Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw die zich als trans identificeerde en het grootste deel van mijn tienerjaren als man presenteerde, maar alleen sociaal transitioneerde en nooit hormonen kreeg. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, de angst als zwak gezien te worden, een paar slechte seksuele ervaringen en de wens voor mezelf onherkenbaar te worden. Na ongeveer vier jaar, zonder actieve steun van mijn ouders (die het als een fase zagen) of van mijn overdreven ondersteunende vrienden, koos ik ervoor het in twijfel te trekken en desisteerde ik. Nu omarm ik vrouwelijkheid, train ik voor kracht en heb ik een beetje spijt dat ik typische meisjeservaringen zoals het schoolfeest heb gemist. Ik ben niet anti-transitie, maar geloof dat eerst andere geestelijke gezondheidsproblemen moeten worden aangepakt en dat transitie een laatste redmiddel zou moeten zijn.
Volledig verhaal
I am a young woman who identified as trans and presented as male for most of my teenage years before desisting. I grew up loving everything stereotypically girly — pink, makeup, dresses, cute stuff, fashion — but I shoved all of that away once I realized other people form judgments about me based on how I present myself. My case was a fairly common one of internalized misogyny: I told myself 'I have to be masculine, otherwise they're gonna think I'm a girly girl slut and that's not who I am.' I didn't recognize it as internalized misogyny at the time because I didn't judge other girls that way — in fact I thought women were brave for showing the world they're women.
Alongside that, a few bad sexual experiences fed into my belief that I was trans. I wanted to be anything except the person I had been before, and taking a 180 in how I presented seemed like the fastest way to become unrecognizable to myself and to others. My greatest fear was being perceived as weaker, and with what I now call my backwards thinking I believed becoming a man would make me strong. It didn't — it just led me to do things I now regret. Consciously I was thinking there was no way I was going to live through life as a woman, so I would go through mental gymnastics to reach the conclusion 'I'm trans and I have to transition.' Most of my so-called dysphoria was rooted in internalized misogyny; instead of addressing it, I tried avoiding it.
I never accessed hormones — it was hard to access them where I live — so I only socially transitioned, which I consider lucky. My parents thought it was a phase; they didn't actively stop me but were waiting for it to pass. My friends were the overly supportive type, so about four years into identifying as trans I had to be the one to tell myself 'I should really think about this.' Even while I identified as trans I was weirded out by people who were extremely persistent about it.
Since desisting I've been accepting being a girl again. I love wearing feminine clothes now — it makes me feel really pretty and happy with myself. I was hyperfeminine before transitioning but suppressed it, so it's nice to indulge in it again. In reality all I needed was a glow-up. I've also started strength training and going to the gym, because I realized physical strength isn't dependent on gender — being a man wouldn't have made me strong if I didn't train, and building muscle as a woman is possible, just harder, and that's something I accept.
I do feel behind: going to university made me realize it, seeing pretty girls with a developed sense of style while I look at myself and think 'what am I doing with my life.' I missed out on being a girl learning her style and experimenting during my teen years, and I still feel a little bad about missing wearing a pretty pink dress and getting glammed up for prom — I'll never have an event like prom again. I know I'm still young and can do those things now, but everyone around me has already done it.
Parts of my childhood contributed to thinking being a woman is somehow bad or shameful. I've worked to unlearn that. I also dug into why I wanted to be 'the man' in a relationship: I was ashamed of being seen as 'the girl,' even though I didn't think it was bad for other girls to be in that role. What I found was that I wanted to separate myself from other girls and thought being treated by a man that way would make me weak and stereotypical — not something I consciously thought. I've accepted that being 'the girl' in a relationship isn't shameful and doesn't make me weak, though I still occasionally hold the door for my boyfriend, give him gifts, and pay for meals. Part of what made me desist was realizing I don't have to label every single part of myself.
On transition generally, I am not anti-transition, but I believe other mental health issues should be addressed first and that transitioning should be a last resort — the first approach to gender dysphoria could be similar to how body dysmorphia is treated, exploring options for relieving dysphoria and leading to sex acceptance before medical steps. I also argue that gender, race, and age aren't comparable categories: anyone can be born male, female, or intersex regardless of their parents, whereas race is inherited, and 'trans-age' makes no sense since time moves forward at a constant pace. I agree that biological females are an oppressed demographic and that a person born male is a person born male, decided at conception.