Alle verhalen

Als kind dakloos, daarna een kliniek die nooit vroeg waarom

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd176
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (gedesisteerde) vrouw met PTSS door dakloosheid in mijn kindertijd, en ik geloof dat mijn transgender-identificatie een traumareactie was die een genderkliniek niet in twijfel trok. Op één dag kwam ik ongebruikelijk veel transgender-iconografie in het openbaar tegen, waardoor ik werd geconfronteerd met hoe wijdverbreid het fenomeen is geworden en hoeveel van mijn eigen verleden ik nog probeer achter me te laten. Ik heb een kritische kijk op de huidige golf van transgender-identificatie, maar hecht eraan dat ik geen onverdraagzaamheid wil tonen tegenover individuele transgender mensen. Ik voel me gekwetst door leugens die me zijn verteld en door mensen die niet luisterden naar alarmerende dingen, en ik maak me oprecht zorgen om mijn generatie. In een latere discussie werd ik aangesproken op vijandige opmerkingen die ik elders had gemaakt, wat botst met mijn uitgesproken wens geen bigot te zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I went for a walk to the beach on a single day and was struck by how much transgender iconography I encountered in barely two hours: a tall person wearing a lesbian flag sweater, then a trans woman, then a car with a customised red number plate reading 'FTM' with a bearded person visible through the tinted windows, and finally a trans flag fan sticking out of a window on a nearby main street. I live in a western country (not America), and I noted that ten years ago nobody in the general population knew the colours of the trans flag, whereas now it seems to be everywhere. I tried to be careful about how I framed this. I clarified that representation itself is not 'the boogeyman,' but argued it can indicate a surge in social influence and a rapid change in the political climate that creates a 'perfect storm' for vulnerable or otherwise normal people to change the course of their lives. I also corrected myself publicly, noting that in my last sentence I should have written 'transgender iconography' rather than 'transgender people,' because I do not want to be bigoted against individuals but rather to question what ensues by way of social influence. I explicitly said the last thing I want to seem like is a bigot, and that I have simply had enough of seeing or hearing about this topic because of my past. Underneath the observation is real pain. I described myself as 'very hurt and picking up the pieces of lies that were told to me, as well as people who never listened to truly alarming things.' I said I am scared for my peers and that I don't want to see people 'erase themselves like I did' — indicating I have detransitioned or desisted and view my prior transition as a form of self-erasure. I go walking to clear my head and move beyond what I called an unhealthy past, only to find that past 'adorned' or 'embellished' in a myriad of places in close proximity, which made me realise how widespread the phenomenon is. I framed my reaction as genuine concern for my generation rather than anger or 'seething.' I also disclosed that I have PTSD from becoming homeless as a child. During that period of homelessness I encountered a gender clinic, and I said they never suggested even once that identifying as transgender might have been a trauma response — instead, in my words, 'they thought layering on another vulnerability would fix me.' I believe my transgender identification was connected to childhood trauma and that the clinic failed to examine it. I hold a critical view of the current prevalence of transgender identification, suggesting that if transgenderism is a real phenomenon it only covers a minutia of people who comfortably live their lives presenting as the opposite sex, well below what is currently observed. I do not appear hostile to individual transgender people, but I am wary of the social and political dynamics around the topic and concerned about its influence on my peers and generation. Later, in an exchange with another user, I was challenged about my own presence in the community: someone pointed out I had recently been active on 4tran4 and quoted me commenting on a post about someone being misgendered with the words 'they should pass a law allowing tr*****s to kill people like this,' using that to question whether I am a 'well-rounded, desisted female.' I did not respond further in the supplied transcript.