Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar als tiener mijn borsten wilde afsnijden, de puberteit haatte en over zelfmoord nadacht. Nu, bijna 30, accepteer ik mijn vrouw-zijn volledig en besef ik dat mijn echte probleem het mens-zijn was, mijn beperkingen, kwetsbaarheid en eindig leven, en niet vrouw-zijn. Geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, seksuele objectivering in de puberteit en een ernstige beperking dreven mijn ellende. Ik ben kritisch over transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, en waarschuw anderen voor zenuwschade door operaties en voor spijt. Ik haat mijn lichaam niet meer en mijn mentale toestand is met de leeftijd sterk verbeterd.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I have always been a woman, though I never transitioned — my story is one of desisting and coming to terms with my sex rather than medically changing it.
When I hit pre-puberty and puberty, being trans wasn't even a thing yet, but I still wanted to cut my breasts off. I thought they were disgusting, weirdly positioned, and too small. I hated my new body shape, thought I was fat, and wanted to go back to being a child. I didn't want curves or prominent nipples. I hated wearing bras so much that I'd wear a vest over a t-shirt to avoid it — I still hate wearing bras. I was a tomboy and my parents hated it (I still am one). I never wanted or liked children (still don't), and I didn't want a period (still don't). During that period I contemplated suicide and was filled with depression, anxiety, and anger.
My whole life I thought I was big, bulky, stocky, with broad shoulders, and I was happy I wasn't taller because I feared looking beastly. My mom was the one who told me I had broad shoulders like her. I have a partner now who calls me petite and genuinely sees me that way, which seriously makes me question my own perception of my body.
What I eventually realized is that my problem was with being human, not with being female. Male or female, I would be unhappy, because my greatest disappointment is being a weak flesh-and-creature with flaws, disabilities, limitations, and a finite lifespan. I theorize that a lot of people are trying to escape their humanity but are focusing on the tree of sex/gender instead of the forest. I consider myself a realist; I see life as a series of distractions and coping mechanisms while we wait for our bodies and our loved ones' bodies to fail and die.
A major contributor for me was internalized misogyny and the unfair expectations placed on women. Being an unwilling sexual object when puberty hits — having to groom a certain way and hide body parts — was stressful, and I wanted to escape it my entire teenage years. I was taught to be disgusted by how my body naturally was: people made fun of women's bodies as "fishy" or "roast beef" and I internalized that. If your breasts weren't the right shape it was disgusting; you were fat if you couldn't wear certain clothes. I had hobbies not perceived as feminine (I still have them), and I dressed in men's clothes because I hated women's clothing — usually revealing, thin, and itchy. Pretending to be male would let me escape all of that in theory, but it wasn't right.
I also have a severe disability that makes it hard to do things, and I feel lesser because of it — like a leech and a waste — because I can't be as productive. I tie much of my value as a woman to my productivity. I've had multiple necessary surgeries for health issues and suffered unexpected consequences from them, including nerve damage: I have many surgical scars, one huge scar with a really sensitive painful spot, and another surgical spot that is permanently itchy. I have damage to my body from multiple sources. I've also had significant weight gain and loss leaving my body scarred and saggy in places. Laser hair removal didn't work for me — almost all the hair grew back — and I'm left doing electrolysis instead.
I never had top surgery or hormones, but I have strong opinions about them from the outside. I've told others considering chest surgery that it causes severe nerve damage and reduced sensation, and that a voluntary amputation of a body part a partner may be attracted to can be a relationship deal-breaker. I've advised people to save up for breast reduction if growth bothers them, comparing it to genetic gynecomastia in men. I've also argued against the term "chestfeeding" and warned teens against interfering with puberty, saying I would never allow myself to make permanent decisions at 15 looking back from twice that age.
On therapy, I once told someone their therapist's behavior was "unprofessional grooming behavior" and that a therapist's job is not to tell you what to think. I'm wary of trans Discord servers, which I consider outrageously over-moderated.
The turning point came with age. I'm almost 30 now and I'm a completely different person. I accept my womanhood and don't question it at all; I don't feel the need to prove anything. I think at 25 I finally stopped freaking out — I consider 25 roughly the age I became mentally "complete." I don't hate my body anymore. I wear some unisex clothing. I understand my body rather than hate it. I still reject a lot of expected behavior, dress, and appearance, but I understand I'm female the same way I'm a brunette even though I wish I weren't. I've never been interested in having children.
I'm politically homeless but consider myself center-left, and I believe people are shades of gray rather than team-bound. I don't have activism of my own, but I do push back on transition for others, particularly minors, and I try to reassure struggling teens that they're normal and will be okay later. I don't hate my body anymore, and my regret is more about lost time and the pain of my younger self than about any medical intervention I underwent.