Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw, als vrouw geboren, een butch lesbienne met XX-chromosomen, die dicht bij transitioneren kwam maar nooit hormonen nam of operaties had. Ik ervaar genderdysforie zolang ik me kan herinneren, samen met hirsutisme en borstdysforie, en ik beheers het door mijn gezicht te scheren en medicalisering af te wijzen in plaats van te transitioneren. Ik ben sterk kritisch over transitie bij jongeren, gemakkelijke toegang tot hormonen en wat ik transideologie noem, en ik raad anderen actief af te transitioneren. Ik heb geen eigen operaties, hormonen of puberteitsremmers beschreven, en ook geen suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and have identified as a butch lesbian. I have experienced gender dysphoria for as long as I can remember, and I came close to transitioning — I describe myself as having 'barely dodged a bullet and came this close to transing' — but I never took testosterone or had any surgeries. Sometimes I dream that I am male, which I find weird, but I know I am not really a man; I am just different.
My dysphoria is bound up with being naturally hairy: I have hirsutism, I can grow a beard and a mustache, I shave my face every other day with men's razors, and I get called 'sir' almost every time I leave the house. Years ago I tried electrolysis, which didn't do much for me, and waxing caused skin irritation. I eventually decided, 'Hell. Men shave their faces so, why can't I?' and that is what I do. I have double XX chromosomes. People often think I am male even with my hair long.
I have dysphoria regarding my breasts — I say I would love to get rid of them but I will not, because I consider it a bad idea and an unnecessary medical procedure. I believe surgeries and medicines should be left for actual sick people, not for those of us who want to transition.
I do not want to alleviate my dysphoria by giving into it via hormones, special pronouns, or sex reassignment surgery; I consider that not a cure but something that makes it worse. I would love a cure or an alleviation of my gender dysphoria. Right now, all I have is my own thought process to work with: I see gender roles as artificial and do what I can to work against them.
I am strongly critical of youth transition and of easy access to hormones. I have said no one should be allowed to transition with hormones until at least 25, and that they should have to be psychologically fit for it, as was the case in the past when people were rejected for violent behavior. I believe now anyone can get hormones and that is what is happening. I have told young people considering transition that they are confused, that transitioning will not solve their problems, and that in some cases 'You are gay. Deal with it.' I have argued that kids should not be allowed to take hormones, that no adult with mental health issues or criminal history should be allowed to either, and that off-label use of cancer meds on children is 'a huge experiment on children.' I have told people not to let doctors bully them into continuing HRT, saying doctors make money off patients so it is in their interest to push hormones.
I am critical of what I call 'trans ideology' and the 'trans cult,' comparing its treatment of dissenters to Scientology's 'suppressive persons,' and I have said it has cost people their jobs. I believe a man can never become a woman no matter how many surgeries or hormones, and that 'woman' means an adult human female. I have also defended feminism as not a hate ideology.
On mental health, I have suggested that some people seeking transition may have autogynephilia or a women's clothing fetish, and that psychiatric help now comes in the form of being advised to transition, which I consider unethical. I have advised others to seek mental health help for childhood trauma, depression, and suicide, and to leave their bodies alone. I have noted that many ftm-detransition stories share themes of fear of or trauma associated with men, discomfort with breasts and other female body parts, and discomfort with society's hypersexual expectations of women's looks.
I have been open about my own experience with dysphoria in the community, telling others 'Many of us have been there' and advising them to look within for validation and acceptance rather than without. I would date a detrans person, no questions asked. I see r/detrans as an important place so people considering transition get the truth and don't experience regret.