Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (Valentina), als vrouw geboren, die zich als FTM identificeerde en slechts ongeveer twee maanden testosteron nam voordat ik in augustus 2022 om gezondheidsredenen stopte. Sinds het stoppen heb ik milde depressie, paniekaanvallen, laag zelfbeeld, aanhoudende haarveranderingen en word ik voor een man aangezien, en ik ben een psycholoog gaan zien. Mijn relatie met mijn homo-geïdentificeerde vriend is door mijn detransitie zwaar onder druk komen te staan, met zijn stilte, spot en verwarring over mijn identiteit. Ik kijk nu kritisch naar hoe ik richting transitie werd geleid, grotendeels door trauma, en ik geef medische professionals de schuld voor onvoldoende informatie. Ik identificeer me nu als bi meisje en benoem mezelf niet meer in termen van gender of seksuele geaardheid.
Volledig verhaal
I'm Valentina, and I was born female. I identified as trans and lived as an FTM for a period, but I stopped testosterone in August 2022 after only about two months on it, because of health issues. I'm 26 years old (as of early 2023). I no longer define myself as a man — I said plainly that I don't define myself anymore, not even about sexual orientation, because I think it was ridiculous for me to continue with the whole thing.
My detransition was partly medical: I stopped T because of health issues, and I've been recovering mentally since August 2022. I had amenorrhoea, though not because of T. My endocrinologist told me while I was on T that certain things were safe, which I now look back on with some skepticism. Physical effects I've noticed: my hair is growing back but not as much as before, and it's not as soft and shiny as it used to be — it looks dry and worse than before. I've been doing oiling and repairing treatments, and I asked the community for advice about whether the hair effects might be irreversible. My voice didn't change since I was only on T for two months. One thing that distresses me is that people still mistake me for a man all the time, even though my voice didn't change.
Mentally, I've been going through a mild depression since stopping testosterone, and my self-esteem dropped significantly after I came off T. After almost a year off, I decided I needed to see a psychologist to help me get through this and to figure out why my self-esteem is so low since I stopped testo. I've had panic attacks. I described myself as still mentally recovering more than a year after stopping.
My relationship has been a major source of strain. I've been with my boyfriend since 2021 — this was my first relationship with a guy. He knew me as FTM and defined himself as a gay male (he is cis). He came out as gay when he was 18 and was pretty sure about it; he met me when he was 20 and was going to be 22 in April 2023. After I stopped T, he struggled to see me as his girlfriend. He craves sex and appreciates my body, but when I feel bad about the effects of T he closes up like a hedgehog and puts on a wall of silence, so I stopped bringing it up. When we did talk, he told me he is both angry and sad about my detransition sometimes. I told him it was painful because I felt he hated me for who I am. I was surprised he perceived me as an entirely different person just because I changed my name back to my birth name. He once told me I was transphobic because I reject the fact that I could be a man.
There are troubling dynamics in the relationship. He and his brothers make misogynistic and derogatory comments about girls they know, except older 'motherly' ones. He likes women who look like men, like bodybuilders. He said between me and a man he would choose a guy for sex, but for a relationship he would choose me, which is confusing. I suggested he might be a bi guy, but he hates being called bi and reacted badly. He mocks me in front of other people — for example, his bandmaster asked if I could play percussion in his band and he called me a 'klutz' and said I can't do anything, a joke made to laugh at me. During my panic attacks he has fallen silent and seemed judgmental. He enjoyed me more when I looked strong and more masculine. His family didn't accept his coming out as gay, didn't accept me as a trans guy, and now barely accepts me as a girl. We are Italian. I stay partly because he was the first person who loved me and desired me as a partner, and I don't feel obligated to leave.
On sexuality and its roots, I reflected that I loved gay men mainly because they didn't require me to 'give' them something I didn't want to give (sex!), which stems from a bias that a heterosexual man may abuse or rape you just for his attraction to females, and usually from traumatic experiences and beliefs. I now describe myself as a bi girl. I feel I'm way behind my peers in terms of romantic relationships, which makes me self-conscious.
On transition more broadly, I've become quite critical. I told someone who took T for 8 years that 'this is what indoctrination does to people' and was happy for their self-discovery, saying they 'finally snapped out of that terrible state.' I said many of us were led to this path by obvious trauma, and that it's one thing to be traumatised and another to say transitioning is totally possible and healthy and should be done ASAP. I said if doctors had told people properly what kind of damage this does, people might still have been in pain but could have avoided testosterone. I also warned someone about combining hormones with T, saying they should do more research and tell people, and that hormones can wreck your feelings. I've been supportive and encouraging to others in the community, telling one person they're a beautiful guy no matter how they dress or how many hormones they took, and telling another that early teenage years are bad for nearly every female and that they could still be a pretty woman and have a baby. I offered to talk with people who need support.