Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben geboren als man en heb gedetransitioneerd/gedesisteerd na een periode waarin ik me als trans identificeerde, gedreven door vroeg optredende sekse-dysforie, fantasiedenken dat ik toeschrijf aan autisme of een schizospectrumneiging, en andere geestesziekten. Sporten, goed voor mezelf zorgen en een periode van dissociatie hielpen me het hele idee los te laten; na ongeveer een jaar besefte ik dat ik me prettiger in mijn lichaam voelde dan ooit. Ik zie mezelf nu als een hetero, matig mannelijke man en ik krimp soms nog ineen bij mijn lichaam, maar kan erom lachen. Ik sta kritisch tegenover transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, en betoog dat spijtpercentages onbekend zijn en dat transitie een laatste redmiddel moet zijn. Ik heb geen specifieke medische ingrepen of operaties beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male, and I grew up with an intense discomfort with my sex-specific biology that started young — the classic stuff, as I've called it. For a long time I had the recurring thought, "I wonder if I would be happier as a woman," and I went through a period of actually living that out, though I never stopped believing, even while I was in it, that "I will never be a woman" — because, in my words, you can never be the opposite sex, and I thought the refusal to accept that was actual delusion. I described the whole thing to myself as an experiment, and eventually I went back to the way things were.
What helped me most was simply taking care of myself — working out, lifting weights, going outside, using my energy for positive things — and realizing that the fantasy thinking I'd been caught in was just that: fantasy thinking, which I've attributed to autism or a schizospectrum tendency. I also had other mental illnesses beyond dysphoria, and I eventually got over the dysphoria itself. At one point something sent me into a massive disassociation bout, and that disassociation actually allowed me to quit the whole idea of transitioning. I used to dissociate at times and found it really tough to see why I was alive; working out and putting my energy into positive things turned it around. After about a year it just hit me: I'm more comfortable. Getting older has also made me worry less about these things.
I quickly became comfortable being male again. I took the label of male and don't care if I do "unmale" things — I don't feel that I do, but I don't sweat it either. I consider myself a straight male and moderately masculine, though to some I appear feminine in my actions and thoughts, and I don't care, because I think rigidly living up to an image or rebelliously subverting it are both shallow and filled with showmanship. I woke up and realized I was straight once I got all the influences out of my life. I still look at my body and cringe sometimes, but now I can laugh more.
I'm indigenous — I've mentioned Mexican background and rural Mexican reporting — and while I don't consider traditional "third genders" the same as what's pushed today, I noted they often had larger cultural impacts and involved a spiritualist role, though they could feel a little constraining. What I do now is remember that people have huge ranges of behaviors and identity not tied to sex, so whatever you decide is yours and what you tolerate are your own, and medicalization need not be involved.
I've become quite critical of transition, especially for young people. I've argued that trans regret rates are not low and that no accurate numbers exist — people who simply stop showing up aren't counted, and those who reverse a social transition without stating regret aren't pursued. I've said the majority of people who transition do not experience any decrease in suicidality. I've been blunt about surgery, calling it maiming, and I've criticized pediatric transition in strong terms regarding growth, bones, health, and the impossibility of effective SRS later. I think transitioning should be the last option, and I've told others that being uncomfortable in your body when young is a stereotype older than any of us and that growing up is strange. I've also pushed back on the idea that estrogen changes personality or politics — I never stopped being not-PC or changed my political beliefs on or off it. I don't watch even the "based" or "good" transition-related content because I don't want it spread in any capacity, and I've noted that PragerU and a political lens push me away from some analyses. I've advised others to get off the internet, do therapy, and stop labeling themselves after porn terms.
I don't describe myself as regretting specific medical interventions because I don't recall stating I had hormones or surgeries — my account centers on the identity, the fantasy thinking, and the discomfort rather than procedures. The discomfort and cringing at my body have improved over time: it's stable-to-improving, and I can laugh about it now.