Alle verhalen

Identificeerde zich als man, nooit getransitioneerd, nog steeds kritisch

Man · Gedesisteerd1,5K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerd persoon die zich als man identificeerde maar besefte dat ik geen vrouw was die in een mannenlichaam was geboren, alleen iemand die geloofde gelukkig te kunnen zijn als vrouw geboren, en ik geloof niet dat ik een operatie nodig had, ondanks dat mij dat verteld is. Ik heb in dit verslag nooit een medische transitie ondergaan of beschreven. Ik ben kritisch over medische transitie bij jongeren, egg-cultuur en wat ik zie als misinformatie over transitieresultaten en detransitie. Ik heb een vriendin en heb gepleit voor een eerlijk gesprek over de nadelen van transitie.

Volledig verhaal

I first posted in May 2021 asking about people's opinions on "gender" vs "sex," and by May 2022 I was writing posts arguing that this community is misunderstood by trans people despite me having no problems with trans folk. I've consistently said that accusing a trans or detrans person of being transphobic is ridiculous denial, and I've pushed back on the idea that a neovagina is identical to female reproductive organs. In December 2022 I made a post about the question "difference between vaginas and neovaginas," calling the misinformation harmful. By October 2023 I was posting about the most untrue or harmful things said about transitioning. For me, one of the worst claims is that FTM bottom surgery gives you a vagina that even gynecologists can't tell apart from a biological woman's. I also strongly object to young teens being told they can just take puberty blockers and hormones to "see if it's for you." Every young person is confused about their place in the world, and that can't be explained away as gender dysphoria, even if the only symptom is feeling like being born a different sex would make life easier. As a kid I wished I was born a hot popular girl, and I'm glad I wasn't encouraged to see that as a definite sign I needed hormones - I keep it 18+. I also dislike how much attractiveness matters in the trans community, where not passing after a year of hormones gives people extreme dysphoria, and I found a thread where someone had suicidal dysphoria over how gorgeous young teens who transitioned early look - I called that creepy. I've argued that there shouldn't be only one solution - transitioning - and that treatment should be done in a variety of ways. I've criticized doctors who prescribe hormones without firm, thorough warnings about life-altering effects, and I've said the side effects are so plentiful I could hardly list them all, with many changes not reversible by just quitting. I've said being truthful and careful about who should be on HRT is what needs to happen, and that an unbelievable number of people have questioned their gender at some point - just because someone questions their gender is definite proof of absolutely nothing. I've expressed worry about people being groomed via misinformation and about puberty blockers being downplayed. In December 2023 I asked about negative side effects of HRT with estrogen and testosterone, saying side effects are downplayed or swept under the rug in Discord servers and subreddits. That same month I posted "Desisters - why did YOU desist?" and shared my own realization: that I'm not a woman born in a man's body, but a man who believed he could be happy if he had been born a woman - however that doesn't mean I shouldn't like who I am and it certainly doesn't mean I require surgery, despite being told so. I also said I never have and will never accept the ending of friendships and shunning of desisters and detransitioners. I've told others they clearly needed help to become well-adjusted and stable first, and that many sessions should have explored what makes someone think they need to transition ASAP, possibly it could have been treated without hormones or surgery. At the end of December 2023 I posted about "egg" culture, saying I dislike it because it helps people who need mental help that isn't transitioning go down the wrong path and end up on puberty blockers or hormones despite not needing them. I've described egg culture as a no-win setup: if you say you are trans, hooray we helped you figure it out; if you say you aren't, you're still in denial but you'll get there. I've said transition is sometimes described as a miracle cure when the opposite couldn't be more true, and that government payment is another selling point. I've asked why detransition evidence would need hiding if trans ideology were rooted in solid science, and said people considering transition benefit from reading detransitioners because this community is honest about the downsides of transition. In July 2024 I posted about a woman's experience being invalidated in trans spaces on a thread about "period envy," arguing that only people born female can genuinely have valid takes on periods, and that envying periods is offensive to women suffering period-related problems. I've said I wouldn't dare claim to know better about periods since I don't have a womb, and I've expressed concern about people taking hormones to recreate menstrual cycles, saying hormones are serious medication with real medical consequences. I've also said I miss simplicity - "Men have penises and women have vaginas" is what I think should be taught in school, not a world of acronyms and fluidity. I've noted that saying you'll never truly switch your biological sex gets you instabanned in trans spaces. I have a girlfriend - I've mentioned her suffering from painful periods and said it's painful to watch as a loving boyfriend. I've also commented on relationship dynamics, saying that when an ex comes back it usually means they thought you were easy to replace.