Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich eerder als non-binair identificeerde, nooit als transman. Ik kwam tot het inzicht dat mijn dysforie geworteld was in eetstoornissen, seksueel geweld en de zelfhaat die daarop volgde, en besloot mezelf niet langer non-binair te noemen omdat ik wilde dat het begrip 'vrouw' ook mij omvatte. Ik woon in Scandinavië en heb genuanceerde, soms kritische opvattingen over de huidige transbeweging, deels aangewakkerd door onderzoek naar autogynefilie bij man-naar-vrouw-transitie. Ik vind het moeilijk om polyamoureuze partners te vinden die mijn desisteren begrijpen, en ik ben alleen op een rustige, zakelijke manier open.
Volledig verhaal
I never identified as a trans man; I identified as non-binary because I could never relate to some sense of womanhood. Looking back, I think that disconnect was mostly driven by eating disorders. I've never felt like a woman in some deep, essential way, but I've come to the conclusion that feeling like me is feeling like a woman — because I am one. I decided I would no longer define myself as non-binary, even though I sometimes still feel that way internally. I can hate my breasts all I want; it doesn't make me less of a woman, it just makes me a bit sad.
I think my dysphoria mainly came from eating disorders, sexual assault, and the self-hatred that followed. It wasn't so much that I realized I'm "not trans" — it's more that I realized I wanted the concept of "woman" to have space for me too. It felt horrible to have to change who I was and cast myself out from womanhood because of my inner disconnect with my sense of sex, if there even is one.
On being out: if anyone asks, I'll say something like "I've never felt like a woman," and add that I don't think it should be necessary to feel a specific way to be one, then leave it at that. I don't elaborate further.
I live in the Nordics, in Europe. I'm not really leftist in the American sense — the left here isn't necessarily woke or liberal; that's separate, social liberalism. Even when Norway stopped puberty blockers for girls, most people on the left here agreed it was sensible.
I've thought a lot about the causes of transition in others too. I recall research from roughly ten years ago suggesting autogynephilia-type attraction was the driving factor for about half of male-to-female transitions, and that the researcher was cancelled and shamed for it. I also mentioned research from a couple of years back — heard about in a podcast about scientists being hunted for their results — showing that a large group of people who transition male-to-female do so because they identify with the "female role" when aroused. I noted that this isn't necessarily bad, since sexuality is vital and feeling aligned physically with your sexual self matters for mental health, but it does mean the idea has merit. That interview was actually what made me start to doubt the current trans movement.
I have a nuanced view of detransition: I think you can absolutely be trans for a while, thrive living as the other sex, and still change your mind and detransition without it changing the fact that you did thrive or that you were trans. People deal in absolutes, and acknowledging this makes people uncomfortable.
On gender and society, I believe society makes women weak — we don't have power or agency — but the answer isn't to change your position from male to female; it's to dismantle the system. I said "fuck the system for making us feel such hatred towards our own sex" — the box for men is tiny and horrible too, just in a different way.
I've advised other detransitioners to take small steps without announcements, that many people will just be happy for you. I've recommended therapy, noting that trauma isn't overused as a concept in real-life therapy, only online, and that being older gives more capacity for self-reflection. I've also told younger people that you can be as masculine or boyish as you want with a female body, that you don't have to transition to have short hair or dress manly, and there's plenty of space to be butch without it. I've warned that disordered eating can fuel gender dysphoria and should be discussed with a therapist.
I've struggled socially as a detransitioned person: I've had a kind of half-opposite problem finding polyamorous partners who understand or will listen to my views around my desisting — everyone is super "progressive" and doesn't want to complicate things.
I don't think trans people are a monolith or that most do anything harmful; it's a very small group. I've pushed back against mischaracterizations of the political left and against claims that biological women have lower sex drives than men.