Alle verhalen

Vijf jaar op oestrogeen, en dan noemen het angst om volwassen te worden

Man · GedetransitioneerdTransitie 22 → Detransitie 28114
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die ongeveer vijf tot zes jaar als transvrouw leefde, van mijn 22e tot net voor mijn 28e, op oestrogeen en spironolacton voordat ik medio 2020 stopte. Ik identificeer me nu als autogynefiel en zeg dat ik stopte met trans zijn omdat het onoprecht was en angst voor volwassenheid weerspiegelde. Ik heb wel spijt van het laten groeien van borsten en rouw om het verspillen van een deel van mijn twintiger jaren, al zei ik vroeg ook dat ik geen spijt had. Lichamelijk en mentaal ben ik goed hersteld van de hormonen, met terugkerende mannelijke kenmerken, een normale libido en een steunende vriendin. Ik blijf kritisch over transitie voor mezelf en heb vaste opvattingen over het recht van biologische vrouwen op ruimtes alleen voor vrouwen, maar ik zeg nog steeds dat ik transgender mensen serieus neem en dat mijn verhaal niet dat van iedereen is.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male. I first came out and began transitioning at age 22, in roughly 2014, and I was on estrogen and spironolactone for about five to six years, stopping a little before I turned 28 — around May or June of 2020, so roughly 12 days to a few months before my first post here in June 2020. I used a higher-than-average estrogen dose against my doctor's advice. I naturally had very low testosterone, a feminine face, and petite bones, which I took as confirmation of my trans identity. My body changed only modestly on HRT: softer skin, breast growth (I describe myself as roughly an AA cup now), and slight curvature. I passed well as a woman, held jobs, and was taken seriously as a woman in daily life. I described my pre-transition life as a dual existence — I was mistaken for a girl constantly and it didn't bother me, and I existed in an androgynous state. I now understand that androgyny was something I always naturally had and was used to, and that my gender feelings were suspiciously tied up with my sexuality. I am, in my own words, a straight male: I have sex with women and fall in love with them. I had a few boyfriends while living as a woman, but I now see those relationships as repressed and shallow — I was performing a role for personal satisfaction regarding my identity rather than feeling real passion. I also described the women I dated as probably being superficially attracted to what is essentially 'a bolder streak of transvestism.' My family rejected and abandoned me for being trans, and I don't expect to forgive them. I chose to keep the name I was born with at first, but after detransitioning I reversed course and pursued changing my name back to my birth name, because I decided I care very much about erasing my identity as a woman. My legal documents had read 'F' with a woman's name; I said I would probably change the marker back to 'M.' What moved me toward detransition was a gradual sense that my identity as a woman no longer suited me — gender mattered less and less, and I realized I no longer felt accurate saying 'I am a transwoman.' I described the whole thing as submitting to vanity, and later, more sharply, as being 'an emotionally clever autogynophile' — I explicitly identified myself as an autogynephile in my update post. I said I stopped being trans 'because it was insincere. It was a weak move reflecting fear of maturity, fear of self.' I also said I was 'an abnormal male but... it was the voices of the world that suggested I was a woman and I took it.' I did not use therapy as the mechanism of my detransition; it was mostly internal reflection and reading others' detransition stories here, which I noticed often matched my own 5-6 year timeline ending before age 30. Medically, I quit hormones around June 2020. I was concerned about breast tissue reduction because I'm very thin, and I hoped for roughly half reduction; I planned to build muscle instead of pursuing surgery. I asked others about surgical breast reduction experiences. Around late June 2020 I had some physical scare — I mentioned healing quickly and suspecting 'a weirdly fast physical effect of testosterone,' and decided a doctor or ER visit wasn't necessary. I reported that I never experienced erectile dysfunction on HRT and that erections remained strong throughout. By November 2020, five to six months off hormones, I reported that nearly all my masculine traits 'naturally snapped back,' my libido is normal, I feel physically healthier and stronger, and I have a supportive partner who likes me for who I am. Mentally, I worried before stopping that I would revert to a 'hardened, apathetic' person, but I don't believe that's happened — I credit my own strength and endurance rather than estrogen for making me a sensitive, dimensional person. I did acknowledge grief and a sense of failure: in my update I said I was developing closure about having 'wasted a fraction of my 20s as a sexual outcast in an unsuitable way,' that there is 'a sense of failure to myself that I am sort of grieving,' and that I actually do regret growing breasts on some level. I also said I feel a small amount of guilt for how I may have made some women feel by being in women's spaces. Overall I said 'No regrets, I wasn't even wrong about anything' in my first post, but my update nine days later showed real regret emerging, particularly about breast growth and about my thought processes when I came out. On adversity, I mentioned undergoing 'hard times, abuse, very uncomfortable situations with people who were just like me' within the trans subculture, and I described the MTF world as rife with sexual exploitation, pornography, sex work, and grooming — while acknowledging I voluntarily did some of this and don't exactly regret it, but that it's not good for the average person. I have been critical and blunt in this community, at one point harshly telling another poster to get professional help and accusing them of attention-seeking across multiple subreddits. I am critical of transition for others in the sense that I think it was wrong for me and that I 'suspect that it was the wrong way for me,' while still saying I take transgender people seriously and that my story won't be everyone's story. I hold strong views about women's spaces — that no woman should be shamed for not wanting biological males in her space, and that if one woman doesn't trust someone the space should be female-only — views I say I held even while passing as a transwoman. I have not described formal advocacy or activism. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm.