Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw die testosteron nam en later mijn vrouwelijke sekse ging zien als een neutraal biologisch feit dat niets van me vraagt. Ik wijs genderrollen en vrouwelijkheid nu af als kapitalistische constructies en adviseer anderen in detransitieruimtes de transitiemindset los te laten, hobby's te vinden, van sociale media af te blijven en radicaal-feministische literatuur te lezen. Ik worstelde met obsessieve zelfreflectie en doorspiralen, wat verbeterde toen ik gemeenschap vond met andere masculiene, voormalige transvrouwen. Ik ben kritisch over transgeneeskunde als schadelijk en over zowel transactivisme als conservatieve critici zoals Matt Walsh. Ik beschrijf in dit verhaal geen operaties, vruchtbaarheidsproblemen of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I have always been female — that is a fact that no amount of testosterone, a beard, or a deep voice can change. I came to that realization after I had taken testosterone, and I describe myself as desisted: I stopped living as a trans man and returned to living as a woman, though the process was gradual rather than sudden.
I don't give a detailed timeline of when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, or exactly how long I was on hormones, but I do know that I had taken testosterone and that I had at some point socially inhabited the role of "girl" in a way that felt inauthentic to me. Calling myself a woman didn't come easy to me at first; it came bit by bit after I desisted. I also note that I kept a masculine name and that people around me have called me brother or boyfriend — I mention that "plenty of women do (myself included lol)."
What helped me most was spending time with other masculine women, many of them former trans people, and finding solidarity with them. I also found radical feminist ideas and literature important: I came to see gender roles as regressive and harmful, and I came to believe that "society is fucked up and gender is shit and IT needs dismantling and not you." I now think of femininity as a capitalist invention — "an amalgamation of products and procedures" — and I reject the idea that being a woman requires performing femininity. I tell others in similar situations to lose the transition mindset, find productive hobbies, do something with their hands, get out into nature, cut screen time and social media (especially TikTok), and stop engaging in trans discussions until they feel better.
I have struggled with obsessive self-reflection and spiraling — what I describe as "very animal in a cage behavior" — and I recognize that pattern in others too. I don't describe formal diagnoses, but I do refer to "existing mental conditions" in the abstract when warning someone else away from hormones, and I say that living in a deeply misogynistic society is "literally traumatic to be a woman nowadays." I recommend radical feminist literature as a way for women to process that trauma.
I don't describe surgeries, fertility concerns, medical complications, or family reactions in this transcript. On the medical side, I do point to another detransitioned person (Isaac Uncooked) as an example of medical negligence in transition and the medical issues hormones caused him, and I tell others that going on injections will "aggravate your existing mental conditions and ruin your health."
My sexuality matters to how I frame things: I use the phrase "It's called sexuality, not genderuality," and I criticize what I see as straight people co-opting labels meant for same-sex attracted people. I also criticize GNC people being "othered" by new identity categories.
My attitude toward transition for others is strongly critical. I tell people that "these 'feelings of being internally male' aren't real" because you can't feel like a sex — "You just are." I believe many women have "given up and embraced the lie that their discomfort with their sex has to be medicated." I'm skeptical of mainstream trans advocacy and equally skeptical of conservative figures like Matt Walsh, whom I say is "not an ally to women or LGB people" — "The enemy of my enemy is not my friend." I don't describe formal activism, but I do actively counsel others in detransition and desistance spaces and encourage them to fight gender roles.
I don't describe a specific intensity of regret in this transcript, but the overall thrust of my writing is that I wish I (and others) had avoided the transition path entirely, and I focus on helping others avoid what I see as the same mistake. My current identity is a desisted woman — female, gender-nonconforming, and critical of both gender ideology and traditional femininity.