Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I am autistic. I never took testosterone, never had any medical transition, and never presented male full-time, so I describe myself as a desister rather than a detransitioner — though I've told friends I internally identified as trans, and I cried wearing my boyfriend's clothes over not having a penis. My gender feelings have come and gone sporadically over the years, so sporadically that I didn't meet the criteria for a recent survey posted in the community. A year before mid-2020, if I could have picked my body like an RPG character creator, I would have chosen a male body — about 6' tall, ectomorph, blue or green eyes, sharp features, without the balding gene. Now I say I wouldn't pick much differently than the body I have, because the person I am has been completely shaped by my body.
I frame my path as dysphoria relief through radical self-acceptance rather than calling myself cis or not trans; I've said I feel "too trans to be cis, and too cis to be trans." I came out publicly on Facebook around late June 2020, when people were upset about an article about JK Rowling, posting very private photos of me trying to pass as the opposite sex along with a rant about detrans/desisters and whether JKR was out of touch but made important points. It went okay; I don't think anyone except my genderqueer friends knew what I was getting at, and I worried I came off pretentious and internally transphobic. I lean gender critical for myself and interpersonal relationships, but politically I just want people to feel safe; I describe myself as gender-centrist on detrans issues with a focus on mental and physical health. I've said I would still like a nose job.
I think dysphoria is not really about gender at all but a crossroads of wanting to be seen as a whole, unique human being and not wanting to be shoved into a box. I believe dysphoria results from the inherent trauma of being misunderstood for not fitting a box you're placed in, with gender roles being a hugely popular box. I have childhood trauma and difficulty with emotional regulation, and I've recommended r/CPTSD repeatedly, saying someone responsible for helping me develop a strong sense of self — my parents — messed things up and instilled shame and conditional love in my core. I've also said my parents put me on this earth and it's their job to make sure I feel loved, and that nobody should mock their child. I've described myself as having loads of childhood trauma.
I'm autistic and I don't believe autism is a disorder, only a variation of human neurotype; I recommend Neurotribes. I think autism plus sensory overload plus not picking up on gender roles is a perfect recipe for dysphoria. I've described feeling like "a linux in a world of windows and macs." I lost my job around a year before mid-2020, a niche job I thrived in, and by mid-2020 I was unemployed with my partner supporting me while I tried to figure out how to make a career work with my limitations; I struggle most days and have meltdowns, but also good days, and I still think of myself as disabled, not disordered. I live in the Bay Area and have spent a lot of time backpacking in Japan.
My body is tattooed, pierced, and I have my tongue split. I rushed into the tongue split and a heavy mod artist did it off-center, which bothers me; I also have a tattoo I wouldn't choose again, one that covered up my favorite freckle. I've said some modifications were attempts to be more attractive, some to get closer to my own heart, and some to claim my body back from people who'd violated it. I'm a body modification artist in training. I believe any modification should come from growth and love rather than self-hatred.
I've been a sex worker for more than a decade — an exotic dancer for over a decade — and spent my teens on 4chan. I see all women, and most men, as victims of misogyny, and I've decided that if someone is going to profit off my perceived worth, that person will be me. I believe sex work and pornography can be healthy and even spiritual when participants come from respect and honesty, but that mainstream porn teaches people to use each other's bodies as masturbatory tools. I consider myself a fairly radical feminist despite being a sex worker, and I cherry-pick the feminism that makes sense to my experiences. I went to a 12-step meeting (al-anon) where I corrected a woman's whorephobic language mid-story and later realized I'd robbed her of the words she knew to speak her truth.
I was in fifth grade in 1999 when I started watching anime; Sailor Moon was my best source of gender-role challenging material, and I liked Ranma 1/2 because I wanted the option to go instantaneously from male to female, especially aesthetically. I grew up in a hippie college town with several very GNC teachers; in preschool another girl and I told our very butch teacher that boys were awful and how terrible it was that we'd have to marry them someday, and she told us girls could marry girls, leading to a playground revolution where we announced the boys had been forsaken.
On transition generally: I've said I never went as far as medically transition, and I use disclaimers when giving advice. I worry about hyper-positivity in trans spaces — I made a post about a therapist who wouldn't write a letter until the patient had talked to three people with bottom surgery complications, and how the top replies just said get a new therapist. I've said I was silenced when asking difficult questions the hugbox didn't like during my transition exploration, and that it took me way too long to find people discussing the negatives. I think some people really do benefit from medical transition and that gendered-brain wiring might exist, but I'm not a neuroscientist. I've said changing your body can be an effective path to happiness for some, but my issue is the demand that others see and treat you a certain way because of it — radical self-acceptance includes acceptance in the face of rejection. I've said "Hating yourself or your body is not a good reason to make changes like transitioning" and that transition should come from a desire to grow, not escape.
I've been critical of both TRA and GC extremes, saying neither has all the pieces, and I've pushed back on people being called "it's a fetish" dehumanizingly. I think the non-binary movement has the right core ideas. I'm wary of puberty blockers and HRT being pushed without informed consent, and I've said "fucking with the development of otherwise healthy organs is dangerous." I've also said I don't want to shut down TERFs, I want to amplify detrans voices.
I've been in therapy using DBT and mindfulness, which have been great for sorting out my tangled feelings; I use "wise mind" and the concept of "effective" rather than good/bad. I've said the question of escape versus growth took me almost thirty years to start asking. I'm pro-choice on suicide in a philosophical sense but very glad to no longer be bombarded by those thoughts — I've said suicide was a constant thought in my twenties and is now pretty rare, and that you couldn't pay me to go through my twenties again. I've recommended psychedelics in mindful, safe settings as part of effective therapy, citing MAPS and Erowid, and said I'm eternally grateful for the healing psychedelic medicine brought me, while acknowledging the risks. Dancing is my favorite stim and was a huge factor in my healing and self-discovery; I also got into macrame over a holiday when I was really depressed and sick.
I became a moderator of r/detrans around July 2020, partly because I saw gender-affirming detrans users feeling they no longer had a voice. I wrote a widely-shared post welcoming GC refugees after r/gendercritical was banned, asking them to keep the space neutral. I wrote the subreddit FAQ, instituted and enforced user flair rules, created a "detrans timeline" post flair, added intersex flair options, ran flairing threads, and did an interview (voice only) with someone about detrans experiences. I've said moderating a controversial sub is exhausting and that I'm a human being. I've described myself as a peacemaker rather than a fighter.
On relationships: I've been with my partner — a friend of a decade — and in mid-2020 said we were getting married soon. He's nerdy, physically softer, wears a C-pap mask, and drives me wild; I said I only started being attracted to people's smiles rather than aesthetics in the year before I was 31. I've advised others that validation depending on an outside person won't bring peace. I've said I don't think I would have been open to dating another trans-man when I was identifying as a gay trans-man.
I've said I've changed what I've gone by several times in my life — sometimes as a break from being me, sometimes to feel more like myself — and that I got clocked as a transwoman the previous year despite not having presented as male in a long time. I've said I don't really think of myself as cis or not trans, but as someone who has chosen a path of dysphoria relief that is essentially radical self-acceptance at its core. I've said shifting to that view took a lot of therapy, working through layers of trauma, and deciding to embrace what I have, and I hope one day it can be offered at the same level as HRT.