Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die op mijn 14e met testosteron begon zonder eerdere genderdysforie, op mijn 16e een dubbele mastectomie had, ongeveer 2 jaar T nam, na het stoppen 2,5 jaar als non-binair identificeerde en rond 2017-2018 officieel detransitioneerde. Ik heb diepe spijt dat ik als kind medisch transitioneerde zonder voldoende psychologisch onderzoek, en ik heb te maken met blijvende effecten zoals een lage stem, gezichtsbeharing, borstlittekens, een asymmetrische borst en chronische borstpijn. Ik werd op het werk herhaaldelijk als ‘meneer’ aangesproken en gevraagd naar mijn voornaamwoorden, wat ik vernederend en blootstellend vond, en in januari 2022 schreef ik dat de situatie me suïcidaal maakte, al beschrijf ik geen pogingen. Mijn mentale gezondheid is in de jaren zonder hormonen enigszins gestabiliseerd, geholpen door mindfulness en DGT, en ik heb nu een steunende partner, vrienden en een baan die ik leuk vind. Ik pleit momenteel sterk voor sociale transitie vóór welke hormonen dan ook, bekritiseer hoe gemakkelijk HRT aan minderjarigen wordt voorgeschreven, en verwerp zowel non-binaire identiteit als buitenstaande politieke figuren die namens detransitioners spreken.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I first thought 'Wait... am I transgender?' one night as a teenager and went with it, thinking it was the reason for and answer to my unhappiness. I started testosterone at 14, in 2014, with no prior history of gender dysphoria, after only about 2 months of therapy, and after learning about transition from Tumblr at 13-14 where my best friend in middle school was trans. I had top surgery (double mastectomy) at 16, in 2016. I stopped taking testosterone about a year and a half after starting, roughly 2 years on T total. After stopping T I identified as nonbinary for about 2 and a half years before accepting that I wanted to live and be seen as female again. I officially detransitioned around 2017-2018; by 2022 it had been over 4 years since I officially detransitioned, and by late 2024 I described myself as 8 years post-detransition. I am now a detransitioned woman.
I developed chest dysphoria only after I started identifying as trans. In the weeks/months before my top surgery I had stopped wearing a binder and felt perfectly comfortable, but went through with the surgery anyway because I had already been on T for a year and a half and the thought of 'being a woman' after putting my body through that made me feel I would be unloveable and ostracized. I deeply regret not thinking through what medically transitioning would actually do to my body and simply jumping in as a child who did not know myself better. I do not regret that I dressed and acted like I thought a boy would. I wish I had just gotten a breast reduction instead. I also regret never socially transitioning or presenting masculine first, due to a fear of being considered 'ugly' and being terrified of people knowing I was trans at all.
Contributors for me included: growing up in a very affirming family, obsessive 'Who am I?' identity searching as a Gen Z person plugged into the internet from an early age, Tumblr posts about how to lie to doctors and therapists to get hormones, my best friend being trans, and a personality 180 when I transitioned at 13-14 where I went from being very against 'PC' ideas and identity politics to 100% for them. I also think white guilt and escaping being 'the oppressor' drives many transitions; I felt less like a bad person when I identified as nonbinary rather than a trans man. I now believe the way society perceives manhood and womanhood, plus rigid Western gender roles, drives much of transitioning, and that I was 'a woman who was deeply traumatized by the preconceived societal notions of womanhood and the female experience, so I ran away from it.' The way I experienced being female in society was a big part of why I transitioned, and I have harsh thoughts and feelings about men I still need to work on. I was very 'anti-feminist' for years before realizing how deeply misogyny runs through social behavior.
Physical effects and medical issues: my voice dropped within a week or two of my first shot or two and fully dropped to being read as male over the phone within about 3 months; years off hormones people say it is deep but no longer has a 'masculine' timbre. I still have coarse facial hair and shave every other day; leg hair got lighter and less thick off T; I never grew chest hair. I did some electrolysis sessions on my upper lip and chin about a year before asking about it (around 2020) and hair grew back within 2 weeks; it was expensive. Facial hair is 'probably the single most distressing thing' about my detransition. My top surgery recovery was over a month; one drain was dislodged so part of my chest is not as flat as the rest; I still get phantom-like pains in my chest, mostly on the right side where the drain was, plus residual numbness, and sore nipples years later. I desperately want my chest back but reconstruction success rates and intensity deter me. I wore a small bra for a long time to illusion a small chest, then stopped and decided to own being flat-chested.
Mental health: on T I was angrier than usual and physically could not cry; I had to re-learn how to cry. I experienced cognitive dysfunction and inability to focus or find pleasure in things I enjoyed while on T, and to this day seriously struggle with reading books and making art, which I consider my life's passion. Off T I became much more sad and could cry at the drop of a hat; this leveled out to a more stable place about 3 years off HRT. I found mindfulness/meditation and DBT skills helpful. I have carried guilt, shame, and trauma about my transition. In January 2021 I said the regret was 'more raw than ever.' In January 2022 I posted that I was having a really hard time, that I feel my life is ruined, that I am 'tormented by this mistake I made when I was a CHILD every day,' and that 'This shit makes me suicidal. I am physically and emotionally disfigured.' I have not described any attempts. I have self-image issues I am still working on.
Adversity/social: at a front-of-house job before COVID layoffs I got Sir'd constantly and a child laughed and said I 'look like a girl!' which broke my heart. At a 'hip' grocery store job I was hired alongside two other women and was the only one repeatedly asked 'what are your pronouns?' mid-shift in front of others, which I experience as publicly outing me. I often get read as a trans woman by both trans and non-trans people, and coworkers have used they and said they were 'waiting for me to tell them' what I am. I find the pronoun question humiliating. I told my parents about my detransition over the phone because it was hard to say in person, and it made subsequent conversations easier. My parents were 'totally affirming.'
Sexuality/relationships: I dated a straight man for a long time who never cared about my flat chest, facial hair, or deep voice; I was in a 5-year relationship with a cis man who called me his girlfriend (after 2 years of 'partner' and they/them) which I ended in early 2023; I am now dating a bi man who tells me I'm beautiful. Detransition made dating more selective. I have good friends and a job I'm passionate about who don't care about my past.
Attitudes: I believe medical transition should be much more thoroughly examined therapeutically first and I strongly suggest social transition before hormones; I consider 'toying' with HRT a red flag. I do not believe in non-binary identity; I believe there are two sexes but people are individuals. I am upset when detransition is championed by figures like Jordan Peterson or Matt Walsh ('hucksters speaking for us'). I participate in studies about detransitioners when I can. I feel stuck between a political rock and a hard place when people's first reaction to my detransition is reassurance that I don't hate trans people.