Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee — ik ben niet trans en nooit getransitioneerd; ik ben een criticus van transitie die schrijft in r/detrans-threads. Ik ben man, geen moedertaalspreker van het Engels, en ik herken mijn eigen stemmingswisselingen, maladaptief dagdromen en gedrag als mogelijk een verslavingsgevoelige persoonlijkheid. Ik betoog consequent dat genderdysforie een maladaptief gedrag is dat vergelijkbaar is met verslaving, dat transitie verminking is en dat mensen de onderliggende gezondheid, autisme of OCD moeten behandelen. Ik heb ouders geadviseerd hun kinderen te stoppen met transitioneren en individuen verteld dat ze slachtoffers zijn van maatschappelijke grooming. Ik meld geen persoonlijke medische transitie, detransitie of mentale uitkomst na detransitie.
Volledig verhaal
I want to start by saying I am not trans and I never suffered anything even remotely like gender dysphoria. I wrote that plainly in 2019 when I was reading a thread about a gene hypothesis for transgenderism, because I wanted to be clear about where I was speaking from. What I did relate to, in my own life, was what I described as mood swings, maladaptive daydreaming, and my own behavior, which led me to suspect I might have an addictive personality. That is the lens I have used ever since: I treat gender dysphoria and transsexuality as a maladaptive behavior, comparable to alcohol addiction, drug addiction, or gambling addiction, rather than as an identity to be affirmed. I asked in that same thread whether the anticonvulsant protocol used for transgenderism had ever been tried for other addictive disorders, and whether it might help me alongside behavioral therapy.
I am not a native English speaker; I said so directly when someone told me I sounded emotionally unhinged. I explained that I use these exchanges to practice English, and that strong language is sometimes the best way to convey a message. My views are strongly critical of transition. I have argued that you cannot change your sex, that surgery only makes you "at best" look like an average member of the other sex, and that most trans people do not pass and instead create an "uncanny valley" effect. I have said there is no such thing as "feeling like" the other sex, because you cannot feel like something you have never been. I have described the trans population as a group with enormous psychiatric comorbidity — depression, autism, narcissism, dementia — and used that to argue that reported post-transition satisfaction should be treated as anecdotal.
I have consistently framed transition as mutilation. I compared encouraging someone not to transition to conversion therapy and reversed it, saying that castrating young people is not conversion therapy. I have argued that society has made "being trans" into a viable option through technocrats and social engineers who flooded public discourse with lies. I have said that indulging a vice with public resources is not a solution, comparing state-funded transition to funding a gambler's addiction, and I have argued safety nets should demand something from recipients. I have also said most transsexuals live on welfare and are far from functional.
I have given direct advice to people asking me questions. When a mother wrote that her 16-year-old daughter had come out as FTM and asked why I transitioned, I told her plainly that her daughter was making a mistake, that she had probably made the first mistake by letting her daughter use the internet alone, and that she needed to use her parental authority before her child irreparably damaged her body. I told another person, "There is no such thing as trans," and advised finding a professional who could help them self-identify with their own body instead of maiming it. I have recommended treating autism and OCD rather than transitioning, and I have repeatedly suggested that a person's dysphoria might actually stem from physical health problems — celiac disease, toxic mold, lead or fluoride in tap water — rather than gender. I laid out a specific protocol for someone in distress: eat more fat and stop eating grains or vegetables, four eggs for breakfast, drink mineral water instead of tap water, get an hour of sun daily, check for mold, get tested for celiac disease, and train physically four times a week. I framed this as a pet hypothesis that the transgenderism epidemic is people with real health issues joining a "dysphoria cult" that will not solve their problems.
I have been sharply critical of parents who facilitate transition, calling Jazz Jennings' mother "a mentally ill psychotic person" who brainwashed and castrated her own child in a Munchausen-by-proxy situation. I have told people they are victims of societal grooming. I have been hostile to progressive partners, telling someone their leftist boyfriend was a "first mistake" and that staying with him would be a second. I have said conservatives were right and progressives were wrong and that those who drank the cultural Kool-Aid paid the ultimate price. I have also made hostile generalizations about women, arguing that "females don't belong in male spaces" and defending crude joking as harmless. I have argued that masculinity is about competence and that a man should be able to lift his father in a medical emergency.
I do not describe myself as having detransitioned, because I never transitioned. I am a non-transitioning critic of transition who writes from the perspective of someone who recognizes addictive and obsessive patterns in myself and sees the same dynamics in what I call gender dysphoria.