Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male, and I've spent the last couple of years caught up in what I first thought was simple gender questioning but have come to understand very differently. I was diagnosed with OCD about six months ago — that would place the diagnosis around early 2022 — and a lot of my life before that makes more sense in light of it. My OCD mostly showed up as cleaning: spending hours and hours on certain things I cared about until I was too exhausted to continue. I also had what I'd call weird magical thinking. For example, I have to adjust my PC's volume to a number with two non-zero bits in its binary representation before using it — 96, but never 100 — before I can use it.
When I first started my gender journey about a year and a half before this post — so around early 2021 — I thought it was straightforward gender questioning. It turned out to be very OCD-like: I was ruminating for hours on end trying to prove that I wasn't trans. I'm still dealing with it, though not as badly as it used to be.
One of the strangest things I deal with, and something I haven't found anyone else who experiences, is that I basically have two mindspaces. One is the real one, where I can mostly tell what's going on — unless I have a really bad OCD episode — and can discern my own thoughts and feelings. The other is a kind of 'fantasy' plane where I'm detached from myself and reality, and where I can experience anything in a very empathetic way. If I read an MTF's story, in that headspace it feels like euphoria when she describes it, and I can empathize with the changes she wants, even though I don't necessarily want that for myself. The same thing happens when I read an FTM's story — I enter that headspace and empathize with the euphoria he's describing. I actually tried this recently as a test and was very surprised to feel the euphoria the trans guy was talking about, because up until then I had only obsessively read MTF stories to test my own feelings.
The other thing is feelings I can't categorize as good or bad, but I can tell are related to OCD — they feel like a weird warm anxiety. I get the same feelings when I've had other obsessions, like fear of being a pedophile or fear of incest, that mimic 'wanting it' even though I can clearly tell I don't want any of that. With the gender theme it's much harder to tell. Because of that I can experience 'gender envy,' doubt about things like the button test, and so on. Since I've spent so much time agonizing over my gender, I can even get anxious in the fantasy plane about being male, even though when I return to reality I realize I don't have that feeling at all. It's very strange.
Another thing that makes the whole 'dysphoria' concept seem fragile to me: whenever I touch the tips of my index fingers together, the anxiety and doubt vanish. I guess it's an OCD ritual, but it works, and it shows how fragile my own thoughts and sense of self can be.
I've also noticed things about my dreams. Funnily enough, I never had a dream with me as a woman. The only dreams I had were of me as a herculean dude, and even my wet dreams were with me as a guy. I don't think dreams are very important — what you want when you're conscious and in a healthy mindset is what matters most.
On the physical side, I'm curvier than most men and not the most masculine out there, and I also deal with body dysmorphia — when you have dysmorphia you really perceive yourself in the worst ways possible. I've told others and myself that just because I'm curvier or not the most masculine doesn't mean I can't be part of the 'men' label, and that perceiving yourself as ugly or fat doesn't mean you can't wear the things you want to.
I'm still in a weird position about identity: I'm not sure what I really identify with — all I can say is that I was born male.
I've become skeptical of certain trans-community claims. I wrote a post questioning the idea of HRT as a diagnostic tool, pointing out that people claim their brains 'were meant to run on that hormone' after a month, and asking whether that's just placebo from expecting bodily changes. I said I believe what the Gender Dysphoria Bible calls 'biochemical dysphoria' is pseudoscientific. I've also noted that many MTFs claim they 'got in touch with their emotions' on estrogen, when estrogen does that to anyone who takes it, and that FTMs report sudden energy and vigor they didn't have before — which I see as pharmacological effects, not proof of identity.
I've been reflecting on how focusing so much on one thing makes you numb and you can drift in any direction, and I related to someone else's search for a self that has to be 100% perfect. I don't currently identify as trans, and I don't identify as a woman; I'm in an uncertain place, working through OCD-driven rumination about gender rather than a settled sense of dysphoria.