Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerd non-binair geïdentificeerd persoon met aanzienlijke genderdysforie die ervoor koos niet te transitioneren, en tot de conclusie kwam dat mijn NB-identificatie voortkwam uit het gevoel geen 'goed genoeg' vrouw te zijn. Ik besloot tegen hormonen vanwege zorgen over mijn zangstem, doordat ik zag dat vrienden na hun transitie niet gelukkiger waren, het accepteren dat ik door en door vrouw ben en onzekerheid over de vraag of mijn ongemak echt dysforie was. Ik red me met gendernonconformiteit (kort haar, mannelijke stijl) en sport/lichaamsverbinding. Ik steun de toegang van trans mensen tot transitie, terwijl ik kritisch ben over de huidige orthodoxie, stereotypering en op identiteit gebaseerde politiek. Ik identificeer me als gedesisteerd persoon die als gendernonconforme vrouw leeft.
Volledig verhaal
I have significant gender dysphoria and for a while I wavered under the non-binary umbrella, but I ultimately decided not to transition. My body is female, and surgery is both financially and practically not an option for me, so I chose to learn to live with my body — this is my choice for my body and won't be right for everyone. I do think transition and surgical treatment is right for some trans people and I will always support access to it.
I came to identify as a desisted non-binary person after taking a deep dive through these issues and concluding that my identification with NB was because I didn't think I was a 'good enough' woman. I believe that's an incredibly harmful message to send to young women. I now see the current framing around gender non-conformity and identity as super regressive and reliant on stereotyping.
Several things held me back from hormones: I like to sing and was worried hormones would damage my voice (lower is fine, inability to sing is not); my friends who have transitioned don't seem happier for it, which put me off taking such a radical step when it might not help or could make things worse; knowing that I am female to my very bones and nothing I do will change that — if I could button-press I would, but that isn't an option, so why risk pain, complications and lifelong medication dependency for something that wouldn't fix my issue the way I wish it could; and uncertainty about whether my discomfort with my physical body is really dysphoria or something else, which led me to decide I didn't want to do this to myself while in any way unsure.
How I live with my dysphoria is by embracing the gender non-conformity that comes with being me — for me that means short hair and a masculine style. Our biology doesn't dictate how we can choose to express ourselves. Also important for me has been exercise and feeling connected to my body; doing full-on exercise and learning to really be in my body has helped me feel better in myself. I live in a western culture where we tend to live in our heads and treat bodies as things that get our minds where we want them to go rather than as fully integrated parts of us.
I struggle with being fully on board with current orthodoxy around trans issues. I think it's fine to be gender non-conforming as a man or woman and dress however you want, and it's fine to be a trans man or trans woman and live your best life — trans people deserve respect, love and safety. But the current way of talking about sex/gender and stereotypes, plus the idea that you can be trans even without dysphoria, can lead gender non-conforming people to think they MUST be trans, which I don't think is always or automatically the case. I believe some people will explore and discover they are trans because they are GNC, but it shouldn't be expected that all GNC people will want to or should transition.
I also think that without some definition of what a 'man' or 'woman' is, the idea of being trans becomes meaningless because you'd have no means of explaining how your experience of your body and identity sets you in opposition to the one you were born as. I'm pretty certain that just as there are people with autogynephilia, there are people with autoandrophilia, so some gay FTMs fit into that box.
Politically I am mostly a left-leaning liberal and I believe in each human being's right to freedom from religious or ideological persecution and to a life free from material threats to existence. It took me a long time to see that current approaches to so-called progressive politics are fundamentally illiberal and opposed to functioning societies. I felt something was 'off' with social justice as it currently stands but didn't know what until I read Cynical Theories. I think reducing everyone down to identities and labels dissolves communities, societies and democracies. I'm critical of postmodernism and the 'words are violence' idea, seeing it as unhealthy and destructive — it rejects logic, science, empiricism and rationality, and won't accept logical rebuttals as valid critique.