Alle verhalen

Commentaar van buitenaf, nooit een eigen transitie

Man · Gedesisteerd40
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een heteroseksuele, als man geboren man die op r/detrans stelt dat FtM-transitioners vrouwen zijn en dat een operatie niemand tot man kan maken. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over transitie, benadruk autisme als onderschatte factor die te weinig wordt vastgesteld, en stel dat vrouwen in het Westen maatschappelijke voordelen hebben. Ik heb in dit transcript geen persoonlijke transitie- of detransitiegeschiedenis; mijn bijdragen zijn commentaar gericht aan anderen. Ik sluit gesprekken ondersteunend af en moedig aan om jezelf als vrouw en lesbienne te accepteren.

Volledig verhaal

I'm a straight man who was born male, and I've spent a lot of time on r/detrans arguing with people who identify as trans men. I hold the view plainly: no FtM is a real man. A man is not a stereotype or a social role, and I don't think gender roles really exist anymore, so it annoys me when people treat he and she as some kind of stereotype. I say directly to the people I reply to: you're a woman, always were, always will be, so what? What can't you do that men can do? I'm blunt about bodies. I've told people that a metoidplasty is nothing like a real penis, that phalloplasty is "a butcher job" where they trade functioning parts for something with a 100% complication rate that still doesn't function like a real penis, and that no one is ever mistaking a metoidplasty for a penis. I've said things like, "Mutilating your genitals isnt going to bring you any closer to anything other than medicalization," and "You know deeply you will always have a female body no matter how you try to poison it." I've told people I'm being blunt because it's better to accept it now than to keep messing yourself up. I've argued that FtM people radically reduce their pool of possible partners, and that they'd be better off accepting they'll always be women. I've commented on public figures too: I've said Buck Angel is a woman and "she admits it now," and that Laith is "just a woman with issues." I've said that biologically male people find Buck Angel to be "a joke, just a straight butch woman with some weird issues." On autism, I've repeatedly suggested that many people identifying as trans are on the autism spectrum, that girls are far less diagnosed than boys, and that what several people described fit autism. I shared two links — a Spectrum News piece on the overlap between autism and gender diversity and a Boston University article on why autistic girls go undiagnosed — and argued that the commonly cited 25% figure is probably lower than the true number. I was careful to say I wasn't telling anyone what they are, just pointing it out as something to look into, and I pushed back when someone implied I was insulting autistic people: I said plenty of my friends on the spectrum are great people and extremely smart, that it can be a superpower, and that I don't appreciate anyone making autism out to be a bad thing. I've also made broader social arguments. I've said women have more freedom of expression and more societal advantages in western countries, cited that my wife makes twice my income ($300k vs my $140k), that my superiors at work are all women in tech, and that women get more degrees and in many professions earn more. I've argued that no one cares about FtM people while MtF people get framed as predators, and that MtF studies show higher incomes and higher positions. I've said that in the west, sex equals gender as it should, that there are sex traits but no gender traits, and that race can't be changed either, so why affirm one but not the other. I've said the only real distinction left is reproductive ability, and that as a straight man I'm into females — heterosexual — though I've said I'd be into FtM people if they were still reproductively female. I've been told I'm a troll and that I made alternate accounts; I denied both, said I haven't been here in a long time, and noted I have a master's degree and speak three languages fluently, not to brag but to explain my level of education. I've ended several exchanges warmly, telling people they seem like cool, sweet, awesome women and rooting for them to find a nice lesbian relationship. I've said repeatedly that kids don't know any better and that letting them harm their bodies is insane.