Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde homoseksuele man die ongeveer vijf jaar als transvrouw leefde nadat bij mij in 1998, op mijn zestiende, genderidentiteitsstoornis was vastgesteld, en die in februari 2002, op mijn negentiende, detransitioneerde. Mijn dysforie, die verlammend was en zelfmoordpogingen omvatte, was geworteld in diepgewortelde schaamte en angst voor mannen en mannelijkheid, versterkt door seksueel misbruik in mijn kindertijd en een feministische opvoeding die mannen als de schurken afschilderde. De dysforie verdampte toen ik besefte dat ik een vrouwelijke man kon zijn in plaats van een vrouw, en ik leef al meer dan twintig jaar gelukkig als gendernonconformistische homoseksuele man, werk als verpleegkundige en presenteer me vrouwelijk. Ik heb geen spijt van de detransitie en geen drang om opnieuw te transitioneren, al worstel ik nog met het woord 'man' en heb ik mijn geslacht nooit helemaal positief kunnen accepteren. Ik blijf actief in detrans-gemeenschappen, waar ik steun bied terwijl ik kritische opvattingen houd over genderideologie en het bevestigende zorgmodel.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and grew up in the North West of England in the 1990s as the only boy among three sisters. From around age four or five I was cross-dressing secretly, playing the princess in games, and I was always a quiet, sensitive child. My mother, raised in a misogynistic household, became a vocal feminist of the 60s and 70s and would attribute my misbehaviour to 'being a man' — 'Of course you did that, because you're a man.' I absorbed the message that men were the baddies: lazy, oafish, sex-obsessed, or dangerous. I developed an enormous dislike of men and a fear of becoming one.
I was groomed and sexually abused by a middle-aged family friend from around age eight, who targeted me but ignored my sisters. I was groomed and raped again at age twenty. I have been attacked, assaulted and robbed by strangers multiple times. These experiences compounded my association of the male sex with both victim and perpetrator.
I came out to a friend as gay at twelve. Around fourteen or fifteen I discovered the concept of transgenderism online — reading someone's transition journal — and my lifelong discomfort suddenly made sense. I was androphilic but also androphobic, which was wild. My dysphoria was crippling: my genitals felt like a tumour I needed off me, puberty felt like poisoning, I couldn't look in mirrors or hear my name without breaking down. My high school attendance in my final two years was 11%. I made suicide attempts. I was diagnosed with gender identity disorder at the Portman and Tavistock clinic in London in 1998, aged sixteen, after my mother noticed something was wrong and we went to our GP.
I socially transitioned from sixteen, changed my legal name and sex on my passport, and was put on puberty blockers at seventeen (around 1999-2000) after a required period of living socially as female. I was part of Mermaids UK when it was a small mailing list — there were hundreds of MTF and only one or two FTM. I had plans for surgery but the waiting lists were years long. I was 100% certain I was female — the only thing I'd ever been certain about.
Then, around age nineteen, after about five years of dysphoria and three to four years of transition, the dysphoria simply evaporated. Exposure to positive representations of feminine men — particularly 90s anime and manga with effeminate male characters whose femininity wasn't treated as a joke — showed me that being a feminine male was a real, viable option. One morning, feeling low and unable to face the stress of presenting as female, I decided to have a 'boy mode' day. I changed nothing about my appearance — still dressed femininely — but told myself internally 'today I'm male.' The imposter syndrome vanished immediately. It was the same euphoria as first presenting as female, but without hiding anything. I detransitioned in February 2002, aged nineteen, and never looked back.
I changed my name again to a unisex name via statutory declaration. My family were relieved; my mother whispered 'oh thank goodness.' I ghosted my adult clinic referral. I kept my entire wardrobe — almost all from the women's section — and continued presenting exactly the same way. I had 8-10 sessions of facial laser and 14 on my legs; the facial hair grew back fully, the leg hair patchily. The blockers stunted my late-teenage growth, which never fully recovered, but I'm glad of my flat chest and small frame. I take dutasteride and oral minoxidil for hair loss. I have no regrets about the physical changes.
I became a healthcare assistant in 2002 and trained as a nurse, registering in 2012. I've worked in nursing ever since, in a female-dominated profession. I do ballet, yoga, aerial hoop, HIIT, sewing, cross-stitch and board games. I share a house with my female best friend, also a nurse, for about fifteen years.
The dysphoria is essentially gone — the body dysphoria fully evaporated, the social dysphoria just got quieter. What remains is a lifelong struggle with the word 'man' and with being male. It took about fifteen to sixteen years after detransition before I could hear 'man' applied to myself without twitching, and I still prefer 'boy' or 'guy.' I've never managed to accept my sex as anything positive. I present in an overtly non-masculine way — pastel colours, feminine clothing, handbag, long hair until recently — partly as a lifelong strategy to distance myself from being perceived as a typical man. I'm intimidated by most men and have almost no male friends or colleagues; my social world is almost entirely women.
I'm gay and androphilic. Since detransition I've dated men, mostly bisexual men attracted to my femininity — what's academically called gynandromorphaphilia. Gay men generally won't touch me when I present femininely. Relationships tend to fizzle around six months; I have commitment issues. One boyfriend during transition drugged and raped me. I've pursued much older men my whole dating life, which my therapist suggested may be recreating my first childhood sexual experience.
I was diagnosed with autism as an adult after an ex-boyfriend who worked with autistic children pointed out my habits, but I don't actually believe I have it — my mother contradicted the childhood history and I think the clinic diagnosed me to placate me.
I've been active on r/detrans for several years, offering support and writing long analytical posts about gender, sex, and transition. I consider myself supportive of transition on an individual level but critical of it as a political movement and of the affirmation model. I no longer believe in gender as a concept — I see it as a matter of faith, unmeasurable and unprovable, while sex is a biological reality defined by gametes. I consider detransition to be fundamentally an internal acceptance of one's birth sex; everything else is cosmetic. I'm now in my early forties and, despite ongoing discomfort with maleness, I'm comfortable in my body and happy with my life.