Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die nooit bewust is getransitioneerd, maar als tiener en jonge vrouw anabole steroïden en testosteron gebruikte om sportprestaties te verbeteren, waardoor mijn stem zakte en ik me een lelijke vrouw voelde. Ik ben met de hormonen gestopt nadat ik hartproblemen kreeg, en mijn diepe stem wordt nu pijnlijk vaak aangezien voor die van een transvrouw, terwijl stemfeminisatiechirurgie werd geweigerd omdat ik genetisch geen man ben. Ik lees sinds de jaren tachtig over transseksualiteit, heb jaren geleden kinderen met genderdysforie geïnterviewd en ben een uitgesproken criticus van transitie geworden, vooral voor meisjes, die ik bekijk vanuit lichaamsdysmorfie en anorexia. Ik ben herhaaldelijk van Reddit verbannen vanwege mijn standpunten en zoek actief andere detransitie- of genderkritische fora en schrijvers op, zoals Abigail Shrier en Hadley Freeman. Ik identificeer me nu met mijn geboortesekse en geloof dat de meer verlichte mensen zichzelf accepteren als hun geboortesekse.
Volledig verhaal
I came to transgender issues sideways, through sport rather than through any wish to change sex. I was athletic when I was younger, quite tall and very strong, and I got involved in sports performance enhancement through chemistry — I took performance anabolic steroids and testosterone as a teenager and as a young woman. I did not intentionally transition; I never set out to live as a man. The testosterone changed my body anyway. My voice dropped, similar to most adolescent males, though my speech mannerisms did not change, so I still sounded like a woman, only an older-sounding one. I stopped taking the hormones mainly because I started having heart problems.
The distressing part now is that, because trans women have become so common, my voice is mistaken for that of a trans woman, and this is very distressing to me. I have thought about having voice feminization surgery, but I was told they only do it on genetic males, so that route is closed to me. I also describe feeling like I was an ugly woman from the side effects of testosterone. I have said that I first became involved with transgender issues after having taken testosterone for athletic enhancement, and that I have been reading about the subject since the publication of Harry Benjamin's "The Transsexual Phenomenon" in the 1960s and all of Ray Blanchard's later work — so roughly since the 1980s.
Some years back I interviewed groups of children who were gender dysphoric and noticed a significant difference between feminine boys and traditionally masculine boys in the control group. That experience shapes my views. I do not believe there is such a thing as a "true transsexual"; I think it is all on a continuum and that each individual makes that decision for themselves, with the more enlightened ones accepting themselves as their birth sex.
My political interest in the subject grew when I realized it was affecting girls more than boys, and that the reasons are entirely different. I think girls have body issues in adolescence which are often expressed through anorexia or gender dysphoria, and I see a real connection between anorexia and gender dysphoria in females, as Hadley Freeman describes. I think femininity is so much more sexualized than masculinity, and that one reason men desire to be women is so they can be sex objects, whereas women usually don't want to be sex objects and therefore seek a remedy that is deleterious to their health and well-being. I have said my focus is on the safety of women. I've never been a lesbian, but I have friends who are gay women and I feel strange about them feeling obligated to like trans women, otherwise they're considered transphobic.
I have been repeatedly banned from Reddit; moderators know who I am and want to stop me communicating with women who are victims of transgenderism, and I have had to keep opening new accounts. I posted asking the community for other pro-detransition forums or websites, because I find Reddit a liberal hotbed, and I was pointed toward writers and activists such as Abigail Shrier, Helen Joyce, Hadley Freeman, Sonia Sodha, Maya Forstater and Naomi Cunningham, whom I thank. I think very highly of Abigail Shrier and quote her on gender dysphoria being vanishingly rare — under .01 percent of the population, emerging in early childhood and afflicting males almost exclusively.
I have apologized when I have offended people, saying I don't want to add to anyone's frustration, and I've said I don't think most males who want to transition are sexual predators — I think most of them are what we used to call transvestites, men who want to experience femininity as a heterosexual experience, men who don't trust others and want to control their own sexuality. I believe transsexuals who have an actual brain-sex difference, more like a female, are the feminine boys who grow up to be homosexual men or transgender. I have never taken an interest in the subject until I started realizing it was affecting girls more than boys.