Alle verhalen

Oestrogeen en masculiene vrouwen brachten haar terug naar vrouw zijn

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd701
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als meisje werd geboren, transitioneerde om als man te leven en later detransitioneerde; oestrogeen nemen en masculiene/androgyne vrouwen vinden om me mee te identificeren hielpen me opnieuw te accepteren dat ik vrouw ben. Ik schrijf mijn transitie toe aan een combinatie van mijn seksuele oriëntatie, seksueel trauma en niet voldoen aan geslachtsstereotypen, en ik betoog nu actief tegen het idee dat genderidentiteit aangeboren is. Ik ben lesbisch, ongewoon lang en in veel opzichten nog een tomboy, maar ik voel me niet meer slecht over vrouw zijn. Ik post veel in genderkritische en detransruimtes waar ik pleit tegen zelfidentificatie, fantoomgeslachtskenmerken en transitie van jongeren, en ik pleit voor alternatieven voor medische transitie. Ik beschrijf geen huidige suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.

Volledig verhaal

I am a detransitioned woman — I was born female, transitioned to live as a man, and have since detransitioned. I don't have exact dates for most of my transition timeline in what I've shared publicly, but I've described myself plainly as "a detrans female" and "a detrans woman," and I've said that taking estrogen helped me after detransition, along with finding things about being a woman and even femininity/female gender roles that I enjoyed. I'm still a tomboy in a lot of ways, but I no longer feel bad about being a woman. As for what led me to transition, I've said that in my case it was a combination of my sexual orientation, sexual trauma, and not conforming to sex stereotypes that made me identify as male. I've argued publicly that the main causes of this kind of distress are autogynephilia and internalized homophobia, and that the reasons people want to transition are usually related to sex — asking what else would motivate someone to fixate so heavily on their sex characteristics besides sexual trauma. I've also said that people who don't desist from childhood gender dysphoria tend to have more trauma, greater childhood adversity, and more autistic or obsessive traits, so they seem to have more trouble coping with or accepting their sex than the majority of children with gender identity disorder who just end up gay or bisexual. I'm unusually tall and gay — I've described myself as "an outlier, both physically and psychologically." I've talked about being a tomboy and about relating to women with rough, androgynous, or masculine personalities that I could look up to. I don't think I've shared details about specific surgeries or medical complications, so I can't speak to those. I do recall that birth control helped me with period pain. On the question of what moved me toward detransition, I've emphasized that taking estrogen helped and that finding role models — women with more rough/androgynous/masculine personalities I could relate to — mattered. I've also advised others dealing with body discomfort to separate whether the issue is that their body feels like it doesn't belong to them versus the assumptions they think other people are making about them based on their body. I've become quite vocal in gender-critical and detrans spaces. I post and comment extensively arguing against the idea that gender identity is innate or brain-based, against "phantom" sex characteristics, and against self-ID definitions of man and woman. I've compared trans identification to Rachel Dolezal identifying as Black, and I've argued that not accepting a belief system is not the same as denying someone human rights. I've shared studies on intersex conditions (CAIS, cloacal exstrophy, congenital adrenal hyperplasia), brain sexual dimorphism, and Blanchard's two-type model. I've also written a longer post analyzing trans ideology from a linguistic perspective, distinguishing semantics from pragmatics. I've given practical advice to others: when asked for pronouns, I suggest saying "I'm not trans" and letting people go off appearance; I've suggested using no pronouns and referring to someone by name; and I've offered advice to someone with a daughter questioning gender about asking open, non-judgmental questions in a "drip drip drip" rather than an interrogation. I don't currently describe myself as suicidal or as having self-harmed. My mental health seems stable now — I've said I don't feel bad about being a woman anymore. My regret isn't expressed in anguished terms in what I've shared, but I clearly frame my transition as rooted in trauma, sexual orientation, and nonconformity rather than an innate identity, and I advocate against transition for others, particularly young people, on that basis.