Alle verhalen

Dysforie op zijn 4e, opgelost op zijn 7e — nooit getransitioneerd

Man · Gedesisteerd3,9K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een homoseksuele man, als man geboren, die van mijn 3e tot mijn 6e genderdysforie had, die eind jaren 90 met verkennende therapie verdween, en ik ben nooit getransitioneerd. Ik ben een uitgesproken genderkritische voorvechter geworden die detransitioners steunt, jeugdzorg met genderbevestiging in twijfel trekt en één-op-één gesprekken aanbiedt aan mensen die twijfelen aan transitie. Ik definieer mezelf stellig als volwassen menselijke man en wijs moderne trans- en non-binaire identiteitskaders af. Ik ben zelf niet gedetransitioneerd, maar sterk betrokken bij de detransitiegemeenschap en kritisch over de moderne LGBT-beweging.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and grew up in Quebec. Between the ages of three and six I insisted I was a girl and would regularly ask my mom to call a magician to turn me into a girl. My parents eventually made me see a psychologist in the late 1990s; I was too young to remember the sessions, but whatever exploratory work we did clearly helped, because I stopped saying I was a girl and stopped thinking about it. I later had some gender confusion again in my teenage years, but that too went away once I did an honest introspection of myself. I never socially transitioned, never took hormones, and never had any surgery — my story is one of childhood gender confusion that resolved on its own with exploratory therapy rather than affirmation. By my own account I am a 27-year-old gay man (as of September 2022). I have never described myself as detransitioned, because I never transitioned, but I have become deeply invested in the detransition community and in gender-critical advocacy. I offered myself up for one-on-one audio conversations with detransitioners who wanted to vent, people questioning their own transition, and trans people who wanted to talk to a gender-critical person. I described myself as a great listener who prefers voice calls to writing. My main driver, as far as I can articulate it, is that I believe gender ideology is 'extremely regressive and harmful, especially to the newer generations of children and teenagers.' I say I have researched and verified these views over the last few years, and that I have 'seen things I wish I could unsee.' I recommend Abigail Shrier's book 'Irreversible Damage,' the site Transgender Trend, Jesse Singal's writing, and a neurologist's debunking of 'trans brain' studies. I also point to how easy it is to get hormones from Planned Parenthood without a mental health letter, and I question the claim that gender-affirming care is life-saving for kids, noting youth suicide rates have not dropped as GAC has expanded. I hold a firm biological-sex-based view of womanhood: 'A woman is a female human of adult age,' and I argue trans women are adult male human beings, i.e., men, and that saying so should not be controversial. I am critical of the modern LGBT community, saying it has 'disappointed me to the highest extent,' particularly in how detransitioners are treated. I am also critical of non-binary as an identity, seeing it as conflating gender non-conformity with not being a man or a woman. I am not personally detransitioned, but I am a gay man with a history of childhood gender dysphoria who has become a vocal gender-critical advocate and supporter of detransitioners. I believe transition can be a reasonable last-resort option in very rare, severe, persistent cases of dysphoria, but that it is currently presented as the default rather than the exception. I encourage young people questioning transition to reduce internet and trans-forum consumption, take time, and pursue self-acceptance first.