Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich eerder als FTM identificeerde. Ik nam afstand van de transgemeenschap en online transgroepen, die volgens mij mijn verlangen om man te zijn versterkten, en ontdekte dat accepteren dat ik nooit een man zal zijn — en dat daar niets mis mee is — heilzaam is geweest. Ik heb sterk gendercritische opvattingen, geloof dat het biologische geslacht onveranderlijk is en heb gepleit tegen het verbannen van de detrans-subreddit, zodat detransitioners hun eigen verhaal kunnen vertellen. Ik heb geen medische transitiestappen, operaties of hormoongebruik beschreven. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of zelfmoordpogingen genoemd.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female, and I identified as trans for a period of my life — I used the label FTM in the past. I never gave a specific age or date for when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, or whether I ever medically transitioned, so I can't fill in those details.
What I can say is that being around trans people, especially online, made me want to be a guy even more. It reminded me of what I described as "those horrible feelings." I noticed that a lot of the people I spoke to who identified as FTM seemed to be attracted to males — some so much so that I wondered whether they were so obsessed with gay men that they had started to believe they were gay men themselves. That observation stuck with me.
Once I distanced myself from the trans community, I started to feel better. I hadn't been away from it very long at the time I wrote about this, but I had already noticed a shift. The key change for me was trying to accept that I will never be a man, and — crucially — that there is nothing wrong with that. That acceptance has been beneficial to me. I now look back at a time when I told someone else that I hoped they wouldn't "grow out of" wanting to be the opposite sex, and I'm kicking myself for ever having that thought.
I came to believe that online trans groups only intensify feelings of envy toward the opposite sex, and I actively warn others — particularly young people — to stay away from them. My view is that people encouraging others to identify as the opposite sex are deluding them, the way I felt I was deluded, and that the goal is to make young people lifelong medical patients so money can be made off them. I hold a strongly gender-critical position: I believe biological sex is real and immutable, that you cannot simply be "whatever you want," and that not liking something about your body doesn't change what you are. I also think the label "trans" means very little, since a biological female cannot be "just a guy" without being trans.
I have been vocal about detransition and desistance. When there was talk of the detrans subreddit being banned, I argued strenuously against it, saying the sub only demonstrates that detransitioners and desistors exist and is a place for people to tell their own stories. I saw the potential ban as evidence that "the woke crowd is scared of detrans people telling their stories," and said that if the sub fell, it would prove our experiences go so against the narrative that we had to be silenced. I distinguished between gender-critical spaces, which I said are at least anti-trans in ideology, and the detrans sub, which I felt wasn't going against the existence of trans people at all — making its potential ban a different and more alarming level of censorship.
I've also commented on the culture around trans activism, agreeing with the characterization that "some people say it's a cult," and I've pushed back on the idea that concerns about biological sex being labeled hate speech come only from fringe activists, pointing to the replies to J.K. Rowling as evidence. I understand transmeds to acknowledge biological sex, and I view their ideological opposites unfavorably.
I haven't described any surgeries, hormone use, medical complications, fertility concerns, formal diagnoses, therapy experiences, family reactions, romantic relationships, or my sexuality before or after detransition — none of that appears in what I've written. I also haven't expressed regret about specific medical procedures, because I haven't stated whether I had any. My regret, as I've expressed it, is more about the mindset I held and the time I spent believing I could become something I can't. I haven't discussed my current quality of life beyond saying that distancing myself from the trans community made me feel better and that accepting my biological sex has been beneficial.