Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd — maar toch gedetransitioneerd

Man · Gedesisteerd219
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die nooit medisch transitioneerde, maar opgroeide met het gevoel anders te zijn dan andere jongens en me uiteindelijk op biologische gronden met mezelf als man verzoende. Ik geloof nu dat er maar twee geslachten zijn, dat sekse biologisch gegrond is, en ik ben kritisch op wat ik zie als een non-binaire overname van transruimtes en op de gemakkelijke toegang tot onomkeerbare medische ingrepen voor jongeren. Ik heb ‘Irreversible Damage’ van Abigail Shrier gelezen en schrijf de toename van FtM/FtNB-transitie deels toe aan onderontdekt autisme bij meisjes, sociale isolatie door smartphones en online invloed. Ik heb geen eigen operaties, hormonen of huidige mentale crisis beschreven, maar ik heb anderen in crisis gesteund. Mijn huidige identiteit is een cisgender man, aan de rand van detransitie, die nooit transitioneerde.

Volledig verhaal

I never actually tried to transition or use different pronouns, but growing up I never related to the other boys in the locker room or at school. I was always shy, skinny, underweight, weaker, unable to read social cues, scared of the dark and horror movies. Over time I came to realize that I am a man for biological reasons: I have mostly male needs and male wants, and I find it easier to relate to men rather than women. No matter how much I tried to repress my sexuality, it always forced its way back, and I still want romantic relationships and sex with attractive women. I hold the view that there are only two genders and that sex is biologically connected to that; people can play with that if they want, but I believe the brain really needs sexuality to function. I've read 'Irreversible Damage: Teenage Girls and the Transgender Craze' by Abigail Shrier and while I disagree with some points, I think the explosion of FtM or FtNB girls attempting transition has a lot to do with underdiagnosis of girls on the autism spectrum. I also think smartphones, cheap high-speed internet, and loss of face-to-face socialization have left these girls fitting in even less and not relating to other girls. The popularity of trans celebrities (Laverne Cox, Caitlyn Jenner, Elliot Page) and broader LGBT acceptance play a part, as do online support groups that tell depressed, detached girls the only solution is transition, with very little pushback from psychiatric professionals before testosterone, double mastectomies, or hysterectomies. I think the solutions are: more checks before a teenager or young adult can order testosterone or irreversible procedures; more screening for autism and Asperger's in boys and girls; and decreasing children's screen time while encouraging outdoor play and pro-social behavior. I'm aware of infighting within the trans community, where the more censorship-happy and overly offended people usually 'win.' I find the pronoun focus annoying and attribute it to a non-binary 'takeover' of trans spaces. According to they/them etiquette it's considered more polite to assume non-binary pronouns for someone with a homely look and weird haircut, whereas the trans people I know (ftm or mtf) find they/them when he/her is clearly appropriate to be offensive and triggering. I use she/her when someone looks female and he/him when someone looks male, and I try to remember the rule: 'The internet isn't real.. stop being offended by it.' I have advised others going through doubt about top surgery that it is irreversible and I'm glad when someone with doubts gives themselves more time. I've told people to be easier on themselves, not let their past pick a worse future, 'pick a team' and define masculinity on their own terms through dating, work, and health goals, find better friends if their current circle can't accept them, but not cut off all ties to people they disagree with. I've noted that relationships are hard for people like us because it's hard to effectively express wants and needs to neurotypical people. I've also noted that many lesbians I know identify with masculine jobs like construction and plumbing, and that if I raised a daughter I would teach her to identify with both male and female characters whose traits she admires. I have responded to others in crisis with messages like 'Please don't take your life.. You have people that love and care for you and you have a lot to live for,' and 'Hugs, We are here for you!'