Alle verhalen

Op haar 11e wilde ze een man zijn — en ze groeide in haar eigen huid

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd116
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw die tussen mijn 11e en 14e een man wilde zijn maar nooit transitioneerde, en ik zeg nu dat ik er spijt van zou hebben als ik het had gedaan, omdat ik het fijn vind om vrouw te zijn. Ik betoog dat mensen andere psychische problemen, waaronder door depressie gedreven zelfhaat, moeten oplossen vóór ze transitioneren, en ik vrees dat spijt na een operatie suïcidaliteit kan verdiepen. Tegelijk geef ik toe dat ik therapie niet leuk vind en niet begrijp, ook al noem ik het een noodzakelijke voorwaarde voor transitie. Ik benadruk de blijvendheid van de effecten van testosteron en geloof dat open discussie over deze kwesties wordt gesmoord omdat het als transfobie zou worden bestempeld. Ik beschrijf geen eigen medische ingrepen en meld geen huidige dysforie of detransitie.

Volledig verhaal

I have been writing on Reddit about transition, therapy, and regret, and my own history with wanting to be a man figures centrally in what I say. I tell people that kids shouldn't be drawn into medical transition, explaining my own experience this way: "I wanted to be a man at the age of 11-14. If I had done anything, I would regret it now since I enjoy being a woman." That is the core of my story — a childhood wish to be male that faded, leaving me glad I never acted on it. Because of that, I argue strongly that people need to resolve their other mental health issues before transitioning. I worry that self-hate driven by depression can be mistaken for gender dysphoria, and I've written, "What if it's your self hate form depression leading you to it? This is why we need therapy before letting people transition." I also raise the danger of regret compounding existing distress: "If they were suicidal before, having a surgery and then regretting it will make them extra suicidal." At the same time, I'm openly skeptical of therapy itself. I've admitted, "Tbh, I hate therapy too. I don't get how it works. You just… talk? Can't you jsut speak to yourself? Or wrote in a journal?" So my position is a complicated one: I want therapy as a gatekeeping prerequisite for transition, even though I personally don't find therapy useful or understand how it works. I'm also concerned about the limits placed on clinicians. I've suggested that "Therapists might even lose their jobs if they tell a trans person 'maybe you aren't trans, you should think about it more. It might come from your self hate.'" I believe the discourse around this is constrained — when asked why something isn't said more openly, I replied, "Because that would be seen as transphobia." On medical effects, I emphasize permanence, particularly regarding testosterone: "It never goes higher. Once you take testosterone, it will never go back." I've also offered practical suggestions to someone trying to raise their voice, comparing it to "how some trans men try to speak with lower voice" — saying maybe you can train your voice higher by speaking with a higher voice. Beyond transition specifically, I hold fairly libertarian views about bodily autonomy, while acknowledging the tension they create. I've argued that "Only way you are able to consent is by saying no. You can't say yes. You only have consent to say no, that's all that should matter," and on vaccination I wrote that "If kids don't want to get vaccinated for plague, you should be able to force them. Even tho it's their body their choice" — an intentionally contradictory statement about autonomy. I don't describe any hormones, surgeries, or medical interventions of my own — my account is of a childhood wish I did not act on. I don't discuss my mental health diagnoses, family, relationships, sexuality, or current identity beyond identifying as someone who enjoys being a woman and is glad I didn't transition as a young person.