Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw en psycholoog die haar transitie nu ziet als een kostuum in plaats van een echte verandering, en die zich als vrouw identificeert zonder aan genderstereotypen te voldoen. Ik geloof dat mijn transitie voortkwam uit zelfhaat, vrouwenhaat, lichaamsdysmorfie en een cultuur die genderniet-conforme mensen richting transitie duwt, en ik werd buitengesloten toen ik desisteerde. Ik heb anderen sterk afgeraden om operaties te ondergaan of naar pro-trans therapeuten te gaan, en ik houd mijn detrans-identiteit verborgen omdat openlijk spreken mijn universitaire carrière zou kunnen kosten. Ik stel dat trans sociaal regressief en overbodig is en dat het uiteindelijk zal worden gediscrediteerd. Mijn eigen medische tijdlijn, diagnoses en seksualiteit heb ik in dit materiaal niet openbaar gemaakt.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned female and a psychologist, and I have been active in detrans spaces for a long time. I came to realise that what I had done was not really a transition at all — as I put it, "it was a costume. It didn't change who I was. It was just decoration. And I don't need decoration, and I don't need to pretend. I am who I am, I don't fit standard gender stereotypes and that's fine - nobody is actually forcing me to. My gender is just irrelevant." I now describe myself simply as a woman who always was one: "I'm a woman. Always was. I don't fit old fashioned gender stereotypes and that's *fine*."
I believe my transition grew out of self-hatred and a reaction against gender non-conformity rather than anything innate. My working view, which I have stated as both a psychologist and a detransitioned female, is that "trans is based on reinforcing archaic gender stereotypes, gender non conforming and homophobia. When you combine any two of those things with body dysmorpia, you get trans. 1+1=2." I have said that being a butch lesbian or a tomboy is no longer permitted — "*you must be a man*" — and that this social rejection of non-stereotypical gender expression is where trans comes from. I suspect "'feeling' a gender at all is abnormal," and that being hyper-conscious of or obsessed by gender invents the idea that it can be experienced at all. I have also linked transition to misogyny, asking another poster whether they were describing "your own misogyny, being the underlying reason to transition."
I have been open that I desisted and was ostracised for it: "I was ostracised when I desisted. I could never come out as a SuperLesbian - It would ruin my career." I work as a psychologist at a University and have said I'm "pretty sure they'd find a way to fire me from the University" if I spoke publicly, and that I must hide my identity because "the PC police would destroy me for it." I have not given a detailed timeline of my own transition — no dates for coming out, hormones, or surgeries appear in what I've written — but I have advised others repeatedly and emphatically against surgery: "Do NOT have any more surgery. Wait. Settle down. Stop rushing," and "I would strenuously recommend against surgery, as it's not *reversible*."
On causes, I have argued that dysphoria is essentially body dysmorphia with extra steps, and that "3/4 trans have an eating disorder," making trans people prime candidates for body dysmorphias. I have suggested that in a culture enforcing gender stereotypes, anyone with body dysmorphia, anxiety, trait neuroticism and "a bit of narcissism to make sure you *really* care what other people think of you" will question their gender if they step out of line on expression. I have also pointed to childhood trauma as a contributing factor in personality development, and to sexual factors, defending Blanchard's typology and autogynephilia as real and posting links to the literature on it, while saying it is not the only reason people transition.
I am sceptical of DID ("DID isn't real. It's basically a meme invented by a fraud"), of psychoanalysis, and of the idea that you can identify trans from a brain scan or blood test: "There is no scientific basis for it being a physical biologically driven phenomenon." I have defended ECT as a legitimate modern treatment and criticised anti-vaccination-style reasoning. I have advised people to find a good therapist and to "be direct and open with a therapist about your goal, to avoid the trans trap, from the start," warning against "super woke pro-trans brainwashing therapists" and "trans-cheerleaders." I have suggested legal action for those transitioned as minors: "You might want to speak to a lawyer about suing everyone involved when you were 15. I would."
My overall position is that "Trans is socially regressive and redundant" because gender roles are archaic and changing sex is unnecessary when you can dress, act, love and marry as you like within your own sex. I believe opposition to medical transition will eventually win out and that "the law suits will flow." I have not described my own mental health diagnoses, my own medical complications, my fertility status, my family situation, or my sexuality before or after detransition in this material. I have not described any suicidal ideation or self-harm.