Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben man geboren en transitioneerde medisch over ongeveer tien jaar, inclusief een orchiectomie, maar mijn transitie liet me niet doorgaan en ik stopte geleidelijk met me als trans identificeren — niet uit eigen keuze. Ik heb geen spijt: de poging tot transitie heeft mijn leven gered, en psychedelisch ondersteunde zelfreflectie genas uiteindelijk mijn genderdysforie, al werd die vervangen door een diepere op angst gebaseerde dysforie die me mijn baan deed opzeggen. Ik ben sociaal gedetransitioneerd en identificeer me nu als gendernonconforme man die van zijn mannelijkheid houdt, maar ik blijf estradiol gebruiken omdat mijn lichaam na de orchiectomie geen testosteron meer kan aanmaken. Ik heb een steunende vriend en voel me dichter bij totale zelfacceptatie dan ooit, terwijl ik af en toe nog rouw om verloren dromen en omga met niet-genderdysforie. Ik verwerp ‘echte trans’-poortwachterij, bekritiseer de huidige expertconsensus over transzorg en pleit voor betere behandelingen die patiënten niet levenslang medisch maken.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male. My gender dysphoria was very bad, and attempting to transition saved my life. I have no transition-related regrets. I still take cross-sex hormones (estradiol) because stopping is impractical. My body can't produce testosterone anymore due to an orchiectomy, and I prefer the skin/hair/bodyfat changes from HRT anyway.
Despite my best efforts, my transition didn't work out. Not everyone finds acceptance or gets to be passable. The opposite of 'to pass' is 'to fail', and this brought me a lot of grief with no support available — a Google search for 'ways to cope with a failed gender transition' turned up nothing. I gradually stopped identifying as trans, which was not by my own choice; I don't believe it's something a person can consciously choose to do with success. For me it just happened. I let go of a lot of the bitterness. I no longer dream of being a beautiful woman; instead I dream of a 'femininely masculine beauty'. I still like my gender nonconformity, maybe now more than ever.
I wanted beauty and was wrong to think I had to 'become' female to get it. Subtracting my masculine traits would have made me more bland; facial feminization surgery likely would have left me very disappointed. I've developed a deeper appreciation of male sexual dimorphism — lions, deer, flamingos — and realized male beauty is what I was missing all along.
Reasons beyond appearance are complicated. I was afraid of becoming like the men in my family — they fought, were violent, hurt women, chased drugs, some are serving life sentences. I tried to differentiate myself by becoming something else, becoming as pathetic as possible, as if signaling 'please don't hurt me'. I'm pretty sure I have PTSD. I also experienced very painful gender dysphoria, which for me was all due to misplaced emotions — that doesn't change its severity. It took ten years to figure it out and I'm still a bit shell-shocked.
Switching back to male hormones involves too many scary unknowns — appearance, psychology, sexuality. I'm terrified, so I reluctantly stay on HRT. Since I've had an orchiectomy, going off estrogen would mean going on TRT, which would cause breast growth anyway, so I choose the hormone with the fewest unwanted effects: estradiol.
Transitioning helped and even saved my life, but it was ultimately a distraction. My gender dysphoria is cured now, thanks to psychedelic mushrooms and lots of self-reflection, but it's been replaced with a different, worse dysphoria: fear that I will never accomplish anything, never be loved, always be ignored or abused, never be pretty, never escape. Some problems were subconscious — like unearthing a dinosaur tooth and finding an entire skeleton. This new behemoth is way bigger than my gender dysphoria ever was; it shook my entire being and I quit my job. At least with gender dysphoria there was the illusion things were fixable with surgery.
I still think attempting to transition was an integral part of my healing. I had to try, to scratch that itch, or I'd have carried resentment and kept deluding myself. Psychedelic-assisted self-reflection helped; it's been nearly a year since I did them and I've experienced enormous growth, though it 'messed me up in some ways' and I have mixed feelings — overall a net positive. I'm no longer obsessed with surgically removing my masculine facial features; it now feels like that was impossible from the start. But that was ten years of my life and my biggest goal gone 'like a plume of smoke' — I am shaken.
I've socially detransitioned but continue cross-sex hormones. I learned to love myself and accept my birth sex. I consider myself a gender-nonconforming male and I am whole. I still occasionally experience dysphoria, but it's no longer rooted in gender. I quit my job at one point during self-reflection. I shaved my head once to embrace potential hair thinning, then grew it back but am less attached to it — 'Buddhism, the cup is already broken.' I epilate my legs and armpits and pluck my mustache with tweezers since there's no laser where I live.
I've gradually wanted surgery less over time, though I still want it at times and feel my face is 'unfixable'. In irony, I now wish to enhance some masculine features, plus possibly a lip lift — I want balance and harmony. My biggest fear is wasting all my money and looking the same or worse. I have a very accepting, supportive and handsome boyfriend who thinks I'm great as I am and makes me feel pretty and wanted. Dating as a guy on estrogen is harder than dating as a trans-identifying person, from my experience as both.
I went into medical transition knowing sex is unchangeable and wasn't comfortable calling myself MTF, but people expected me to, including medical professionals — that felt unscientific. I felt there was no place for me at the table despite treating sex separately from gender. I distrust the current 'expert consensus' on trans care. I reject the 'true trans' narrative as harmful gatekeeping. I think the surgeries are risky and barbaric and often fail; I want better treatment modalities that don't make us medical patients for life, and no conversion therapy — 'proud expression, not shameful repression.' I've advocated for detrans-friendly spaces and pushed back against 'detransphobia'. I advised a parent not to be in a hurry, saying HRT is overrated and being a medical patient for life isn't worth it.
I feel super happy about where I am in my life: nearer to total self-acceptance than ever, I love my maleness, and I have a supportive boyfriend. I wouldn't press a magic button to undo my transition — 'giving up on my gender transition saved my life.'