Alle verhalen

Schreef tegen transitie van de andere kant — en detransitioneerde toen

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd408
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich niet meer als trans identificeert. Ik heb nooit een gedetailleerde tijdlijn van mijn eigen transitie gepost, maar van 2019 tot 2020 schreef ik uitgebreid als iemand aan de andere kant ervan, en betoogde dat dysforie een psychologisch symptoom is — cognitieve dissonantie, geïnternaliseerde homofobie en nood over hoe vrouwen worden behandeld — en niet een mismatch tussen geest en lichaam. Ik ging transitie zien als een winstgedreven industrie die teert op angst en vervreemding, en pleitte voor strengere toegangscontrole, screening op geestelijke gezondheid en leeftijdsgrenzen vóór elke medische ingreep. Ik heb in dit transcript geen operaties, hormoongebruik, vruchtbaarheidsproblemen, medische complicaties of suïcidale gedachten beschreven. Ik blijf kritisch over transitie zoals die nu wordt toegepast, en ik uit ook mijn verdriet over het zien van tieners en kinderen in deze ruimtes.

Volledig verhaal

I never wrote much about my own transition story directly on Reddit — most of what I posted was questions and arguments aimed at other people — but looking back at what I did write, it's clear where my head was at for those years. In March 2019 I started a thread asking FTM-identified people why they transitioned, what they expected to complete, and what kept their belief in 'transing' alive. I said I'd seen the surgery pictures of what they do to your body and was curious about motivations. That framing — surgery photos, bodily harm, motivations — tells me I was already skeptical and probably processing my own decision to stop. I don't have a clean timeline of my own medical steps in these posts. I never gave dates for when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, whether I took hormones, or when I detransitioned. What I can say is that by 2019 I was writing as someone firmly on the other side of it, and by 2020 I was arguing that dysphoria is 'a symptom and not the cause' — that it's really cognitive dissonance from looking at images and projecting yourself onto them. That's not an abstract theory for me; it reads like a description of something I went through. I told one commenter directly: 'you can always just spin it back and say you're a man who is transitioning into a woman? Technically, it's true.' I was pushing back on identity claims I no longer found convincing. In another thread I asked someone bluntly, 'What about womanhood depresses you?' and 'Is the way that your society makes you think women should behave, that depressed you?' — questions I was clearly also asking myself. I framed being female as simply being 'biologically different creatures from men,' which is how I'd come to settle the question for myself. I don't think I ever described my own family, my own therapy, or my own surgery history in these comments. What I did describe was a worldview. I believed transition was being sold as a cure-all by an industry that 'feeds off of anxiety and alienation,' and that addressing root causes like internalized homophobia would 'literally take money out of the hands of people who have sprung up to provide services for transitioning individuals.' I compared the whole thing to anorexia and body dysmorphic disorder, saying 'this isn't a physical problem, it's definitely a mental one with similarly severe overtones.' I wanted more gatekeeping, not less: 'I'm fine with going back to the 80s model. More mental health screening and tests. I also wish the wikihows on lying to therapists to get approved for hrt would be taken down. No one before the age of 21 should be getting cosmetic, life-altering surgeries or taking synthetic chemicals to alter their body for some internet ideal.' I was angry at what I saw as a system that took advantage of desperate people on both sides. I also defended Blanchard's AGP typology in long arguments in February 2020, insisting AGP exists and that the people who write the literature for trans people 'refuse to question/explore the underlying reasons for why people transition.' I defined HSTS as homosexual people whose dysphoria is 'caused by internalized homophobia' — a framework I clearly found personally meaningful. On a personal level, the closest I came to describing my own body distress was in a comment about someone who kept saying they couldn't live as a female: I asked 'What events or experiences have you associated with your birth self, that it physically affects you to be reminded of that fact? Did you grow up in an environment where an adult or parent figure constantly told you that it was a woman's duty to have children?' I was probing for upbringing-based causes, and I noted the person kept 'coming back to parenthood and the functions associated with that' while also saying they were gay. I told them 'it seems to me that there is something you don't want to face, and are just looping around.' I also told someone who was fixated on how future male partners would see them: 'Why are you so fixated on how you are perceived by potential future male partners? ... You do know that you can still present with that completely idgaf attitude as a girl, right?' That's advice I was giving from a place of having made peace with being female myself, though I never said explicitly how long that took or what it cost. I don't describe any surgeries, hormone durations, fertility concerns, or medical complications of my own in this transcript. I don't describe a diagnosis, a therapist by name, or a specific date of detransition. I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm. I don't describe a partner, children, or a career impact. What I do describe is a sustained, years-long campaign of skepticism — toward trans identity claims, toward the medical establishment, toward what I saw as a culture that pushed people toward transition for profit — and a firm belief that dysphoria is a psychological symptom rooted in internalized homophobia, trauma, and distorted self-image rather than a mismatch between mind and body. I was clearly active in detrans spaces from at least March 2019 through June 2020, and I engaged most intensely in early 2020. I recommended 'pique resilience' to someone else as a resource. I expressed real distress at seeing young people in these spaces: 'It hurts my heart every time a teenager comes on here. So damn young...' and about a child, 'this kid is gonna crack real bad under the pressure of being forced to perform all the time.' I advised a parent of a 12-year-old to limit internet access and gently question the child's beliefs rather than fight them directly. By the end of this record I was a detransitioned woman — female, no longer identifying as trans — who had come to see my own dysphoria as a mental health problem rooted in how women are treated and how I'd internalized that, and who wanted much stricter safeguards for anyone else considering transition.