Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man (MtFtM) die zichzelf een autogynefilie-desister noemt, ongeveer 19-22 jaar na mijn transitie, nu getrouwd met een steunende vrouw. Ik schrijf mijn dysforie toe aan seksgerelateerd trauma in mijn kindertijd en een hechtings-/overdrachtsstoornis, gevormd door onbehandelde ADHD, PTSS en mijn afkomst als Aziatische jongen, en ik zeg dat therapie en begeleiding het hebben opgelost. Ik zie genderdysforie als een hechtingsgerelateerde ziekte die door testosteron wordt geseksualiseerd, en ik bekritiseer zowel de gangbare transideologie als het radicaal feminisme omdat die mannelijk trauma en mannelijke sterfte negeren. Ik ben stabiel en in vrede, met af en toe dysforie die ik beheers met basketbal, meditatie en mijn huwelijk. Ik doe informele belangenbehartiging voor andere MtFtM-detransitioners en betoog openlijk dat autogynefilie verhuld trauma is en niet zomaar een fetisj.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I have been detransitioned for many years now — by my own count, roughly 19 years sober from the whole thing, or closer to 22 if you count back to when I started detransitioning in my late teens. I describe myself as an MtFtM detransitioner and an autogynephilia desister, and I say plainly that therapy, counselling, and a wonderfully supportive wife got me through it.
What drove me toward transition, in my own reading of it, was sex-based trauma plus attachment failure. I frame gender dysphoria as an attachment-based disorder: my primary object of transference was unavailable or there was only a single caregiver, so transference got displaced. In my case I had untreated ADHD and PTSD, and white female teachers were compassionate toward me, so they became my object of transference. Because I am Asian, I noticed the problem in my dissociative identity — under trans ideology I wanted to be a white woman; when people asked what I felt like, I secretly thought "a (white) woman." I say that if race hadn't tipped me off, I might have stayed transitioned. I also say I had dysphoria long before the internet existed, so porn (including sissy hypno) was not the cause for me, though I acknowledge repeated viewing can create minor trauma in others.
I describe the sexual component of my dysphoria as trauma becoming sexualized under testosterone — testosterone making everything more intense, worsening stress, and hyperaccelerating sex drive so it adds a sexual dimension to the attachment disorder. I explicitly say I have been on testosterone blockers and/or testosterone at some point, though I don't give doses, dates, or durations. I don't mention any surgeries, and I don't mention fertility either way.
What moved me out was therapy and counselling focused on attachment and transference — I point others toward trauma therapists, Winnicott's holding/contained containers, object relations (Klein), and the second-person perspective in Darwall, Fichte, and Levinas, as well as Christ. I also recommend meditation on the present moment, Thich Nhat Hanh and Tara Brach on Insight Timer, gratitude, loving openly, and not doing what you know is harmful. I play basketball with my friends on days the dysphoria comes back. I have a wife who supports me.
I grew up around "bougie trans people and women who hated the poor" who also hated men, and I say I had an intellectual father — a philosopher whose name I won't give — whom I had the privilege of studying under, whose original work on the "culture of death" I draw on. I've been in detrans communities so long that a lot of members are kids to me; I say the number of people I've seen die in those communities is staggering, including old friends and both failed and successful suicide posts.
Mental health: I mention untreated ADHD and PTSD from childhood, and I describe gender dysphoria as essentially an extreme form of OCD — sex-based anxiety. I don't describe current symptoms or medication.
I don't recount specific assaults or abuse events in detail, but I repeatedly invoke sex-based trauma as the root of my own condition and of autogynephilia generally.
On sexuality and identity I don't state a orientation label directly, but I refer to my wife, so I was in a relationship with a woman. I don't describe a current identity beyond detransitioned/desisted male.
On regret, I don't use the word "regret" explicitly, but I treat the whole transition as something to be shaken off "forever," an addiction of dependency you can come off one day at a time, and I express bitterness that male detransitioners have no visible voice while female detransitioners get the spotlight. I don't describe worsening distress; my tone is that I'm at peace and stable, still occasionally hit by dysphoria but managing.
On attitudes toward transition for others, I'm critical of mainstream trans ideology while explicitly not opposing an androgynous society, and I criticize both radical feminists and TRAs. I've done informal advocacy: a long post defending a trauma/attachment account of autogynephilia against TERFs and Blanchardians, repeated arguments in r/detrans, and direct messages offering to help other detrans males. I say "For MtFtM detransitioners, you will never get this content again from anyone else I promise you." I also retracted one insult publicly, saying it was insensitive, and agreed to stop using a banned term in favor of "mainstream trans ideology."