Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een man uit Zuidoost-Azië die obsessief nadenkt over transitioneren maar niet is getransitioneerd, en die zich momenteel identificeert als man die schommelt tussen masculiene en feminiene gevoelens en van zijn mannelijkheid en baard houdt. Ik experimenteerde met crossdressen, wat toenam op SSRI's en stopte toen ik op antipsychotica werd gezet voor een denkstoornis met synchroniciteit en paranoia, deels gelinkt aan LSD-gebruik; nadat ik ongeveer een jaar geleden met antipsychotica stopte kwam het crossdress-verlangen terug maar de paranoïde synchroniciteit niet. Ik ervaar wat ik gender-euforie noem in plaats van dysforie, en ik worstel met schuld over een seksuele vernederingskink die volgens mij in strijd is met mijn masculiene neigingen. Ik ben niet gedetransitioneerd maar ga kritisch om met de gemeenschap, met het argument dat binair transseksualisme een medische constructie is en de vraag of gender-nonconformiteit een psychische ziekte is.
Volledig verhaal
I am male and have been thinking about transitioning for the past few months, quite obsessively at times. I found the r/detrans community and it scared me about the idea of transitioning — I just don't want to do something I'll end up regretting and then have to come back and rant about it. I've experimented with cross-dressing and I like the idea of switching between masculine and feminine as per my mood. I feel I can pull off being a man equally well, so I like my masculinity and my beard, and I oscillate between the feelings, which is why transition doesn't make sense to me. I like my body as a man but I also get very excited thinking of myself as a woman — I'd call that gender euphoria rather than dysphoria, because dysphoria implies hating your own body.
Medically, I was on SSRIs, which I believe made my gender dysphoria more intense and made me start cross-dressing; I also felt kind of manic and impulsive on them, and whatever I was doing got very dangerous. I was then given antipsychotics because I had a thought disorder and was experiencing a lot of synchronicity — everything around me felt related to me, movies, TV shows, music, even writing on someone's t-shirt felt like a message to me. After taking the antipsychotics all of that stopped, and my desire for experimenting with my gender stopped too. The dose was pretty low but it still happened. I stopped taking them because all my desires went away — I didn't feel like doing anything and would just sleep all day with no motivation. Once I stopped, the desire for cross-dressing returned. It's now close to a year since I stopped those medications and I haven't experienced anything like that again. I was also taking a lot of LSD before, which I think was one of the reasons I was experiencing so much synchronicity and paranoia; I have stopped taking those completely too and none of those feelings have returned.
I'm from South East Asia — I don't think you'd find anyone at schools transitioning here, or even outside you'll rarely meet a trans person. I know about the hijra community from India who are okay with being considered transgender; they don't think they are neither man nor woman, and they know the limitations that they can never bear a child and be considered a real woman — yes for some it causes distress but they accept their situation as it is. I also know that they were once hiding when we were colonized by the westerners who imposed their own Christian morality and criminalized them; after independence they were accepted as the 3rd gender, though now they live extremely poor, mostly earning by giving blessings at weddings or begging, and are considered magical beings in Hinduism so their curse is feared. The community includes both intersex and mtf people.
I've observed that there seem to be more FTM transitions than MTFs because femininity is naturally considered inferior to masculinity — a tomboy is much more acceptable in society than a guy wearing a skirt. As a man I can understand that being a man gets very lonely; you don't get the same time of sisterhood and acceptance as a woman, and if you aren't providing anything valuable as a man then you aren't actually valued much. I've also noticed that when women and men interact it's mainly the job of a man to impress the woman, and it gets hyper competitive for men seeking women's validation.
I don't agree with comments saying my experience is AGP because it's not always a sexual thing for me — I don't get sexually aroused when I walk outside in dresses; I feel it's about expression too. However, I'm still struggling with a sexual humiliation kink when I'm with a man, and I still feel guilty about it sometimes because I feel like it contradicts my masculine inclinations. I've asked others in the community how they came to terms with it. I also believe anyone can experience gender euphoria, not just actual trans people. I've posted a CMV arguing that binary transsexualism is a medical construct of the 20th century, and I've asked whether wanting to try clothes and accessories of the opposite gender should be considered mentally ill, and whether people who consider themselves non-binary or gender non-conforming are mentally ill. I've also pushed back on the term 'trans-trenders,' saying it's just a term used to mock trans people who don't pass, and asked whether experimentation with gender should be allowed more so that the existence of trans people gets normalized.