Alle verhalen

Sinds 2019 een bondgenoot op r/detrans, en daarvoor twee keer verbannen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd395
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een bondgenoot, geen gedetransitioneerd persoon, die sinds november 2019 reageert op r/detrans, detransitioners steunt en me verzet tegen vijandigheid jegens bondgenoten. Ik ben kritisch over aspecten van transitiegeneeskunde, met name pubertijdremmers, levenslange hormoonafhankelijkheid na operaties en de prikkels van de farmaceutische industrie, en over beweringen die ik als desinformatie zie, zoals dat trans vrouwen menstrueren. Ik ben van een ander subreddit verbannen omdat ik beweringen over dilatatie en menstruatie in twijfel trok. Ik heb geen vermelde persoonlijke transitiegeschiedenis en blijf individuen in de gemeenschap steunen, terwijl ik kritisch blijf over transitie in het algemeen.

Volledig verhaal

I have been an active commenter in the r/detrans community since late 2019, and from the start I have identified myself as an ally rather than a detransitioned person myself. When I first joined the subreddit in early November 2019, I posted a comment about dating realities for detransitioned people — noting that many straight men would be put off upon learning someone was born with a penis, or by the fact they cannot have biological children — and I was met with hostility. I pushed back, saying I had only joined that day and had commented only a few times, and asked people to "miss me with the attitude, I am note your enemy." I repeatedly described myself as an ally, and in July 2020 I asked the moderators directly what counted as detransition advice versus general support, giving the example of whether I could encourage a person going FTMTF who wanted to wear a skirt: "Just so I am clear and do not overstep as an ally... pls not mad." I said I did not comment much but liked the "kind atmosphere" and did not want to get banned, and I described the subreddit as wholesome, "Giant group of friends just being friendly and showing love to everyone in the group." I have no stated personal history of transition, dysphoria, hormones, or surgery in this transcript. Much of my commentary has been conceptual and critical of certain aspects of transition medicine and of transgender activism. In June 2020 I agreed with the idea that "giving name to everything under the trans umbrella has promised a solution to many that isnt actually there." I expressed concern about puberty blockers, saying what bothers me most is "the idea that blockers are not harmful for anyone long term." I voiced strong suspicion of the pharmaceutical industry's financial incentives, arguing that the pharma industry makes money off each trans person for life, especially after bottom surgery, and that once a person has had bottom surgery they can no longer produce their own sex hormones and must pay for hormone replacement for life — "Even if they detransition big pharma will get to continue to exploit and victimize them." I said I believed big pharma was preventing studies from being truly publicized. I also commented approvingly about a lawsuit (in November 2019) and about the possibility that Jazz Jennings might sue, saying "if Jazz Sues many will sue." I was banned from another subreddit for asking how dilation after surgery correlates to understanding menstruation, and I was frustrated by claims from some trans women that they experience periods or understand menstruation through dilation. I argued at length in June 2020 that trans women do not menstruate, writing firmly: "Transwomen do not experience menstruation. This is not an opinion." I also expressed skepticism about claims that male bodies on estrogen experience cyclical period symptoms without a uterus, asking for sources and concluding such symptoms would be "At best psycho somatic symptoms." I have been generally supportive and encouraging toward detransitioners in the community. In May 2020 I wrote a long, warm reply to someone overwhelmed by regret after surgeries, telling them "There is life beyond your body" and that "Your body may be damaged but much of it can be healed and the rest can still be lived with." I shared my own coping method for regret: "Whenever I feel regret it helps me to imagine how much worse. Its morbid but it kinda works in a way." I told a woman who had had a double mastectomy that "You're still a woman. Yiu lost your breasts to an illness. Just mental instead of physical" and suggested reconstructive surgery exists. I praised another person for "recovering from trauma you've only just begun to be able to recognize" and for learning "to be you as you are, not what trauma society and dysphoria tell you you should be." I also encouraged a pregnant person, saying "You're going to be q wonderful mother" and that confidence is what's sexy. I reacted negatively to hostility and gatekeeping within gender-critical spaces. I recommended blocking a particularly toxic commenter, called out harshness toward allies, defended detransitioners who don't blog or have social media as still being "real," and pushed back on people judging others' choices of underwear. When GenderCritical was banned from Reddit in June 2020 I said "Yeah gendercritocal Is gone and idk how I feel." I suggested faith-based and liberal Christian counselors as options for someone seeking help in December 2019. I have expressed worry about the long-term harms of medical transition, particularly blockers and lifelong hormone dependence after surgery, and I have been critical of what I see as overreach and misinformation in some trans advocacy, but I have also been consistently warm and encouraging toward individuals in the detransition community who are struggling.