Alle verhalen

Vrouwelijk, niet vrouw, en weg uit de groep

Man · Gedesisteerd935
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben als man geboren en leefde mijn hele tienerleven als trans vrouw voordat ik desisteerde, nadat ik besefte dat ik vrouwelijk was en niet vrouw, en dat ik een ander persoon had willen zijn en niet mijn lichaam wilde corrigeren. Ik maakte geen onomkeerbare medische veranderingen en begon nooit met HRT, deels omdat mijn moeder voorzichtig was en deels omdat ik een trans-identificerende groep verliet die me negatief beïnvloedde. Ik identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde man en heb kritische opvattingen over de transgemeenschap, de eicultuur en verwante ideologieën. Mijn sociale leven heeft geleden: ik ben met bijna iedereen overhoop komen te liggen over ideologische verschillen en heb nog maar één goede vriend over, waardoor ik me soms eenzaam voel. Af en toe heb ik nog niet-seksuele fantasieën over vrouw zijn, maar ik ervaar ze niet als dysforie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male into a family that was heavily female-dominated. My mother was surprised when I turned out to be a boy, my father died when I was very young, both grandfathers were already senile during my childhood, and other male relatives were distant, so I never had a male figure in my life and was always surrounded by women. Growing up I envied the women around me — watching my mother dress up in pretty clothes and makeup for events while I was stuck with pants and a dress shirt, hearing about my cousins' sleepovers I couldn't attend because I was a boy, and dreading clothes shopping because my options felt boring and repetitive. I had feminine interests: mermaids, fairies, wanting to play the princess on the playground, always choosing female video game characters because I thought they looked cooler. I wasn't into sports, fitness, or cars; my mother tried to get me into Boy Scouts but it didn't last. Most of my friends were girls and I never really knew how to talk to other boys. When my mother told me my father had always wanted a son, that sealed it for me — I was raised Christian and concluded God had planned me to be a woman but made me male because my father asked. With a mix of rebellion, feeling out of place, and some self-hatred, I decided to transition. I lived my entire teenage life as a trans woman, which I now describe as putting on 'essentially a drag persona of my repressed femininity.' I came to realize I wasn't female, just feminine — I didn't want to be a woman, I just wanted to feel like I was part of the puzzle. I'm glad I reached that conclusion before making any drastic changes I'd regret, implying I detransitioned before medical intervention. I also recall that a group I was in convinced me to hate my mom because she was cautious about signing me up for HRT day one rather than immediately affirming; she wasn't against it, she just wanted me to be sure. After leaving that group I started realizing how many false ideas I'd been influenced with. I chose to keep my name after detransitioning partly because it fit me and people were already used to calling me it. Since detransitioning I've had occasional fantasies about being a woman again — picturing myself as a woman doing mundane things, which makes me feel calm, and feeling envy when I see beautiful women — but I'm sure it's not sexual and I don't think it's dysphoria; I desisted because I realized I wanted to be a different person entirely, not correct a body mistake. I wonder if these feelings relate to dissatisfaction with my life's direction or a lack of masculinity around me. I've considered exploring my gender again but get a sick feeling thinking about re-entering trans spaces. I'm critical of egg culture and trans representation in media, annoyed by claims that it doesn't exist, and I've discussed AGP and porn addiction as real phenomena. Socially, I've had falling outs with pretty much everyone over ideological differences; my old trans/progressive friend group wouldn't like the real me, and I quietly left them because I realized they wouldn't want me around if they knew my views. I have one best friend I still talk to. I miss the social credit that identifying as trans gave me — instant friends and respect among progressive people — but I can't go back to pretending. I feel lonely and sometimes wish I could turn off the critical part of my brain to have a decent social life again. I now believe trans identity is largely a product of strict gender roles and that if society didn't stigmatize gender nonconformity, trans would be far more niche or nonexistent.