Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde man die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar verpleegkundigen smeekte om testosteron of een geslachtsaanpassing voordat ik in mijn vroege twintigers snel desisteerde. Ik identificeer me nu als hetero man en schrijf mijn verdwenen transitiewens toe aan ongeveer vier jaar werken aan opleiding, carrière, vriendschappen, hobby's en een langdurige relatie, plus zelfhulpwerk zoals Jordan Petersons Future Authoring. Op mijn 27e kon ik mezelf helemaal als man accepteren en liefhebben. Ik ben nu zeer kritisch over gender-affirmerende behandeling en betoog dat het onderzoek (met name studies van het Karolinska Instituut) de voordelen ervan niet onderbouwt en dat financiële en ideologische prikkels de sector sturen. Mijn vader, een arts, reageerde vijandig toen ik deze zorgen uitte en noemde me een 'homofobe trumper'.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and have identified as male throughout my life. I never went through a medical transition myself — I desisted very quickly from the idea of transitioning — but the whole experience shaped how I think and write about gender, transition, and detransition.
Looking back, I can see that my own wish to change gender was not really about being in the wrong body. It was about feeling inadequate as a male. I bounced between different worldviews trying to make sense of it: the toxic incel view that you can't compete or get a girlfriend unless you're a certain height and shape, the PUA idea that you just need confidence, and a leftist-feminist framing that never made sense to me either. None of them fit. What actually helped was doing the basic things in life — getting an education, building toward a career goal, finding hobbies, making friends, and eventually having a long-term relationship. I did Jordan Peterson's Future Authoring program and read 12 Rules, and while I know JDBP is controversial, his framing of masculinity was the most forgiving one I found: find some avenues where you have some status and deliver value, and you will have more friends, a better chance of a relationship, and feel better about yourself. It took me roughly four years of sticking to those things before I became completely detached from any idea that I needed to 'transmax' or that my problems meant I was actually a woman. I'm now so far removed from the guy who begged the nurses for either more testosterone or a sex change.
It wasn't until I was 27 that I felt I started to get a path in life and accept and love myself as a male. I remember being a total mess until that age, and I'm happy nobody threw hormones and surgery at me — I don't think that would have helped. Sometimes I feel like trans surgery just interferes with a process of growing up that is generally pretty tough for many people. I do get scared when I think about what would have happened if someone or some people had 'affirmed' me instead.
I've never been diagnosed with a specific condition, but I've struggled with feeling like I didn't fit in, low confidence, and a sense of inadequacy in my twenties. I don't take any hormones or medications now. I don't have fertility concerns or medical complications from transition because I never medically transitioned.
My social world has been complicated. My father is a physician who is very much into the trans issue and wants to be very liberal; he called me a 'homophobe trumper' recently when I expressed concerns that the majority of this generation's trans people are likely trenders or mentally ill people being exploited. I also talked with a relative who works in developmental science and was disturbed by how positive he was toward trans treatment — he said something I've heard from doctors too: 'but you want to help, and what are you supposed to do?'. I feel many doctors with a certain ideological leaning have completely forgotten the 'do no harm' tenets of Western medical practice.
In my friend group more than ten years ago — before the recent trans movement — everyone identified as bisexual because it was the most 'tolerant' view. It was really a sort of social hysteria. The gay guys in that group are still gay, but most people are now either straight or gay; the whole 'I'm pansexual' thing hasn't panned out. As the guys have grown guts or become more rugged, we don't make out with each other like we did as more androgynous emo boys. I'm straight. I've dated three trans women, one of whom came from a religious cult, and I've had sexual experiences with trans women that felt sad and without much pleasure for them, compared to my experiences with women, which were always a very lusty affair.
I now hold a strongly critical view of transition as it's currently practiced. I posted a long analysis arguing that the Karolinska Institute longitudinal study — one of the largest and longest on trans treatment — couldn't show consistent improvement yet still recommended treatment anyway, and I noted the authors' conclusion had been corrected for being too strong. I pointed out that outcomes are only compared to the general population mean, not age-matched, and that we have no data on how desisted people's mental health changes over 10+ years. I've quoted Karolinska's Svante Norgren saying the scientific basis for the treatment's effect and benefit has major shortcomings and there is disagreement about how to weigh the risk-benefit analysis. I've argued that if a treatment doesn't have clear positive effects, or proven positive effects outweighing the negatives, it should not be done. I'm skeptical of claims that transition is beneficial even for legitimately dysphoric people or someone born intersex, and I think there's a lot of financial incentive keeping the research going. I've also written about health risks of cross-sex hormones, noting my grandmother likely died from cancer caused by a much more aggressive estrogen treatment for menopause than is recommended today.
I've also written about how many people — including detransitioners — are trying to escape a hard situation rather than actually being happy while having dysphoria, and how my own idea of changing gender, and a friend's, pretty much went away when we got into long-term relationships. I'm skeptical of transmaxxing research as methodologically weak, and I've compared aspects of trans ideology to a cult or religion, including describing how some people treat trans kids like a form of child sacrifice. I don't advocate for any particular alternative treatment; I mainly argue for caution, more rigorous research, and not medicalizing people who are simply unhappy with their life situation.