Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. My gender confusion started online: seeing the claim 'cis people don't question their gender' on Instagram at around 15 is what began my downfall, as I put it. I had some bad experiences in my life that made me realise that no matter how much I changed about myself, without surgery I still had to go through all the bullshit females have to go through. I describe myself as FtMtF — I transitioned and then detransitioned.
A lot of my social dysphoria came from interests and traits I had that I'd been told were incompatible with being a woman. I'm super into history — not in a superficial way, but in an 'I must know the models of every aircraft' way — and all my life only men shared those interests with me; the women in my life only liked history on a superficial level. I thought to myself, 'I have all these things about me that are not what a woman can be so I must not be a woman.' I also had lots of physical characteristics and interests that made me feel alienated from womanhood. I now see that as reaffirming to society that women can only be a certain way.
I was sexually assaulted by a trans woman, after trusting them 'like they were female.' That experience made me realise that, in my words, no matter how much we play pretend, biology can never be denied, and that MtF people follow the same patterns of sexual assault as biological men. It made me realise the value of female-only spaces. I also recall thinking, when my friend's partner got facial feminisation surgery for free, 'fuck I'm a female and I'd love free facial feminisation surgery' — which led me to conclude that most females would want free face surgery, and that this reflects unachievable standards for women. Being female should be enough to make me a woman; that is the perspective I hold now.
I now identify as a gender-non-conforming woman — 'fuck shaving my legs' — but I hold that there is an innate biological power imbalance. I feel a solidarity in womanhood, defending each other from sexual predators: that look on the bus from another woman asking if you're okay with an old man talking to you. I say that no matter how deep in transition a MtF is, they will never understand the fear of being raped and impregnated. I find it sick that most MtF people I've spoken to describe catcalling as 'validating/gender affirming,' because it shows they see womanhood as objectification.
On the question of gender and sex being separate, I think our current idea is flawed; people claim it is scientifically proven, and it is not. I argue that saying 'I cannot be a man because I don't want to conform to being aggressive/dominating, so I must be a woman' reinforces to society that men and women HAVE to be a certain way. There are differences between sexes, but society's expectations have destroyed our understanding of them. I advise people considering transition to first consider expressing themselves simply as an effeminate man — effeminate meaning expressing yourself in a way society associates with womanhood, man being your sex — and I warn that lying to yourself and trying to convince everyone around you that you are not what you physically objectively are will only lead to more pain and dysphoria. I think surgery and hormones have so many negative effects that they are not worthwhile unless they are your only option. I ask people to imagine their younger self seeing them a few years on: would they rather see nothing changed about you but you expressing yourself however you want, or see you after hormones and surgery?
I also encourage working through hyper-fixations rather than running away from them. I write lots, never show anyone, just write whatever is in my mind, because getting it on paper lets me look at my own thoughts from an outside perspective. I tell people to backtrack their thoughts and ask whether a desired surgery is practical or cosmetic and whether the downsides outweigh the upsides, and not to make decisions before they are ready and confident. I've advised others that they will still be the same woman regardless of whether they go ahead with surgery.
I've also commented on how people read gender presentation superficially: I felt someone was 'clearly female' but people were calling her masc just because she had short hair and wasn't wearing makeup, and that with long hair or makeup there would be no questioning. On giving advice to people considering transition, I take a 'you can lead a horse to water' view — sometimes people just want to do the opposite of what everyone tells them, and it may be a lesson they have to learn for themselves.
I've found it validating to be able to express my opinion on r/detrans without being shut down. I don't describe any ongoing medical needs, fertility concerns, or specific surgeries of my own beyond the general FtMtF trajectory.