Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I am female, and I have lived with fairly severe sex dysphoria for most of my life. I came out at 14 and started cross-sex hormones at 15, transitioning young because I saw it as my only option to treat my dysphoria and because, as a kid, I didn't have much foresight. I passed fairly easily, so I never experienced much social difficulty from being transsexual, but I never associated with mainstream trans culture — I thought of myself as a medical transsexual rather than transgender, and back then I believed in the idea of brain sex and a mismatch that could only be fixed by transition.
I also had top surgery as a minor — a double mastectomy at sixteen, on the surgeon's recommendation, for a chest I described as small-chested, probably an A-cup, though I only ever wore sports bras so I'm not certain. I didn't require drains and healed quickly, which I attributed to my age. Bottom surgery had been the ultimate goal throughout my transition; I thought I was going to have it at 18 and, if I could have had it as a minor, I might have. I am overwhelmingly glad I did not do that to myself.
Over the years the reality of my situation wore on me. No matter how well I passed, I would always be transsexual, never an actual male; I would always need hormones and never have a normal life as a man. I realized I was living as a "decoy male," always at least a little anxious about being found out, always maintaining a facade. I described my testosterone use as essentially an unhealthy coping mechanism and a form of denial — I used it to cope with what I call body dysmorphia (sex dysphoria), knowing it wasn't healthy for my body or my mind, but not knowing what to do without it. I compared it to using drugs or alcohol to cope with depression: it made me feel better but wasn't a real solution, and covering the problem up for so long made it harder to recover than if I had never become dependent on HRT.
I detransitioned because I recognized I could not change my sex and would not be happy unless I came to terms with my body and stopped being obsessed with changing it. I stopped considering myself trans years ago. My sexuality shifted along the way: I came out as bisexual, then lesbian, in middle school; when I first decided to transition I considered myself a straight man, then bi, and for a little while thought I was a gay man. After reidentifying I went back to being primarily interested in women. I find some men attractive, but the idea of interacting with a man sexually is entirely unappealing to me. I have never been in a serious relationship — just two short ones, one well before I even thought about transition — and I'd love to have a girlfriend, but I struggle to imagine any woman going for me since I'm too mannish for gay women and too female for straight women.
I now identify as a butch lesbian. I don't think of myself as cis or trans because I don't have a gender identity; I am a woman solely on the basis that I am biologically female, and had I been born male I would be a man. I don't identify with my birth sex — I'm just no longer actively disidentifying with it. I stopped believing in "gender" altogether: it's not that I started to think of myself as a woman, it's that I realized I objectively was one, and had been throughout the entire process.
Dysphoria hasn't vanished. I still have it and it's pretty severe honestly, but I've gotten a lot more comfortable with my body, particularly over the past year, and I feel better about my body and looks now than I ever did while transitioning. I've learned to appreciate aspects of my body I didn't think about before — I actually like my body hair more now than I did back then. There are still aspects of my appearance I will likely never be comfortable with.
My mastectomy is the thing I feel most conflicted about. Immediately afterwards I felt relief because I didn't have to bind anymore, but after a short while it wasn't enough — I didn't feel as happy or relieved as I thought I would, and I was still very dysphoric about the rest of my body. That was one of the first big things that made me question my transition. My regret wasn't immediate but has become more of a nagging, ongoing feeling. I will never get breast implants, so there's not much I can do; I wish I hadn't gone under the knife and I feel like something is missing from me, and I probably always will to some extent. Physically, I get occasional sharp pains in my chest that I assume are related to the surgery — nerve damage and nerve pain are possible long-term side effects. My surgery was nearly five years ago as of mid-2025. I wish I still had my breasts, even though there are other physical changes from my transition I wouldn't go back on.
