is emotional trauma" and that they "should deal with these emotional trauma, not use transition to hide from it." I also said, "For many of us, the reason for transition is the body image issue. Another problem is the emotion of feeling trapped. When these came at per-puberty time, it seems to be part of puberty." That is my own framework: body image distress and a feeling of being trapped, arriving around puberty, and then easing as puberty settles. I told one teenager that "I felt that everything gets better as puberty starts to settle," and that I believed the same was happening to them. I also believe having a child changes your perspective completely, "for the better."
On how I got to where I am now, I did not describe therapy or a dramatic turning point. What I described is withdrawal from the discourse. I recommended disconnecting "from all the discussions one side or the other," finding other things to focus on, and then being able to "listen to your own voice" so that "your body will then tell you what to do." I blamed the constant chatter about gender and sexuality on social media for making it hard to think clearly. I also placed a lot of weight on surrounding yourself with people who love themselves rather than people who are considering changing themselves, because "the energy will rub off on you."
I am critical of how the LGBTQ community and some doctors handle people in my position. I wrote that "the lgbtq together with a few doctors look at us as problems to get rid off rather than people they should help," that the wider society does not want anything to do with us, and that "we need mental help desperately, not medical intervention." I urged another detransitioner to use their position to push the LGBTQ community toward research rather than "pushing us to harm ourselves when we were at our most vulnerable time mentally." I do not see speaking up as hateful; I told someone, "You are not being hateful or harming the trans community."
On my body and appearance now, I am at peace. I told someone that being "self reflecting and humble about your appearance itself is already so beautiful," and that there is "no need to let other people's judgements of your appearance push you to harm your body." I also said, "Sounds like you really like your body," which was the register I was writing in about bodies generally. On identity, I am comfortable with ordinary pronouns now — I told someone, "Don't be bothered with the pronouns either... You will eventually be at peace with the common ones too." I do not define manhood or womanhood by feeling: "Just because you don't feel the masculinity, does not make you any less a man... You are foremost an individual." On relationships, I see friendship and romance as a continuum, and I think about my future family concretely — imagining whether I want a child's father in the picture and what kind of "good man" he would be.
I did not describe surgeries, medications, specific diagnoses, self-harm, or suicidal thoughts anywhere in this material, so I will not claim any. What I can say is that I came through a difficult period, I am stable now, I feel no guilt, and I have found a way of thinking about my body and my past that lets me help other people without bitterness.