Alle verhalen

Dysforie sinds haar 3e, en ze koos ervoor te blijven

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd500
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die sinds mijn derde genderdysforie voelt maar nooit sociaal of medisch is getransitioneerd, en ik identificeer me nu als vrouw die de dysforie privé houdt. Ik heb mijn lichaam nooit gehaat, ik voelde me er alleen los van, en ik besloot dat transitie me nooit tevreden zou stellen. Ik ga met de dysforie om via een blog, door me naar buiten te richten en door betekenis te cultiveren rond mijn vrouwelijke lichaam. Ik zou een hypothetische pil nemen die de dysforie wegneemt, al heb ik geen spijt van de groei die mijn worstelingen me hebben gebracht. Mijn opvattingen zijn gemengd: ik geloof dat echt transgenderisme bestaat, maar ben sceptisch over de huidige aantallen en over transitie als standaardbehandeling.

Volledig verhaal

I have dealt with gender dysphoria for as long as I can remember — since I was about 3 years old, well before puberty, and it never went away even past my teenage years. I never physically or socially transitioned: I never started hormones, never lived as the opposite sex, and I would never tell anyone in real life, let alone ask anyone to use a different name or pronouns or to view me as the opposite sex. I decided early on that transitioning would not satisfy me — I knew I would never be happy with the results and that it would be a time and energy sink for results I would never be content with. I told myself that if the technology existed to do a good job of physically changing me, and it wasn't as risky or expensive, I probably would have, but as things stood I chose to satisfy my dysphoria in other ways: I decided to turn my focus outward rather than inward, and to be confident in my choices and actions even if I might not be content with my life. I never hated my body. I describe it as neutral to me, like a car or a tool to maintain, and in fact I think my body is quite lovely because I take good care of it. What I do feel is a disconnection — as if the body is someone else's, or not my own. I don't think being a woman is worse than being a man, just different. I've noticed that my dysphoria is strongest right before the start of my period, which made me wonder whether it is partly hormone-related, since I don't think about gender dysphoria at other times of the month. I never came out or lived socially transitioned. In a post about whether it's wrong to hide gender dysphoria from a romantic partner, I wrote that I am open to relationships but worry about doing the other person a disservice, comparing it to a gay man marrying an unwary straight woman or a woman marrying a man and later starting hormones. I said I would never tell anyone in meatspace about my dysphoria or ask them to humour me with pronouns or a different name, and asked how much truth we owe a partner — while also acknowledging that if everyone exposed all their secrets nobody would be in relationships. I also reasoned that if I'm never going to transition or live as the opposite sex, there's little point in mentioning it. I've thought a lot about what causes this kind of dysphoria in myself and others. I believe true transgenderism exists as a natural phenomenon, just like being gay, and that it existed before the internet and across cultures — crossdressers, third genders, people outside the two gender roles — so it isn't solely a modern trend. At the same time I'm sceptical that there are as many transgender people today as there appear to be; I joked about there being 'something in the water' or a psyop, and I've cited the observation that most young children who want to be the opposite sex grow out of it. I've said it's possible to outgrow being trans but not guaranteed, and that people's brains and feelings can change, so someone who was genuinely trans might still change — which doesn't invalidate real trans people's experiences. I've also speculated about evolutionary explanations, such as the idea that people who identified as the opposite sex might have had a reproductive advantage, or an 'incel wiki' concept of same-sex-attracted trans people as 'sneakers' — males who pass as female to get close to females — while acknowledging the source. I've wondered whether some people's dysphoria is a natural and understandable response to an abnormal environment — sexual trauma, a misogynistic society, feeling out of place in a male-dominated field. I have never been diagnosed with anything in the transcript, but I've suggested to others that breast aversion can be 'an ASD sensory thing', and I've speculated about social conditioning — that in some communities women are conditioned to tone themselves down and put their own needs last, so taking on a male role feels like permission to be oneself. I've encouraged others to work on trauma rather than transition, to cultivate traditionally masculine or feminine virtues in themselves rather than reaching for hormones, and to consider that what they hate might be change or sexualisation rather than the body part itself. I've argued that women have real power in society and that I wish more women knew what they had. I would take a medication that removed dysphoria if one existed. I don't regret my struggles — I think they forced me to mature and develop in ways others don't, and that pain causes growth as long as it doesn't break you — but I also believe suffering in itself isn't a virtue and I wouldn't choose to suffer forever if I didn't have to. I keep a blog to help me cope. I've never started transitioning physically or socially, so my situation is unchanged from before.