Alle verhalen

Dyslexie, jongensachtig zijn en als kind willen dat ze een jongen was

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1,9K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die als kind genderdoorbrekend was en haar ouders zei dat ze een jongen wilde zijn, maar bij wie de interesse in gender een paar jaar na het begin van de puberteit vanzelf verdween. Ik heb dyslexie en waarschijnlijk niet-gediagnosticeerde ADHD, en ik geloof dat neurodivergentie heeft bijgedragen aan mijn vroege genderdoorbrekende gedrag. Ik ben nooit medisch getransitioneerd, dus ik heb geen spijt over operaties of hormonen, maar ik ben al jaren betrokken bij detransitiegemeenschappen en een uitgesproken criticus van medische transitie geworden, vooral voor jonge vrouwen. Ik zie transitiegeneeskunde vaak als medische nalatigheid en heb anderen aangemoedigd te procederen en schadevergoeding te eisen. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw en adviseer jongeren op lange termijn te denken in plaats van beslissingen te nemen op basis van hoe ze zich over hun lichaam voelen.

Volledig verhaal

I was a gender non-conforming child who told my parents I wanted to be a boy. Looking back, I think a big part of that was that I was less socially aware and skilled than my peers — while they absorbed gender like a sponge from a very young age, it all whooshed straight over my head. I literally wore trousers every day while all my friends wore skirts and didn't even notice I was doing something different. Even though I was sure I wanted to be a boy and grow up to be a man, I didn't actually like boys' stuff like sports; I liked the geeky middle ground. I wore trousers for practical reasons — I didn't want cold legs or scraped knees. My reluctance not to grow up to be a woman was also practical in a sense: I didn't want to be treated like shit and have babies. I'm not neurotypical — I have dyslexia and would probably be diagnosed with ADHD, though I've never pursued it because I wouldn't take medication for it anyway. I've noticed that if you have one of these things you usually get the set. A couple of years into puberty my brain changed and did start drinking in gender, which in a way I'm lucky for because I clearly remember the process and know how it happens, while many people who never have gender issues assume you're just born liking feminine or masculine stuff or that kids are groomed into it rather than their brains actively looking for it. So I likely had normal inborn gender non-conformity that was solved by puberty. I've theorised that the human mind goes through periods where it searches out and absorbs gender presentation — it's not that evil society imposes gender on all children; children want to learn gender. For most people that happens as a toddler, but for some, especially the neurodivergent, it happens as a teen, and some get mixed up and start absorbing the opposite gender. I clearly remember when I was 16 that female clothing and behaviour became really interesting in a way it never had been before. I never medically transitioned, but I have thought a lot about what leads people to transition and then detransition. I've spent years engaging with detransition communities, reading research, and thinking critically about the medical system's role. I've come to see transition-related medical interventions as frequently amounting to malpractice — I've told people who regretted surgery that they were sold an experimental medical procedure that went wrong and that they have to go forward from there. I've said plainly that hormones can be just as damaging as surgery, that testosterone changes behaviour for the worse and that the change seems mostly permanent, and that taking cross-sex hormones essentially induces a hormone disorder — comparing it to PCOS, which gives women double the risk of type 2 diabetes regardless of weight, at far lower testosterone levels than are given to female-to-male transitioners. I've also warned about puberty blockers not simply pausing puberty but having long-lasting negative effects, and about the full side effects of hysterectomy. I've been critical of the rapid rise in referrals, noting the UK's 4000% increase in teenage girls being referred to gender clinics and saying clearly there's more going on than people suddenly thinking it's okay to be trans, and that many of them will detransition. I've discussed autogynephilia as being in the DSM-5 and described it as a progressive disorder that gets worse the more you indulge it, including the binge-and-purge cycle of buying clothes. I've also discussed how porn can make you think that if you want to be admired or cared about you have a better chance as a woman. I've been supportive of detransitioners pursuing legal action, telling people they suffered medical malpractice and should sue, and noting that there needs to be some sort of industry compensation scheme. I've also advised people to record meetings with doctors because they act like they're protecting themselves rather than looking out for your best interests. I've observed that some detrans people say their doctors and therapists had a real problem with sexism — that they often really believe feminine men aren't real men and gender non-conforming women aren't real women. On personal decisions, I've advised people to take their time, not rush toward a goal, and to think about where they see themselves in 5, 10, 20 years — what lifestyle, job, relationship, whether they might want kids — rather than basing big decisions on what makes them comfortable or how they feel about their body. I've said you don't need to realise what you are; you are you, and you should make the right choices as a person, not as a category. I've recommended CBT for people stuck in obsessive worry about being trans, and suggested reading 'The Body Keeps the Score' for trauma and dissociation. I've also reflected that some of us were brought up cynical but still went down the same path because we thought we were fighting against the norm and authority. I've been open about my dyslexia and un-diagnosed probable ADHD, and I've discussed neurodivergence and gender non-conformity at length. I've commented on issues of sexism, both in medicine and in online discourse, and I've been critical of trans activism shutting down research and harassing researchers. I've also commented on the origin of the term 'egg' as simply 'eggs hatch into chicks' and called it completely sexist. Currently I identify as a woman who was gender non-conforming as a child but whose relationship with gender resolved itself around puberty. I have not undergone any medical transition and have no regrets about medical changes because I never pursued them, though I do think about the time and mental energy spent on gender questions.