Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw die eerder als non-binair identificeerde en tot de conclusie is gekomen dat een non-binaire identiteit niet echt bestaat. Ik denk niet meer na over gender of voornaamwoorden en ben gelukkiger, productiever en meer naar buiten gericht sinds ik ben gedesisteerd. Ik ben van zeer linkse opvattingen verschoven naar een gematigde, licht links georiënteerde middenpositie, al was desisten niet de belangrijkste drijfveer. Ik steun mensen die gelukkiger zijn door hun transitie, terwijl ik kritisch ben over activistisch autoritarisme en het gebrek aan debat in sommige queer-ruimtes. In dit transcript worden geen medische ingrepen, operaties of hormoongebruik vermeld.
Volledig verhaal
I used to identify as nonbinary, and I was one of those very leftwing postmodernist types — not quite "infinite genders," but I engaged with a lot of the gender discourse as a philosophical or theoretical debate, including the idea of biological sex as a social construct. Among my activist friends, the questions I had about gender would automatically have been seen as bad faith questions, so I kept them to myself for quite a while before I desisted.
Eventually I asked myself, "what would actually be different about my life if I identified as a woman instead of as non-binary?" and the answer was: nothing at all, except that I might be more relaxed in relation to other people and less obsessively introspective. All the mental energy I'd put into thinking about gender only got in the way of my interpersonal relationships. I no longer think nonbinary is real. I (still) don't have a gender identity. I know that people (accurately) read me as female, which they always did, and I don't worry about it anymore. I still have some of the same feelings that led me to identify as non-binary — sometimes I'd like to have been male, sometimes I'd like the magical ability to change my sex at will — but I just get on with my life, my interests and my career. I'm happier, more productive and more outward looking. Now I don't concern myself at all with how other people see me; I don't think about my pronouns or gender or anything like that. I find it healthier not to think about how to identify at all, just to do the things I enjoy and recognise that people will view me through my actions rather than any labels.
I don't miss the authoritarianism of the activist spaces I was in. I've disliked trans activists using intersex people as a gotcha in their arguments since before I desisted, and I have never once seen trans activists actually supporting intersex activists. I find something very Evangelical about the brittleness and rigidity of some activist spaces — they're self righteous and insecure. The older trans people I know are generally much more live and let live. I don't want a big anti LGBT backlash but they're making it more likely. I think it is essential to avoid social groups that don't allow questions, debate or disagreement: within them, you either give up your critical thinking or become very lonely. I really appreciate that there are different viewpoints on the detrans sub I post in and I've seen disagreements but no pile-ons; I wouldn't visit it if it was transphobic or hostile to debate.
Losing any kind of community is painful, but it does force you to focus on what is right for you and hopefully makes you better at thinking critically and finding more compassionate, intellectually open people to be around. I believe there are people who are or would be happier for having transitioned and I support them in doing so. I recommend finding trans spaces and friends that are comfortable with intellectual and political diversity, and I think intergenerational friendships are a good thing.
On presentation: I'm not super feminine, but I found it quite a relief to go back to wearing women's clothes because they'd been designed for my body shape — trying to find menswear that I liked and that fit properly was always hard work. I suggested to someone else that a pull toward femininity after trying to be masculine for a long time is probably a reaction against that, plus some comfort and external validation in gender conformity, and that transitioning and detransitioning can both be lonely experiences. I also advised taking things slowly when someone described numbness in the days after stopping, suggesting they might be grieving the time and emotional energy they put into transition.
My political position is a bit different from what it was when I identified as trans, but my desistance was not the main driver of that change. I was very leftwing; now I'm more of a normie liberal/centrist, probably slightly left-leaning. These days I'm pretty moderate. I didn't become more religious. I think it is generally unwise to go straight from one in-group identity into another.