Therapy has been a consistent frustration. In early 2023 I had a second appointment with a therapist to whom I had explicitly explained that I am gender critical and don't believe in trans beliefs or gender identity, and after all that he said, "I wonder if maybe you could be genderfluid." When I reiterated that I don't believe in gender identity he said, "That would actually be agender." I told him no, I'm not any of that, and I don't think I'll see him again. Every therapist I've seen pushes gender beliefs on me and ignores what I say. I've also found it hard to relate to other detransitioners, because many are content going back to their original-ish body physically; when I see progress photos of people who went off hormones, I feel terror at the idea of that being me.
As of mid-2023 I was still on testosterone after three years of it, passing myself off as male to satisfy my sex dysmorphia while knowing it was rotting my mental health. I described being dependent on cross-sex hormones to the point that just thinking about going off them caused pure dread, and I doubted I would ever be able to quit because of the personal repercussions. I called myself "a stunted woman" whose anxieties kept me from living a full life. I also described the cognitive dissonance of knowing I'm female while presenting as male as causing me distress, and said transition put an unhealthy degree of importance on my physical appearance that did a number on my self-esteem and mental health.
Legally, I changed my sex to male while transitioning and have not officially changed it back, nor have I legally changed my name from the male name I used. My current birth certificate says male; my original said female. My state ID card and passport both say female because I received both after detransitioning. My SSA data most likely says male and apparently cannot be changed. I want to legally change my name and gender back, and I care more about the sex being correct on documents than the name. When I first detransitioned I still put male when I signed up for things, and it took a long time to feel like I could "admit" to being female. I largely pass as male in real life. I changed my given name to something unisex because I felt more comfortable with that, though I don't have an issue with my original given name anymore — I just didn't feel like having such an overtly feminine name. Many people in my day-to-day life still call me by the masculine name I used while transitioning.
On causes, I've reflected that a lot of my dysphoria was a desire to be "normal": I couldn't be a conventional woman since I'm gay and inherently gender non-conforming, so I switched to being a man. I never grieved an idealized boyhood, but I was upset that childhood memories had to be kept secret because they'd give away I'd been a girl, and that my past couldn't be reconciled with my life as a "man." In ceasing to believe I am male, I found more comfort in my middle-school memories, which I'd previously couldn't revisit because they reminded me of something I hated in myself. I had a good experience in middle school, better than high school, likely because I wasn't trans yet.
Detransitioning has been mostly a relief. Being trans was nonstop anxiety — passing, my future, medical stuff — and while I still have anxieties, it's a relief that my existence no longer revolves around passing as male. I feel more connected to myself as a butch woman. When I was trans I wanted nothing to do with the trans community and didn't relate to most trans people, because I specifically didn't want to be trans — I wanted to be a cis man. I'm still isolated because I can't relate much to men or women: I'm not a man, but I'm so different from the average woman. Detransitioning made me research feminism much more, and I like having a community of other women who share my views.
Being a strongly GNC woman is isolating. Almost every GNC biological woman I know does not identify as a woman, so for pretty much any woman I have a lot in common with, I'm not allowed to acknowledge we're both female. All my close friends are either feminine women or trans/non-binary, and I don't have a single close friend I can relate to in terms of being a GNC woman. I find it exhausting to pretend I don't think beauty rituals like shaving and makeup are degrading, and I've noticed an unspoken rule that masculine women are tolerated only if they chronically recognize themselves as unusual.
I'm gender critical but not transphobic — I don't hate trans people. I view sex dysphoria as a subset of body dysmorphic disorder and don't think plastic surgery or cross-sex hormones are an appropriate treatment for it. I'm not against transition in all circumstances, but I think professionals should try to help people cope on their own first, and I believe sex dysphoria usually originates as a response to society, oppression, abuse, or other mental illnesses rather than being innate. I think more research should be done into less extreme treatments. I've recommended post-trans.com, a site of detransitioned women's stories, to people who are questioning, and I've offered to message with people going through similar experiences. I also think bottom surgeries are so fraught with complications that they shouldn't be treated as legitimate surgeries, and I've argued that gender and gender roles are a system of sexist oppression rather than innocuous self-expression.